01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Roof joints

Hips and valleys on tiled roofs: the joints that take the water

Hips and valleys are the angled joints between slopes of a tiled roof. Here is how each is built, how each fails and what a lead valley asks of the roofer.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

A plain slope is the easy part of a roof. The joints between slopes are harder, because the covering has to turn a corner without leaving a gap. A hip is the sloping line that stands proud where two slopes meet, like the edge of a pyramid. A valley is its opposite, a sunken line where two slopes drain into one channel, so it carries run-off from both.

That difference sets the risk. A hip sheds water, and its tiles tend to fail by slipping or losing their bedding. A valley collects water from two slopes at once, and it fails when its lining splits, lifts or silts up with moss and leaves. Both are cut work, with tiles trimmed to an angle, and cut work is where a roofer's skill shows.

The sections below set out how each joint is built, the lead codes used in valleys, what the view from the garden reveals, and the approval tests on the English and the Welsh side of the border. For the whole tiled roof, see our pitched roofing page.

Hip or valley: two angles, two jobs

People can use the two words as if they described one sort of joint. They are mirror images, and each has its own parts and its own way of going wrong.

A hip set beside a valley
FeatureHipValley
The angleOutward, a raised edgeInward, a channel
What it doesSheds water to both sidesGathers water from both slopes
Built fromHip tiles over cut slope tilesLead, a trough or laced tiles
Usual troubleSlipped or loose hip tilesSplit lining, blocked channel

When you stand in front of a house, the hips are the diagonal lines running from the ridge to the corners of a hipped roof, and the valleys are the sunken lines you can sometimes see where a back wing meets the body of the house. A dormer adds a pair of small valleys of its own where each side of the dormer meets the main slope.

On a simple hipped roof there are four sloping surfaces and four hips. Add an extension or a dormer and a valley appears wherever one roof runs into another, with a lead gutter hidden under the tile edges. These joints are the places we start at on a survey, because the same angle that makes them neat to look at makes them hard to seal.

A third joint belongs in the family. Where a lower roof runs up against a house wall, a stepped lead flashing takes the place of the valley, and the tiles beside it can suffer from a different fault, covered in our guide to nail sickness on a tiled roof.

Hip tiles and the foot of the hip

A hip is finished with hip tiles, which sit over the cut edges of the two slopes. Half-round and angled hip tiles are both made, and the choice follows the tile family on the roof. At the bottom of the hip a metal hip iron, a bracket screwed to the rafter, stops the lowest tile sliding off, because the weight of the whole run bears down on that one point.

The fixing is the same question as on the ridge and the verge. Traditionally hip tiles are bedded in mortar. BS 5534 is the code that covers how a covering is fixed, and Marley notes that the 2015 amendments "made it clear that mortar could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering". BS 8612 is the specification for dry-fix, which holds hip tiles with clips and fixings in place of a mortar bed. Marley also says "Installing to BS 5534 isn't required by law", so these are choices of method, and the choice rests on the tile in use and the state of the roof.

Signs a hip is failing:

  • a hip tile that has dropped or tilted along its run
  • cracked or missing bedding, with daylight or a dark gap under the tile
  • a hip iron rusted or pulled away from the rafter
  • cut tiles beside the hip that have slipped or cracked

A slipped hip tile can drop onto anyone below. Keep people clear of the foot of the hip, and let us look at it before anything is climbed.

Lead valleys and the codes that suit them

In an open lead valley a sheet of lead lines the channel, and the tiles either side stop well short of the middle, so a strip of metal stays in view. The gap between the two tile edges is set at the survey to suit the roof, because a gap that is too narrow clogs with moss and one that is too wide leaves lead exposed to the sky. It is an old and sound way of carrying water off two slopes, and it depends on neat work at the edges, where the lead is dressed beneath the tiles.

Lead is sold in numbered codes. These figures are from the Royston Lead brochure for cast lead sheet.

Lead codes and their listed uses, from Royston Lead
CodeListed usesmm
Code 3Recommended for lead soakers only1.32
Code 4Soakers, flashings, pitched valley gutters, dormers1.80
Code 5Flashings, valley gutters (pitched), parapet and box gutters, dormers2.24
Code 6Flashings, valley gutters (pitched), parapet and box gutters, dormers2.65

Code 3 is rated for soakers only, so it is not a valley lead. Codes 4 to 8 all list pitched valley gutters. Soakers are the folded pieces that sit with each course of tiles against an upstand.

On life, MyJobQuote says correctly installed lead flashing "can last for over 80 years". That is a hedged claim about flashing, not a promise, and a valley is only as long-lived as its fixing and the roof around it. The same site puts a patch repair to a chimney lead flashing at around £200 and a full replacement at around £570, with full leadwork between £350 and £920 depending on scaffold.

Laced valleys, valley troughs and tile valleys

Not every valley shows lead. There are three other builds, and an older house may have any of them under a layer of moss.

  • A laced or swept valley has the tiles themselves curved round the angle in courses, with no metal showing. It needs skilled cutting and is neat when new.
  • A valley trough is a pre-formed channel, of GRP (glass-reinforced plastic) or similar, laid in the angle with the tiles cut to its edges.
  • A tile valley uses special angled valley tiles made by the tile maker for that purpose.

Each is matched to the tile on the roof, and mixing makers is where trouble starts. Tile makers publish the lowest pitch for each product, and Marley's table runs from 12.5 degrees for one concrete tile to 40 degrees for one clay tile. Read the maker's own sheet for the exact tile on your roof, and never carry one product's figure across to another. A valley laid at a pitch below what its tile allows is a design fault no repair of the lining can cure.

If a valley is the cause of a leak, the repair depends on the build:

  1. Clear the channel of moss, leaves and silt by hand. Marley does not recommend high-powered jet washing for slate or tile, because it can damage the surface.
  2. Look for a split, a lifted edge, or tiles resting on the lining where they should be cut back.
  3. Judge whether a patch can hold, or whether the lining needs relaying.

Relaying means lifting tiles along both edges, which is why a valley repair may not be a small job. We photograph the opened valley so you can see what sat behind the tiles.

Reading hips and valleys from the ground

The garden gives a good first view. Pick a dry day, stand where both angles show, and bring binoculars if you own a pair.

On a hip, look for a straight line of tiles with an even gap on each side. A hip tile sitting lower than its neighbours, a sliver of bright sky underneath or a trail of mortar dust on the roof below is worth recording. On a valley, look for dark green or black streaking along the channel, plants rooted in the centre or a dip in the tile line on one side.

Inside, a stain can sit in the corner of a ceiling under a valley, or along a sloping line under a hip. A stain marks where water arrived, and that can be some way down the slope from the opening that admitted it. Our guide to whether to re-tile or repair shows how such findings weigh against the age of the whole roof.

A short note helps the survey:

  • the date and the weather when a drip first showed
  • whether it appears in any rain or only when rain is driven at the house
  • photos of the ceiling with a ruler for scale
  • photos of the roof angle taken from the ground in good light
  • whether the stain grows only after a long wet spell, which points to slow wetting and not an open gap

That note speeds up the visit, and your photographs sit beside the ones we take on the roof.

Approval tests in England and Wales

A repair to one hip or valley and the relaying of a whole slope sit on different sides of the approval tests, and the English test is a different test from the Welsh one.

  • In England, the Planning Portal sets the line for a normal exemption at "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" together with "Less than 50 per cent of the roof".
  • In Wales, the Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."
  • In England, the Planning Portal names a covering that adds "15 per cent or more" to the roof's weight as needing approval, while Approved Document A says "more than 15%".
  • In Wales, the Welsh Government's example of a changed covering is slate replaced by tiles, with approval described as "likely" to be needed. A hip or valley rebuilt in a new material falls into that thinking.

Where lead on a valley or abutment must be let into a neighbour's wall, section 2(2)(j) of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 lets the building owner cut into the neighbouring building for weather-proofing, as with a flashing. Notice goes from the owner to the neighbour in advance of the work, and for work to a party wall the Act requires it at least two months ahead. Questions go to a party wall surveyor, not building control.

Roof work in either country can disturb bats, which the law protects together with their roosts. Natural England licenses bat work in England, and Natural Resources Wales licenses it in Wales, so a roof with signs of bats is raised with the right body before tiles are lifted.

Hips and valleys: three questions

How can I tell a hip from a valley on my own roof?

Look at the angle. A hip stands up from the roof, like a spine running down between two slopes, and a valley sinks into it, like a gutter. If water would run away to either side, it is a hip. If water from two slopes would run together, it is a valley.

Is a lead valley better than a tile valley?

Neither wins every time. Lead suits some roofs, but a laced or tile valley can be right for the roof it was built with. We match the repair to the house, and the survey photographs show which build you have and what condition it is in.

Can a valley be repaired without re-tiling a slope?

Sometimes. A small split in the lining can be patched by lifting the tiles along the edge only. If the lead is thin, torn along its length or laid in the wrong code, relaying the valley is the sounder choice, and the photographs make the reason plain to you.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing