In brief
Normally no. The Planning Portal's test asks whether less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope is affected and less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected. Keep within both limits and no application is lodged for the job. A covering whose weight is up by 15 per cent or more brings approval in, and so does taking out a chimney breast. Near either limit, ask building control before work starts.
The two limits that decide whether a repair is exempt
The test comes from the Planning Portal, the government's planning service for England. It looks at two things, and both must hold for a roof job to go ahead without a building regulations application:
- less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope is affected, and
- less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected
Here the envelope is the shell of the house taken as one: its walls, floor and roof, with every window, door, roof window and roof-light. The first limit therefore guards the building as a whole, and the second guards the roof. Patching a ridge, replacing a handful of tiles or refixing a flashing falls well inside both.
The word "normally" is the Planning Portal's, and it is worth keeping. It leaves room for a repair that touches something structural. A good survey records the area involved and the fault found, so there is a written basis for the decision if building control asks for one, and a record of the roof before and after.
When a repair does need approval
Some situations take a roof job out of the exempt category, whatever the area, and the table sets out the three that matter most for a repair:
| Situation | What the source says |
|---|---|
| Heavier covering | Planning Portal: approval is needed once the new covering weighs 15 per cent or more above the old |
| Structural loading | Approved Document A (structure) calls a rise of more than 15% in the roof's loading a significant change |
| Chimney breast removal | Planning Portal: approval always applies to taking out a breast, since it is part of the structure |
The weight limit exists because a roof frame was sized for the covering it carries. If a heavier covering is on the cards, a structural check comes first, which is why our page on heavier roof coverings exists. Building Regulations are separate from planning permission, and being exempt from one tells you nothing about the other. Above the area limits, an application is the usual route and not the exception.
What the energy rules ask of a roof in England
In regulation 2 of the Building Regulations 2010, the term thermal element takes in walls, floors and roofs only, and windows, doors and rooflights sit outside it. Approved Document L (conservation of fuel and power) wants better insulation when one of these elements is renovated. Laying a fresh waterproof membrane across a flat roof is treated as renovation, so a flat roof is caught even though no tile moves.
Until 24 March 2027, AD L 2021 applies, and its tables give these roof figures, in W/m²K:
- Table 4.2, for a new roof: 0.15
- Table 4.3, for a renovated roof: a threshold of 0.35, improved to 0.16
- roof windows: 1.4 or WER Band B; rooflights: 2.2
Where 0.16 cannot be reached for technical or practical reasons, or the payback would be longer than 15 years, paragraph 4.13 lets the work stop at the best feasible figure, and generally no worse than 0.7. From 24 March 2027, AD L 2026 takes over, with the tables renumbered 3.2 and 3.3. Until then, the 2021 tables are the ones in force, and a quote that mentions insulation should say which figure it is aiming for.
Who decides, and where to ask first
Building control is done by the council or by a registered building control approver. Private businesses doing building control must register with the Building Safety Regulator, and the English registration regulations came into force on 6 April 2024, although private building control existed before then. For Herefordshire addresses, Herefordshire Council Building Control is on 01432 261938. Elsewhere in England, ask the council for your address which building control service covers it.
On the planning side, re-roofing is normally permitted development under Class C of the 2015 Order, and the English wording of Class C sets no rule about matching what was there before. Listing does not remove those rights, but a listed house needs listed building consent as well, under section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. Our guide to roof window planning in England and Wales sets out the planning conditions in full.
We measure the area affected on the survey, photograph what we find, and give one written total price. If the answer is a patch, you get a repair. If the survey points to a re-cover, we tell you, and the written price follows from that. Everything for repairs sits under roof repairs, and a house in Wales follows the page on repair approval in Wales.
