01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Metal roof corrosion

Cut-edge corrosion on profiled metal roof sheets

Rust that starts at a cut edge can spread under the coating of a profiled metal sheet. This guide covers where it starts, how we read it and the choices in England and Wales.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

A profiled metal roof sheet is a thin steel sheet, shaped into ribs or corrugations for stiffness and finished with a protective coating on its faces. The coating is applied to the sheet as it is made. Where a sheet is cut later, the steel at the cut is bare, and the coating that protected the faces does not cover it.

Cut-edge corrosion is the rust that begins at such an edge. It may not be dramatic at first: a thin orange line along a lap, a brown stain below a rooflight, a blister in the paint beside a cut. Left alone, it can lift the coating, open the sheet and let water into the building. Industrial units, farm buildings and warehouses carry large areas of metal sheeting, so a fault of this kind has a lot of edge to start from.

The sections below cover where the corrosion starts, what shows from the ground and from inside, what else looks like it, the choices for the sheets, and the safety points and rules in England and in Wales. The wider subject is covered on our commercial roofing page.

How rust starts at a cut edge

The coating on a metal sheet is a barrier. While it is whole, it keeps moisture and air off the steel beneath. At a cut, the barrier stops, and the steel is exposed to every shower and every drop of condensation that runs down the sheet.

Rust forms there first and then moves sideways, along the edge and in under the paint. It can creep under the coating from the edge, lifting it from within, so the damage reaches further than the visible mark. That is the main reason a small rust line at a cut deserves a proper look: the visible edge may be only the start of the affected area.

Edges exposed at the factory and edges cut on site both matter. The difference is that a cut made on the roof is made with less control. The cutting disc leaves swarf, which is fine metal dust and filings, and if swarf is left lying on the sheet it can rust and stain the surface around it. A clean cut with the filings swept away leaves the edge in a better state than a rough one.

Moisture lingers longest in places that stay damp: the overlap between two sheets, the underside of a ridge flashing, the line where a sheet meets a gutter. For that reason, the places where we expect trouble first are the places where the sheet is cut or folded and held against another surface.

Where the cut edges are on a unit roof

Every roof of profiled sheets has cut edges, and most of them are in a few predictable places. On our surveys we go through the list in turn:

  • the sheet ends at the eaves, where each sheet is trimmed to fit the line of the gutter
  • the laps along the length of the sheets, where the edge sits against the next sheet
  • the ridge, hips and verges, where sheets are cut to meet the flashing or trim
  • the openings cut for rooflights, vents, flues and plant
  • the edges around penetrations such as pipes, extraction fans and cable ducts
  • any sheet cut to length on site, because a standard length did not fit

Each of those edges has a different exposure. An eaves edge sheds water into the gutter, so the cut meets a steady flow. A rooflight opening has a cut metal edge that also meets the lining of the rooflight sheet beside it, and the junction can trap dirt. Around a roof-mounted fan, the cut can sit under a flashing that hides the corrosion until the stain shows below.

We map these edges on the survey drawing before we climb, so that each one is looked at in turn and none is missed. On a long roof that list is the difference between a repair that tackles one lap and a repair that tackles the cause.

Our guide to profiled metal roof sheets covers the sheet types, laps and fixings, and why the lap detail affects where water collects. On an older unit it is also worth checking what lies under the sheets, since the deck or liner can carry its own problems.

What shows without going up

Binoculars from the ground, and a walk round inside the building, show a good deal before anyone climbs. Start at the laps and the openings, since those carry most of the edge.

What the signs suggest and what we check
What you seeWhat we check
Orange line along a lapHow far rust has travelled under the coating
Blistered or flaking paint at a cutWhether the steel beneath has lost thickness
Rust streaks below a rooflightThe cut edge around the opening, and the flashing over it
Brown staining on the ceiling liningWhich edge or fixing above is passing water
Pinholes of daylight insideWhere rust has gone right through

Daylight inside is the clearest sign, since it means the metal has gone through. Dark patches on the liner or on insulation can mean water has been entering for some time, and a damp stain on stock or machinery below is a reason to ring us sooner.

Where possible we take photographs from inside along the line of the laps. They show the underside of the sheet, where corrosion can hide behind a coating that still looks sound from above. Those pictures reach you with the survey, labelled by bay and by lap, so you can walk the building and match each one to its place. A mark at the same lap in two bays suggests a shared cause, such as the way the sheets were cut. If a leak is already affecting the building, our guide to finding leaks on large commercial roofs sets out the method for tracing it.

