A valley is the trough where two slopes meet, and it drains the rain from both. Each shower sends the run-off of two slopes down that trough on its way to the gutter, so the lining at the bottom has to outlast the covering around it. The tiles or slates beside it are cut to a slant, and under those cut edges sits the real waterproofing: lead, GRP or a bed of mortar.
Cut edges, a hidden lining and a heavy flow make valleys fail in particular ways. Leaves and moss pack the channel, a lead sheet splits along a fold, a GRP surface cracks, a mortar joint lets go. A ceiling stain under a valley could mean any of them, and each needs a different cure.
Below we describe the three kinds of valley we repair on tiled and slate roofs, the way we find the fault, the choice between a patch and a new lining, and which approvals apply when a repair grows, either side of the border. The guide belongs to our roof repairs service, with sister guides on tracing a roof leak and on abutments, soakers and flashings.
How a valley is built, from the rafters up
A valley starts with timber. A diagonal valley rafter carries the ends of the common rafters from each slope, and boarding laid along it gives the lining a firm bed. Underlay from both slopes is turned onto that bed, the lining goes over the top, and the covering is trimmed to the slant of the valley.
How much of the lining you can see gives the valley its name:
- an open valley leaves a strip of lead or GRP showing in the gap between the trimmed tiles or slates
- a closed valley, also called a laced or mitred valley, buries the lining under cut tiles or slates that meet in one unbroken line
- a mortar valley bedds and points the cut tiles along the angle, with or without a lining beneath them
An open valley is the easy one to inspect, since the lining is in plain view through binoculars from the lawn. A closed valley looks like one clean sweep from the garden, but a fault stays out of sight until we lift the courses beside it.
Three details decide whether any valley keeps the weather out. The first is the width of the exposed channel. The second is how far the covering laps onto the lining at each side. The third is how the lining is held, because lead moves as the temperature changes and a sheet nailed hard along both edges can tear itself. A channel that is too narrow lets rain blown across it creep under the covering on the far side.
Lead valleys: which code, and where they split
Lead is the old-fashioned choice for a pitched valley lining. Royston Lead's cast-lead brochure sorts its sheet into six codes by thickness and colour, and gives each code lettered uses. Royston's key runs from A to E: soakers first (a soaker is a folded lead tab slipped under each course where a roof meets a wall), then flashings, then the pitched valley gutter that concerns this guide, and last the heavier parapet, box and dormer work.
| Colour | Code and thickness | Lettered uses |
|---|---|---|
| Green | Code 3 (1.32 mm) | only soakers (A) |
| Blue | Code 4 (1.80 mm) | soakers A, flashings B, valleys C, dormers E |
| Red | Code 5 (2.24 mm) | flashings B, valleys C, box gutters D, dormers E |
| Black | Code 6 (2.65 mm) | flashings B, valleys C, box gutters D, dormers E |
| White | Code 7 (3.15 mm) | valleys C, box gutters D, dormers E |
| Orange | Code 8 (3.55 mm) | valleys C, box gutters D, dormers E |
Royston marks Code 3 as "Recommended for lead soakers only", so Code 3 is out for a pitched valley, and Codes 4 to 8 all list pitched valley gutters. We confirm the code for a given valley against the maker's table before any sheet is ordered.
Lead gives itself away in three places: splits along the folds and laps, sheet that has crept downhill and gathered at the foot, and nail heads that have pulled through. MyJobQuote puts it this way: flashing in lead, if fitted correctly, can last for over 80 years. That hedged line concerns flashing, so a valley lining is judged on its condition when we stand on the roof, never on its age.
GRP valleys: cracks, lifted edges and blocked outlets
GRP stands for glass-reinforced plastic, also known as fibreglass. Layers of glass matting are set in resin and finished with a topcoat, so a valley lined this way is one continuous channel with no joint along its length. That suits a roof where lead would be awkward to form around the cut tiles.
GRP fails in ways that lead does not. We look for:
- fine cracks across the channel, sometimes over a board that has flexed
- a topcoat that has crazed, faded or worn down to the matting
- edges that have lifted from the board and let rain run beneath
- a blocked outlet at the foot, where the valley empties into a gutter or onto a lower roof
- a poor joint near the top where two pieces were run together
A crack or a worn patch can be cleaned back, keyed with abrasive and mended with new matting, resin and topcoat. A lining that has lifted across a wide area, or gone brittle from end to end, is better replaced, because new resin does not bond well to old resin that is failing.
Checkatrade (June 2026, ex VAT) gives GRP fibreglass repairs at £130 to £180 per m², on a rate that stops at a maximum of 3 m². That is a unit price for small areas, and it does not scale into a total for your valley, which gets one written price after the survey. For GRP roofing in general, HomeBuilding gives 25-30 years and Less gives 25 to 40 years. Both are typical ranges for the material, never a promise for one valley.
Closed and mortar valleys: cut tiles, bedding and fixings
A closed valley depends on the cutting. Each course is trimmed to the slant of the valley and fixed so that the cut edges meet in a clean line, with the lining out of view underneath. When the line is right, the valley reads as part of the slope. When one cut tile slips or cracks, the gap over the lining cannot be seen from the ground.
A mortar valley relies on bedding to hold the cut tiles. As a roof moves the mortar cracks, and once it has, rain can reach the lining below. Marley says that since the 2015 amendments to BS 5534, mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering", and that "Installing to BS 5534 isn't required by law". Mortar is not banned. For a valley, the lesson is that tiles cut along the angle want a clip or nail as well as a bed, since the heaviest flow runs there.
On a tiled valley the repair runs in this order:
- lift the cut tiles on both sides to expose the lining
- look over the lining for splits, lifting edges and debris
- mend or renew the lining as the inspection shows
- relay the courses, swapping any cracked tile and fixing each one
- re-point only where the bedding is sound enough to hold
On Herefordshire's traditional stone roofs, the same trimming is done in sandstone tilestones. SPAB says to test any claim of shortage or delay with the quarries, which matters when a valley repair needs matching tilestones.
Finding the fault: patch, re-line or rebuild
We begin in the loft with a torch, following the valley rafter for tide marks, damp battens and chinks of daylight. Outside, we clear the channel by hand, since leaf litter and moss hold damp against the edges of the covering. Clearing is done by hand and brush. With the channel clear, we photograph the lining, the laps and the cut edges and show you the pictures on the spot.
The choices that come out of the survey are:
- clearing and re-bedding, where the lining is sound and only the cut edges have slipped
- a patch to the lining, for a single split or one worn spot
- a new lining along the whole valley, with the courses lifted and relaid
- a rebuild of the boarding below, where timber has been soaked and has softened
What sets the price is the length and pitch of the valley, the number of courses to lift, the lining material and whether scaffold is needed to reach it. For orientation only, MyJobQuote (September 2026) prices patching the lead flashing on a chimney at around £200 and a full replacement at around £570, with full leadwork at £350 to £920, "depending largely on whether scaffolding is required". Which? (November 2025 survey, ex VAT) found renewing between one and six broken tiles at £75 to £400, a useful guide to the tiles beside a valley.
Our written figure is one total. Where a patch will do the job, that is the recommendation. Where the lining is failing along its length, the photographs show why patching would not last.
When a repair grows: which rules apply where
A lining patch is maintenance. Re-covering a large part of a roof is a different matter, and the test changes at the border.
- England: the Planning Portal sets the line at "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" together with "Less than 50 per cent of the roof", and, the Portal adds, a new covering heavier by "15 per cent or more" brings Building Regulations approval into play.
- Wales: the Welsh Government states that re-roofing needs Building Regulations approval "in most situations".
- Wales: where more than 25 per cent of the roof area is renewed or mended, the Welsh Government's roof page expects the thermal insulation to be improved as well.
- England: a listed house needs consent before changes that touch its special character, under section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990.
- Wales: sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 govern works to a listed house, in force since 4 November 2024.
A conservation area, a National Park or a National Landscape adds another layer, so ask the council before altering a valley that faces the street. Inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, check with the National Park Authority too.
Before work of any size, we ask the building control body for that address. Herefordshire Council Building Control is on 01432 261938. A Powys address goes to the council's building control service or a registered building control approver.
