A new roof is a rare purchase, and the covering is the part of it that faces the street for decades. It also carries the longest argument, because slate, clay, concrete and stone each answer a different question. One is about how the house looks, another about how heavy the roof may be, a third about the pitch the rafters already have, and a fourth about budget.
The sensible place to start is the roof you have now. The existing covering shows the load the structure was built for, the look the street expects and, on an older or listed building, the material the council will want to see again. Only then do we compare alternatives, with numbers from published sources rather than sales talk.
What follows looks at the four coverings in turn, quoting the lifespans, pitches and prices that third parties publish, and then at the approval rules that apply in each country. It belongs to our roof replacement service, with two related pages on approval for a heavier covering and on swapping slate for tiles in Wales.
Natural slate: Welsh, Spanish and reclaimed
Slate splits into thin, flat, dense sheets, and its published life is the longest of the four. HomeBuilding's table of approximate lifespans lists Welsh slate at 100+ years, Spanish natural slate at 75-100 years and reclaimed Welsh slate at 50-80 years. SPAB, writing about the border counties, thinks a well-slated roof will probably pass the 100-year mark. These are typical ranges, never a promise about one roof.
Origin shapes both the look and the bill. SPAB explains that Welsh slate today means rock from the north-west corner of Wales, where Bethesda and Blaenau Ffestiniog are still producing. HomeBuilding's supply-only prices show the gap, with Welsh slate at £185 per m² against Spanish at £72 per m². Both figures are for material by the square metre, so neither turns into a roof total.
On the roof, slate is laid so that every course bridges the joints beneath it. Cupa, a slate supplier, quotes 20 degrees as the floor for natural slate at moderate exposure, using a 500 mm slate lapped by 115 mm, as indicated by BS 5534:2014+A2:2018. Cupa also says hook fixings are off the table on any pitch below 25 degrees, so a low-pitched slope calls for nails.
Slate is the covering we reach for when the house already wears it. Matching what the building was designed to carry is the surest road to a roof that looks right, sheds water as intended and does not strain the timbers.
Clay plain tiles and pantiles
Clay tiles are fired from earth, and their colour comes from the clay and the kiln. In Herefordshire, the building stone atlas credits the Raglan mudstones as the clay source behind the county's old brickworks and tile works, and its Sites and Monuments Record lists some 250 brickworks, so clay has deep local roots.
For lifespan, Marley reports that the BRE fixed a minimum life expectancy of 60 years for clay roof tiles. That BRE figure covers clay only and does not stretch to other materials. HomeBuilding approximates clay at 60-80 years.
Pitch is where clay can box you in. Marley publishes a different minimum for each product, so the maker's sheet for the tile you pick is what counts:
| Product | Minimum pitch |
|---|---|
| Canterbury | 40 degrees |
| Ashdowne | 35 degrees |
| Hawkins | 30 degrees |
| Acme Single Camber | 30 degrees |
| Lincoln pantile | 15 degrees |
A pantile is an S-shaped clay tile that laps once, which is why it copes with a shallower slope than a plain tile. All five are Marley product names, not regional styles.
A plain-tile roof that has stood for generations carries the pitch it needs. A new product on the same rafters must meet its own limit, which is why a change of clay tile is checked against the slope before anything is ordered, and why the check happens before the survey photographs are even sorted.
Concrete tiles: heavier, and a lower supply price
Concrete tiles are moulded from sand and cement, in smooth or granular faces and many colours. They feature in HomeBuilding's main cost example: a 65 m² three-bedroom semi in plain concrete tiles may cost between £10,000 and £15,000, including labour, scaffolding and insulation.
Sources disagree on how long they last, so we give both. Marley puts concrete roof tiles at around 60 years, with the rider that this is not a guarantee or warranty of longevity. HomeBuilding approximates plain concrete tiles and Double Roman tiles at 40-50 years, and fibre cement tiles at 30-40 years. A band running from 40 to 60 years is as far as the published evidence goes.
Marley's minimum pitches for its concrete ranges run:
- Plain concrete tile: 35 degrees
- Double Roman, smooth: 22.5 degrees
- Ludlow Plus: 22.5 degrees
- Wessex: 15 degrees
- Mendip, smooth: 15 degrees
Those are Marley products and not local styles, so a tile is chosen only once its data sheet has been read against the real pitch of the roof.
Concrete is also the heaviest covering in a swap from slate. If the new covering raises the roof's loading by a significant amount, structural advice comes first. The section on rules below shows where the line falls on each side of the border.
Fibre cement slates and tiles sit between the two worlds: a slate look at a lower weight, with the shorter life HomeBuilding gives above. They suit a house that wants the slate profile without the full cost.
Stone tilestones: Herefordshire's own roofing
Stone roofs are the local material. The county's building stone atlas points to the sandstones of the St Maughans Formation as the main source of roofing stone, still worked by a small number of quarries, with numerous active permissions in the Golden Valley area, while Downton Castle Sandstone and the brownstones served as older tilestone sources. Flagstones from the Raglan Mudstone cover older cottages in Kington, and Longtown has its own flagstone roofs.
SPAB's advice note for the Welsh border counties adds that greys and browns dominate among stone slates in the region, though some Herefordshire stone is purple. It laments that so many roofs have been swapped for another stone, for natural slate or for a fake, and its advice on any claimed shortage or delay in supply is to ask the quarries.
For a stone roof, the pitch and the expected life depend on which stone it is, how thick it has been dressed and how the house sits in the weather, so they are settled with the quarry and on the roof, never from a general table. Stone is heavy, which matters for the timbers, and each tilestone is dressed to its place, which is why a stone roof is priced after a survey and not from a catalogue.
Where the existing roof is stone and a supply can be found, it is the covering to keep. Where supply is the obstacle, we ask the quarries for samples first, and show you what the alternative would look like beside the neighbours before you decide. The same stone turns up beyond roofs, in the plinths of timber-framed houses and the stacks that rise above them.
Weight, rules and matching on each side of the border
Changing the covering raises three separate questions: weight, planning and appearance.
- England, weight: the Planning Portal sets approval at a covering that is 15 per cent or more heavier, under the Building Regulations, while Approved Document A treats a load increase above 15% as significant.
- Wales, weight: the Welsh Government's re-roofing page uses slate to tiles as its illustration, saying approval is likely, so that stability, fire performance and energy use are all checked. Welsh Approved Document A also says more than 15%.
- England, planning: because Class C of the 2015 Order covers alterations to a roof, re-covering a dwelling counts as permitted development in the normal case, and a listed building needs consent as well.
- Wales, planning: Class C.2(a) of the 1995 Order asks for new roof materials to look like the old ones so far as practicable.
In a conservation area, check with the council whether an Article 4 direction applies. A house inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park should also check with the National Park Authority, since the Park Authority decides planning there while building control stays with the council.
Re-covering also brings an energy upgrade. In England, Approved Document L 2021 sets a new roof at 0.15 in Table 4.2 and, in Table 4.3, takes a renovated one worse than 0.35 to 0.16. In Wales, Table 4.1 sets a new roof at 0.13, and Table 11.1 sets 0.16 for retained roofs, with 0.35 as the worst acceptable figure.
What sets the price, and how to compare
Published costs vary widely, because roofs, coverings and access all vary. Which? (November 2025 survey, ex VAT) gives a whole new roof for the typical three-bed home as £7,000 to £21,000. MyJobQuote gives averages of around £5,250 for a new roof and around £7,800 for fitting a slate one. HomeBuilding's worked example runs £10,000 to £15,000 in plain concrete, and its Welsh slate version of that house might reach £18,000.
These sources measure different things, so they are shown as separate ranges and never averaged. What moves a real quote:
- the shape and area of the roof
- the covering and its supply
- how much timber must be replaced
- chimneys and valleys
- scaffold, and the insulation the rules require
To compare coverings fairly, ask for the same roof priced in each, on the same written terms. Then set the published lifespans against the price gap, and think about how long you mean to stay in the house.
Repair rates are a clue to material cost too. Checkatrade (June 2026, ex VAT) gives concrete tile repairs at £90 to £120 per m², clay at £110 to £160 per m² and natural slate at £150 to £220 per m², each on a rate that stops at 3 m². Those are repair rates for small patches, never a basis for a whole roof, and the order of the three materials is the only lesson to take from them.
Our survey records the pitch, the structure, the existing covering and what the council or building control will want. You then get one written total for the covering you choose. A worked example sits in what re-roofing a three-bed house costs.