When it is not cut-edge corrosion

Rust on a metal roof has more than one cause, and a repair aimed at the wrong one will not work. We rule out the other candidates before naming the problem:

  • rusting fixings, where the screw head or washer has corroded while the sheet is sound; our answer on why roof sheet fixings rust deals with that
  • condensation, where warm moist air from inside meets the cold underside of the sheet and drips; a separate answer explains why a metal roof can drip inside without any leak
  • debris and moss held in a lap, which keeps the area wet and can damage the coating
  • gutter overflow, which soaks the lowest edge of the sheet and the wall beneath it
  • damage from foot traffic, ladders or dragged tools, which scratches the coating through to the steel

Scratches matter because they act like a small cut edge, and a roof that has been walked on by earlier trades can show them in lines. A line of bare steel running along a sheet can corrode in the same way, though it has no relation to the original cuts.

Telling the causes apart is a matter of pattern. Rust that follows the laps and the cut edges suggests cut-edge corrosion. Rust that follows the lines of screws suggests the fixings. Dripping that appears on cold mornings with no rain suggests condensation. The survey sets the evidence side by side, and the photographs behind each conclusion are yours to check.

Treat, replace or overclad: the choices

Once the extent is known, the options come down to a short list, and which one suits depends on how far the corrosion has gone:

  • treat the edges, by cleaning back the rust and applying a protective coating, which can suit early and shallow rust
  • replace the worst sheets, where the steel has lost too much to be saved
  • overclad, meaning a new sheet over the old, where the whole roof is failing and the structure can carry the extra layer
  • replace the roof covering, where the sheets and the fixings are tired throughout

A repair that treats rust which has already crept under the coating can fail again at the same place, because the coating no longer sits on sound steel. Replacing a few sheets also raises the question of the sheets beside them, since new metal next to tired metal can leave the old laps exposed. We look at the neighbouring bays before we quote, and we tell you which ones we would expect to follow. That is a judgement the survey photographs help us make with you rather than for you. If the rust is early, treatment may be the sensible buy.

An overclad is a different project, covered in our guide to overcladding an industrial roof, and it needs a check on what lies beneath. An older unit may hold asbestos in its sheets or linings, so the HSE's rule applies before any work. Its page on whether asbestos is present says, "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it."

We recommend the least that will last, and a full replacement only where the evidence supports it.

Safety, rules and the job on site

Metal sheets are slippery when damp and may be weak where they have corroded, and rooflight sheets are fragile. Access is therefore planned before a repair, with edge protection, crawling boards or a mobile platform to suit the roof. The Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 give a lone contractor, in regulation 15(5), the duty of having a construction phase plan prepared before the site is set up.

If a job grows into re-covering, the Building Regulations come in, and England and Wales read them differently:

  • In Wales, the Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."
  • In England, guidance from the Planning Portal, written for houses, puts it that no application is normally needed where "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof" is affected. For a unit, ask the council's building control or a registered building control approver.
  • In both countries, regulation 2 of the Building Regulations 2010 treats a roof as a thermal element, which brings insulation into the discussion.

Scaffold or a platform that stands over the road is licensed under the Highways Act 1980, section 169. We arrange the licence with our scaffolder, and fee and notice period vary by council. Nests are protected while in use or being built, and bats are licensed by Natural England in England and Natural Resources Wales in Wales, so we look before sheets are lifted.

Pricing for a commercial roof follows the survey. One written total is what you receive, scaffold, waste removal and a tidy site included.

Cut-edge corrosion: your questions

Can the rust at a cut edge simply be painted over?

Only if it is early. Paint over rust that has already crept under the coating tends to lift again at the same place. We clean back to bright steel where treatment suits, and you see photographs of the edge from us first, so you can see whether treatment or replacement is the better buy.

How much of the damage can I see from the ground?

Binoculars show orange lines along laps, blistered paint at cuts and streaks under rooflights. From inside, daylight through a sheet or brown staining on the liner points to rust that has gone through. Neither replaces a survey, because the underside of a sheet can hide the worst of it.

Does replacing corroded sheets need Building Regulations approval?

The answer turns on the extent of the work and on which country the unit stands in. For Wales, Welsh Government guidance expects approval for re-roofing in most situations. In England the Planning Portal's test is written for homes. For a unit, we check with the council's building control or an approver before work starts.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing