In brief
The valley is the sunken line where two roof slopes join, lined with lead and overlapped by the slates or tiles each side. It leaks at one of four places: a split in the sheet, an open lap or joint, a blockage that makes water back up beneath the covering, or rotten boards that no longer carry the lead. We trace which one, photograph it on your roof, and tell you plainly whether patching or re-lining suits it.
Where water gets past a lead valley
Rain from two slopes runs down into a valley, so it carries the run-off from both. The Royston Lead brochure lists Codes 4 to 8 for pitched valley gutters, which shows how wide a range of sheet thicknesses can be used. A valley fails in a handful of ways:
- the sheet has cracked, along a fold or at a nail hole
- a lap or joint has opened, so water passes under the upper sheet
- leaves, moss or tile fragments have dammed the channel, and water backs up beneath the edge of the covering
- the slates or tiles alongside the channel lap the lead by too little
- the boards under the lead have rotted and let it sag into a pocket where water sits
- the foot of the valley, over the gutter, has lifted or been bent
A valley carries more water than a flashing and can be walked on or blocked, so it is judged by its own condition. MyJobQuote's hedged line on lead flashing lasting over 80 years concerns chimney flashing, so it tells us nothing about a valley.
Reading the signs inside and out
A valley leak may not announce itself at the valley. Water follows the boards and the rafters, then appears on a ceiling some distance away. The line of a stain can still point back, because the valley runs from ridge to eaves at a set angle. These signs help:
- a mark on a ceiling or wall that lines up with the run of the valley overhead
- damp or dark timber on the boards or rafters directly below it, seen from the loft
- green growth or a bank of leaf litter along the line of the channel
- lead that is visibly cracked, lifted at a lap or dented where it has been trodden on
- a dip in the line of the valley seen from the ground, which can mean soft boards below
None of that proves the valley is the fault. A chimney flashing, a ridge or a slipped slate can send water the same way, and the survey looks at them too. We photograph the valley from the roof, and the boards from the loft where we can reach them, so you see what we see. The guide to lead valley gutters shows how a sound one is built, and the lead roofing hub shows where valleys sit among the other joints.
Patch, repair or re-line
The right fix depends on how far the fault has spread. One split in otherwise sound lead can be mended, and an open lap can be dressed back down if the sheet around it is flat and whole. A valley with debris in it needs clearing, and sometimes nothing more.
Re-lining is called for when the lead is cracking along its length, when the boards beneath have rotted, or when the covering either side has been cut back or bedded in mortar in a way that leaves no proper overlap. Re-lining means lifting the edge of the slates or tiles each side, replacing any bad boards, laying new lead and laying the covering back over it. It costs more than a patch, and we tell you when the patch is the better buy.
The page on repairing old leadwork covers splits and lifts in more depth. A bead of sealant along the lead tends to hide a defect without curing it, and the answer on mastic and lifted lead goes through why. When we re-line, the quote names the lead code for the valley, so you can check it against the Royston table.
Price, access and the rules on each side
MyJobQuote's published lead figures are for chimney leadwork, so none of them describes a valley. A valley has its own length, its own boards and its own access, and our figure is a single total written after the survey. It carries the scaffold and the clearing of waste.
Access matters because a valley can be between two slopes with no easy foothold. If the scaffold needs part of the public road, we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. To show how fees are set, in England Worcestershire County Council charges £85 per week, £65 for subsequent weeks and a £25 urgency surcharge. Every council along the border runs its own scheme.
On a listed house, relining a valley in a different metal or by a different method goes to the council first. The route in England is section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, and Wales has its own statute in sections 88 and 89 of the 2023 Historic Environment Act. If you hold a quote for a valley, check that it says whether boards are included, whether VAT is in the figure and what lead code is proposed.
