In brief
The guides disagree widely. Which? (November 2025 survey, excluding VAT) gives £7,000 to £21,000 for the whole roof of an average three-bed home. HomeBuilding (30 September 2025) gives £10,000 to £15,000 for a 65 m² semi in plain concrete tiles. MyJobQuote puts an average new roof at around £5,250. None of these is our price: yours is a single written total after a survey.
Four published figures, side by side
No single number is right for every three-bedroom house, because each guide counts something different. The table names each source with its date and basis, and no figure in it is ours. They are here so that a quote can be read against something. Patch-repair rates quoted per m² are left out too, because they describe a few square metres of repair and say nothing about a whole roof, and multiplying them up would mislead.
| Source | Figure | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Which?, Nov 2025 | £7,000 to £21,000 | Whole roof, average three-bed, excluding VAT |
| HomeBuilding, 30 Sep 2025 | £10,000 to £15,000 | 65 m² semi, plain concrete tiles, with labour, scaffolding and insulation |
| HomeBuilding | might reach £18,000 | The same property in Welsh slate |
| MyJobQuote | around £5,250 | Average new roof in the UK |
Which? built its figures from a survey of 11 Which? Trusted Traders. HomeBuilding notes that pay is greater in the capital and the south-east. None of the four is specific to Herefordshire or the Welsh border, so treat them as a rough frame and not as a quote, and expect a survey to move your own figure either way.
What moves a three-bed price up or down
A three-bedroom house can wear a roof of very different size and shape. One semi has two plain slopes, while its neighbour adds a hip, a rear extension roof and a chimney. On any roof, these things set the price:
- how large and how steep the slopes are, and how many valleys, hips and abutments they meet
- the covering chosen: concrete tile, clay tile, natural slate or something else
- the number and condition of the chimneys, and the leadwork around them
- the battens, underlay and any timber repair found when the old covering comes off
- the insulation the energy rules ask for, which England and Wales treat differently
- access and scaffold, including a highway licence where one is needed, which we arrange with our scaffolder
- taking away the old covering, including any asbestos found in it
Two roofs on one street can differ a good deal on that list alone, so a published figure is a starting point for questions, not an answer. Look at each quote for a statement on VAT and scaffold: is either left out? How a re-roof runs on site is set out in scaffolding for a roof replacement.
Concrete tile against Welsh slate
The covering is one of the few big choices that is yours to make. HomeBuilding costs the 65 m² concrete-tile semi at £10,000 to £15,000, and for the identical house in Welsh slate it says the figure could climb to £18,000. MyJobQuote separately gives £7,800 as its average for a slate roof, a number drawn from a different sample altogether.
Lifespans point the other way. They are indications rather than commitments, but HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate over 100 years, while for concrete tiles Marley says around 60 years and HomeBuilding says 40 to 50 years. A dearer covering can therefore cost less across a long life.
If your house already has slate, SPAB says to put any supply delay to the quarries themselves before accepting it, so a merchant's lead time does not push a slate house into tile. The survey also shows what the existing slates and battens will tolerate, which bears on the price of keeping the look. Our page on choosing a new roof covering compares the options in more detail, from clay to slate.
Rules that can add work to a re-roof
Approval is part of the job on a whole roof, and insulation comes with it: when a roof is re-covered, the energy rules ask for the insulation to be improved where that is feasible, and the survey notes what the roof already holds. In England, the Planning Portal normally asks for no application under 25 per cent of the building envelope and 50 per cent of the roof, while a whole new roof goes past the second figure. In Wales, Welsh Government guidance expects Building Regulations approval in most situations.
Weight brings in a structural check as well. In England, the Planning Portal draws that line at a covering 15 per cent or more heavier than what it replaces. In Wales, Approved Document A reads a loading rise of more than 15% as a significant change.
None of this arrives as a surprise bill. The survey records the roof, you are shown what we find, and you receive one written sum that says what is in it. See how many quotes for a new roof to compare like with like, or the main page on roof replacement.
