In brief
Normally yes, for a whole new roof. For England, the Planning Portal splits its test in two, and a small repair stays inside both halves: under 25 per cent of the building envelope affected, and under 50 per cent of the roof. A replacement covers most or all of the roof, so it falls outside. A heavier covering, 15 per cent or more, also brings Building Regulations approval in.
The two limbs of the exemption for small roof jobs
England's Planning Portal publishes the test for roof work, and it comes in two parts. A building regulations application is normally unnecessary when both of these are true:
- under 25 per cent of the whole building envelope is affected
- under 50 per cent of the roof is affected
Envelope is the portal's term for everything that separates inside from outside, from the walls and floor up to the glazing and the roof itself, counted as one. The first part therefore measures the house, and the second measures the roof by itself. Both have to be met. The portal says "normally", and we keep that word, because a job near either figure is a question for building control before any scaffold goes up. It is better asked early, while the scheme can still change.
A ridge, a flashing or a few tiles sits well inside both figures. A replacement roof does not. Building Regulations and planning permission are also two separate systems, so clearing one hurdle says nothing of the other, and each needs its own answer. If you are unsure which side of a figure your roof falls, an area worked out on the survey settles the question.
Why a replacement roof lands outside them
Stripping the whole roof and laying a new covering touches well over half of it. The roof limit is passed, and an application becomes the normal route. A house with several roofs is a different sum: re-covering one slope might stay under the figure. Hence the area is measured on the survey and the result written down, instead of being guessed at on the doorstep, and you can check the working yourself.
A heavier covering is the other trigger. The Planning Portal puts the line at a new material that weighs 15 per cent or more beyond the old covering, so any change of material is worth weighing before you order it. Approved Document A, the structure volume, words it as a loading increase above 15%, which it calls a significant change. Quote either one and name it. Both lead to a structural check of the rafters and the walls under them, and it is a Building Regulations step, not a planning one.
If the new covering is heavier than the old, our page on heavier roof coverings goes through what that check looks at and when it is asked for.
Energy rules and the consents beside the approval
Regulation 2 of the Building Regulations 2010 defines a thermal element to include roofs, along with walls and floors, and to leave out windows, doors and roof-lights. That is why Approved Document L, the energy volume, follows a re-roof, and our page on roof U-values in England gives the figures.
Other consents run beside the approval, and which ones apply depends on the house:
- Planning: swapping the covering on a house falls under Class C permitted development in the normal case, and Class C sets no matching-materials condition in England. Householder permitted development does not extend to flats.
- A listed house: listed building consent is needed as well, under section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990.
- A chimney breast: taking one out always brings Building Regulations approval, the Planning Portal says, because the Portal counts the breast as structure.
- A conservatory roof: the Planning Portal says a new roof there must comply with building regulations, so ask building control before ordering anything.
Mention any of these at the start, so the application deals with them together and nothing is found halfway through the job.
Who gives the approval, and what we do first
Building control is carried out either by the council or by a registered building control approver. A private approver must sit on the register held by the Building Safety Regulator. England's registration rules started on 6 April 2024, though private building control was around before that date. For a Herefordshire address, Herefordshire Council Building Control answers on 01432 261938, and elsewhere in England ask the district council which building control service covers your address, since some councils share one.
We begin with the roof. A survey measures the area affected and notes how the roof was built. You are shown pictures of what is wrong up there, and the price you get in writing is a single sum naming the covering and the approval route. Where a repair would solve the problem, the repair is what we recommend, since a new roof is only worth selling when it is the answer, and we tell you if that changes the approval needed.
The wider page on roof replacement shows how a job is run, and insulation when replacing a roof picks up the energy side.
