01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Replacement sequence

A roof replacement, stage by stage, from scaffold to sign-off

A new roof goes on in a fixed order, and each stage has to be right before the next begins. Here is that order, with England and Wales marked where they differ.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

From the pavement a roof replacement looks like a scaffold, a skip and a few weeks of noise. Up close it is a chain of stages, and each one leans on the one before. A covering depends on its battens, the battens depend on the rafters, and the rafters can be judged only once the old roof is off.

We lay the job out in the same order every time, because order is what keeps a house dry while its roof is open. Nothing is stripped that cannot be covered again before dark, and nothing is covered that has not been looked at first.

The six stages below run from first survey to last handover walk. At each we flag where England and Wales part company, since a Herefordshire address and a Monmouthshire address are not approved the same way. If you are still weighing a repair against a replacement, start with our main page on roof replacement.

Stage one: the survey and the written price

Everything starts up in the loft, torch in hand, and out on the roof with a camera. We look at the rafters, the wall plate that carries them, the battens, the underlay if there is one, the covering, and the lead around chimneys and walls. The aim is to learn what the old roof is made of before deciding what the new one should be.

You see the photographs. They are of your own roof, taken from inside and out, and they stay with the survey notes behind the written price. We put forward a replacement only when a repair would not do the job, and where a repair suits the house better, a repair is the recommendation.

The survey settles several things that change the work:

  • the covering on now, and what it would take to match it or replace it
  • whether the rafters, wall plate or battens need timber repair
  • whether any material looks like asbestos cement or a board product
  • the chimneys, valleys and abutments that need new lead
  • how the scaffold will stand, and whether it meets the highway
  • how rainwater leaves the roof, and whether the gutters can stay

For a sense of scale, the Which? November 2025 survey (ex VAT) gives "£7,000-£21,000" to re-roof an average three-bedroom house in full, and MyJobQuote gives an average new roof of around £5,250. Both are UK-wide figures from third parties, not a price for your house. You receive that price after the survey, for the job as a whole.

Stage two: approval and paperwork before the scaffold

Approval comes before the scaffold, because a replacement can be stopped half-way if the paperwork is missing. The rules depend on the country the house is in.

Approval tests for a re-roof, by country
QuestionEnglandWales
Building RegulationsThe Planning Portal: no application normally needed if work touches less than 25 per cent of the building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof, tested togetherThe Welsh Government: approval "in most situations"
Heavier coveringPortal: "15 per cent or more"Welsh Approved Document A: "more than 15%"
PlanningClass C, 2015 orderClass C, 1995 order, matching so far as practicable

In England, the heavier-covering line can catch any swap to a weightier covering. In Wales, the Welsh Government picks slate swapped for tiles as its example of a different material. Either way the structural check is what matters, so we record the rafters at the survey.

Under regulation 15(5) of the CDM Regulations 2015, the one contractor on a job owes a construction phase plan, and we write ours before the scaffold goes up. A listed house needs consent too: section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 in England, and sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 in Wales.

Building control is the council or a registered building control approver. Herefordshire Council Building Control is on 01432 261938. For addresses elsewhere we confirm the right building control service with you at the survey, and agree what goes into any application before the first pole is erected.

Stage three: scaffold, then the strip-out

The scaffold goes up first and stays until the last gutter is on. It gives the crew a safe platform and a way to carry slates and tiles without ladders. Where it stands on the street, a highway licence is needed (section 169, Highways Act 1980), and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. Licences have a page of their own: scaffolding for a roof replacement.

Before the first slate comes off, asbestos is ruled in or out. HSE says: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." It adds that "AC roofs are always fragile", so nobody walks on one. If a material looks suspect we stop work, and what follows is set out in what happens to the old roof.

The strip itself goes in a set order:

  1. Ridge and hip tiles come off first, and are stacked or skipped.
  2. The covering is lifted slope by slope, working from the top down.
  3. Battens and old underlay are removed.
  4. Lead is peeled back and kept if it is sound enough to reuse.
  5. Each cleared slope is covered with a temporary sheet before the day ends.

Waste comes down a closed chute to the skip, so nothing is thrown from height, and the skip stands on the drive where there is room for it. Only the slope being worked on is open. Once it is bare, the rafters can be examined end to end. You see a photograph of every defect before we replace any timber.

Stage four: rafters, underlay and ventilation

With the roof stripped, the timbers are checked in full. We look for rot at the foot of the rafters, damp at the wall plate, woodworm flight holes and any rafter that has dropped out of line. Repairs are made with new timber alongside the old, and what we replace is agreed with you first.

The underlay goes on next, and the type decides how the roof breathes. Marley's guidance on a high-resistance (HR) underlay: no vapour permeability, so the eaves need a continuous gap of 25mm at pitches of 15° or less, or 10mm above 15°. An air-permeable (LR) underlay is different: with a well-sealed ceiling, Marley's conditions let normal eaves construction supply the 3mm.

Underlay types and eaves ventilation, from Marley
UnderlayVapour-permeableEaves ventilation
High resistance (HR)No25mm at 15° or less; 10mm above 15°
Air-permeable (LR)Yes3mm normal eaves, under stated conditions

Battens go over the underlay, set to the gauge the covering needs. Marley points out that "Installing to BS 5534 isn't required by law", yet since the 2015 amendments mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering". We fix tiles and slates mechanically to the batten.

The insulation figure is set at the same stage. Where a roof element is newly fitted to an existing house, England's Approved Document L gives 0.15 in Table 4.2, and Wales gives 0.13 in Table 4.1. Our guide to insulation when you replace a roof explains the renovation figures, which differ again.

If the loft is to be converted now or later, mention it at the survey, because escape and insulation rules for a converted loft are separate from those for a plain re-roof.

Stage five: covering, ridge, verges and lead

Slates and tiles go on from the eaves upwards, one course above another, with the battens setting each gauge. The right minimum pitch depends on the product, so we check the data sheet for the covering chosen against the slope measured at survey.

Minimum pitches as published
CoveringMinimum pitchSource
Natural slate20 degrees, moderate exposure, 500mm slate, 115mm overlapCupa
Marley Mendip (smooth)15 degreesMarley
Marley Edgemere17.5 degreesMarley
Marley Plain35 degreesMarley

Below 25 degrees, Cupa rules out hook fixings for slate. On a stone roof we follow the laps and lie of the existing stone, and SPAB describes stone and Welsh slate roofs as predominantly double-lapped.

The ridge, hips and verges are the lines that meet the sky, so they are fixed with care. BS 8612 covers dry-fix systems, and mechanical fixing is the route Marley describes for these lines under BS 5534.

Lead goes in as the roof is covered, not after. Royston Lead's brochure lists Code 4 for soakers, flashings and pitched valleys, and Code 5 or 6 for flashings and for valley and parapet gutters. MyJobQuote says correctly installed lead flashing "can last for over 80 years", a hedged range for flashing and not a promise. Valleys get their lining before the courses either side are laid, so the lead sits under the covering and not on top of it.

Stage six: gutters, clearing up and sign-off

The last stage ties the roof to the ground. Gutters are fixed with a fall so water runs to the outlet, and Brett Martin gives the rule as "1mm for every 600mm". Fascias, soffits and downpipes are checked against the new eaves line, and any that were disturbed are refitted.

Then the scaffold comes down in reverse order and the site is cleared. We take away the waste, sweep the drive and clear the gutters of slate dust and nails. A magnet sweep of the lawn and drive catches metal the brush missed.

The sign-off has three parts:

  • A walk round with you, with photographs of the finished ridge, verges, lead and gutters.
  • Building control's inspection, where an application was made. In Wales that may be the council or a registered building control approver, and in England the same two routes apply.
  • The paperwork: the written price as agreed, and any building control record sent to you.

On lifespan, SPAB says a well-slated roof is "likely to be more than 100 years". For concrete tiles, Marley says "around 60 years" while HomeBuilding gives "40-50 years" for plain concrete tiles. Read these as typical ranges and not as promises; how long any roof lasts depends on the exposure, the fixings and later upkeep.

Roofs need looking at again afterwards. A short check of the ridge, valleys and gutters after the first autumn costs little and catches a loose fixing before a leak shows.

Stage by stage: your questions

Can the roof be left open overnight during a strip-out?

We work one slope at a time and cover each cleared slope with a temporary sheet before the day ends. The aim is that no bare rafters are exposed overnight. If the weather turns, we stop stripping and secure whatever is open before doing anything else.

Who decides whether my replacement roof needs building control approval?

Building control does, not the roofer. In England the Planning Portal gives a test on the envelope and the roof; in Wales the Welsh Government says approval is needed in most situations. We bring the survey photographs to the council, or to a registered approver, before work begins.

What if the survey finds rot once the roof is stripped?

Timber repairs are photographed and shown to you ahead of any being made, then added to the written price as a clear change. The rafters are checked at the survey from the loft, so a surprise is less likely, but a stripped roof shows what a torch cannot.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing