When a roof comes off, every layer between the weather and your ceiling is in plain view. That makes it the one realistic chance to add insulation without disturbing the rooms below, and the energy rules see it the same way. Part L, the section of the Building Regulations on saving fuel and power, reaches a roof whenever a re-cover is big enough to count as work on a thermal element.
The detail depends on the country. England and Wales publish separate approved documents, with different tables and different numbers for the same roof. Both speak in U-values, the measure of heat lost through a surface, where a lower figure means a better-insulated roof, and both allow a relaxation when an upgrade cannot be justified.
This guide sets out the figures, the way insulation and ventilation must work together under a new covering, and the point at which the rules give way. It belongs to our roof replacement service, with sister pages on U-values in England and U-values in Wales.
Why a new roof brings Part L into the job
Under regulation 2 of the Building Regulations 2010, a thermal element is a wall, a floor or a roof, and the definition keeps glazing, doors and openings in the roof out of it. Building work on a thermal element can carry energy duties with it, and a roof that is stripped and rebuilt is the plainest example. Pure repairs, such as replacing a few slipped tiles, are a different matter and do not bring the upgrade with them.
Two different tests hide behind the phrases new roof and renovation. A roof built from scratch on an existing dwelling meets the table for new fabric. A roof that is kept and partly renewed meets the table for retained elements, with a trigger that decides how much of it must be brought up.
The Welsh Government makes the point plainly on its re-roofing page: roofs count as thermal elements, which is why a re-cover should come with better insulation. In England, Approved Document L 2021 counts new waterproofing laid across a flat roof as renovation work, so flat-roofed extensions come into the same tests as the pitched slopes.
At the survey, that gives us four jobs:
- find out what insulation is already there, its position and its thickness
- decide whether the work is a new roof or a renovation, which depends on how much of the structure stays
- identify which approved document governs the address, the English one or the Welsh one
- agree the build-up with building control before the first batten comes off
Photographs of the loft and the existing layers arrive with the quote, showing exactly what changes.
England: Approved Document L figures for a roof
In England, Approved Document L 2021 took effect on 15 June 2022 and stays the guide until its successor arrives. Its tables set the figures, in W/(m²·K), against which building control measures a roof.
| Element | Table | Figure |
|---|---|---|
| New roof, existing dwelling | 4.2 | 0.15 |
| Rooflight | 4.2 | 2.2 |
| Roof window | 4.2 | 1.4 or WER Band B |
| Retained roof, renovation | 4.3 | 0.35 threshold, 0.16 improved |
Table 4.3 works as a two-step test. A retained roof worse than 0.35 should be upgraded towards 0.16 when it is renovated. A roof already better than 0.35 is left alone, even though the improved figure is lower still.
The 0.15 belongs to a roof that is new. A loft conversion or a renovation takes the retained-element route, which is why the right number for many re-covers is 0.16 and not 0.15. The figure of 2.2 is kept for rooflights alone, while roof windows are measured as windows are.
In a cold pitched roof, where insulation lies across the ceiling joists, a low figure means laying a thick quilt. In a warm roof or a room in the roof, rigid boards go between and over the rafters. We confirm the thickness for the product chosen, because manufacturers' conductivity figures differ from one board to the next. These table figures are limits for the finished roof, so the depth of insulation needed depends on the rafter depth, the product and the build-up, and we show the working to building control.
Wales: the Welsh Approved Document L
In Wales, the dwellings volume is the 2022 edition incorporating 2024 amendments, in force since 23 November 2022. It does not copy England's tables.
- In Wales, Table 4.1 sets a roof in an existing dwelling at 0.13, so a new roof must be better insulated than the English 0.15.
- In Wales, rooflights take 2.2 and roof windows take 1.4 or WER Band B, the same as England.
- In Wales, Table 11.1 covers retained pitched roofs, with insulation at ceiling level or between rafters, and flat roofs or roofs with integral insulation. Its figure is 0.16, with 0.35 as the limiting value.
- In Wales, paragraph 11.14 calls for the whole element to be improved where more than 50% of its surface is being renovated.
The notable difference is the role of 0.35. In England it is a threshold that decides whether you upgrade. In Wales it is the worst acceptable figure where 0.16 cannot be reached, so a renovated roof should hit 0.16 and fall no lower than 0.35 if that proves impossible.
In Wales, once work touches more than 25 per cent of the roof area, the Welsh Government's roof page says the roof insulation would normally need improving, and it puts smaller repairs outside the need for an application, normally.
For a house in Monmouthshire or Powys, building control sits with the council's service or with a registered building control approver. We make that check for you before the written price is finalised.
Where the insulation goes, and how the roof breathes
Insulation and ventilation are partners. Add more of one without thinking about the other and condensation can follow. For a cold roof, where insulation lies at ceiling level and the space above is ventilated, Marley sets out the eaves openings for a high-resistance underlay as 25 mm for pitches of 15° or less, and 10 mm for pitches of more than 15°.
The underlay type matters. High-resistance, or HR, underlay will not let vapour through, so those eaves openings are needed. Marley adds that an air-permeable underlay of low resistance, laid over a ceiling that is well sealed, can rely on the leakage of ordinary eaves construction, about 3 mm, so long as the UKAS certification conditions are satisfied.
The choices we put to you on a re-roof are typically four:
- a thicker quilt over the ceiling joists, keeping the roof cold and ventilated
- boards between the rafters, which keeps ceiling height but needs a clear air path
- boards over the rafters, a warm roof that changes the roof height and the fascia detail
- boards both between and below the rafters, for a room in the roof
Each has its own detail at the eaves, ridge and wall plate. A house that already has spray foam under the slope needs a separate look, covered on our spray foam insulation removal page.
Ventilation is dealt with at length in our answer on whether a new roof needs ventilating, and the survey checks the eaves and the ridge for the opening the build-up requires.
When the numbers cannot be reached: the payback relaxation
The energy rules do not ask for the impossible. Both nations allow a lower standard when the target is out of reach, but the wording differs.
- In England, paragraph 4.13 of Approved Document L 2021 covers a roof where the Table 4.3 improved figure falls short on technical or functional feasibility, or would take longer than 15 years to repay in simple payback. The upgrade is taken as far as it will repay itself within 15 years, and the upgraded element should generally not be worse than 0.7.
- In Wales, paragraphs 11.20 and 11.21 cover a roof where the Table 11.1 figure is not economic, functional or technical to reach. The target becomes the best standard feasible, generally no worse than the limiting 0.35, and the economic test is repaying the initial cost within 15 years through energy savings.
Typical cases where the relaxation arises are a loft space with no depth to spare, an eaves detail that would be blocked by more insulation, or a historic roof where extra thickness would alter its profile.
The decision is not ours. Building control, whether the council or a registered building control approver, accepts or refuses the argument, and we put it to them with photographs and measurements. The outcome is written into the quote, so nothing comes as a surprise on the day. For the full principle, see what if insulating the roof will not pay back?
Keeping a record matters too: ask for the building control sign-off and the insulation product's data sheet, as buyers and surveyors can ask for them later.
Roof windows, the next editions and what we confirm
Roof windows and rooflights have figures of their own in both countries, because they are not part of the roof element. Rooflights are held to 2.2 and roof windows to 1.4 or WER Band B, in England and in Wales. A like-for-like swap in an existing opening still has to reach the figure for the product, and the flashing kit must be the one made for that window and that covering.
New editions are on the way, and they affect work that starts later. In England, Approved Document L 2026 takes effect on 24 March 2027 for building work not connected with higher-risk building work, with the roof tables renumbered 3.2 and 3.3 and the payback rule moving to paragraph 3.14. In Wales, the new Approved Document L takes effect on 4 March 2027. Until those dates, the 2021 English tables and the 2022 Welsh edition are the ones in force.
Before any roof is stripped, we agree four points on paper:
- which approved document covers the address
- the U-value target for the build-up, and the product that reaches it
- the eaves and ridge ventilation that goes with it
- the building control body that will inspect, whether the council or a registered building control approver
The figure in your quote arrives once the survey is done and names the insulation it includes, so the thickness you are paying for is on the page, not left to the day.
