In brief
The answer turns on the kind of work. For England, Approved Document L 2021 gives a renovated roof an improved figure of 0.16 W/m²K, against a threshold of 0.35 (Table 4.3), and gives a roof element new to the house 0.15 (Table 4.2). Rooflights must reach 2.2, while a roof window is rated on its own scale: 1.4, or a WER (Window Energy Rating) of Band B. Building control confirms which table fits your roof.
Two tables, and which one a re-roof uses
A U-value measures heat loss: the energy that passes through one square metre of the roof when inside and outside differ by one degree, written W/m²K. The smaller the figure, the better the roof holds its warmth. For England the roof figures sit in Approved Document L, the 2021 edition with its 2023 amendments, which has applied since 15 June 2022. It states them in two places, and the table below sets them out.
| Work | Table | W/m²K |
|---|---|---|
| Renovated roof, threshold | 4.3 | 0.35 |
| Renovated roof, improved | 4.3 | 0.16 |
| New roof element in an existing dwelling | 4.2 | 0.15 |
A re-covered pitched roof is read against Table 4.3 and its target of 0.16, because the work renovates an element that is already there. The 0.15 of Table 4.2 belongs to a roof element that is new to the dwelling, such as a roof added with an extension. Quoting 0.15 for every re-roof mixes the two tables up, and building control confirms which one your job falls under before the price is fixed.
How a roof gets down to 0.16
The figure belongs to the whole build-up, never to a single layer. Insulation can go between the rafters, over them or beneath them, and each choice alters the depth of the roof, the ceiling height in the rooms below and the detail at the eaves, ridge and verge. Insulation over the rafters means lifting the old covering first, and the timbers under it are only fully seen once it is off.
So the survey does the groundwork. We look at how the roof was put together, photograph the rafters, the underlay and any insulation that can be reached, and talk you through the pictures. The insulation choice is then priced alongside the covering, inside the one written total. A flat roof follows the same logic: Approved Document L lists renewing the waterproof membrane as renovation, so a replaced membrane is judged against the renovated-roof figures.
Our page on insulation when replacing a roof goes into the choices in more detail, including what each one asks of the rest of the roof and of the rooms underneath.
When 0.16 cannot be reached
Some roofs cannot take the full upgrade, and paragraph 4.13 of Approved Document L exists for them. Two conditions open it up: the Table 4.3 improved figure is out of reach on technical grounds or functional ones, or the work would fail to repay itself within a simple payback of 15 years. In either case the roof goes up to the lowest practical U-value that still pays back inside 15 years. As a general guide, an upgraded element should end up no worse than 0.7 W/m²K.
This is a relaxation for a real obstacle, and the decision is taken with building control, not on the roof by the roofer. We photograph the obstacle in place on your roof, and the case goes forward with the survey attached, so the outcome rests on evidence rather than on argument across a table. If building control disagrees, the upgrade proceeds to the figure it names, and the written price is revised before work starts.
Our page on what to do if insulating the roof will not pay back takes England and Wales together, and sets the two tests side by side.
Windows in the roof, and the March 2027 edition
Glazing in the roof is kept apart from the roof itself. In England, Table 4.2 asks 2.2 of a rooflight, and 1.4, or a WER of Band B, for a roof window, a rating that scores glazing and frame together. The Building Regulations 2010 leave glazing, including roof lights, out of the thermal element definition, so the roof's own figure does not apply to a window, and each window is judged on its own rating.
A new edition is on its way. Approved Document L 2026 takes effect in England on 24 March 2027 for work that is not part of a higher-risk building. Its tables are renumbered 3.2 and 3.3, the roof, window and rooflight values stay as they are, and the payback rule is renumbered 3.14. Until that date the 2021 edition, with Tables 4.2 and 4.3, is the one in force, and a job started in the meantime follows it. Ask building control which edition it will apply to your application.
For the job as a whole, see roof replacement, and approval for a new roof in England for the application side. Once the survey is finished, a single written price follows.
