01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Asbestos cement roofs

Asbestos cement sheet roofs on industrial units

A corrugated sheet roof on an older industrial unit may be asbestos cement. This guide sets out how to treat it, what the HSE categories mean, where the waste goes and what differs in Wales.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

Corrugated cement sheets covered the roofs of industrial units, workshops, farm buildings and warehouses for much of the twentieth century. Asbestos cement is a mix of cement and asbestos fibre, and in sound condition it is stable. The danger comes when the sheet is broken, drilled, scrubbed or smashed, because that releases fibre into the air.

The Health and Safety Executive gives owners a simple starting rule: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." It also says plainly that "AC roofs are always fragile", which makes a roof of this kind a falling hazard as well as a dust hazard. Any work on the sheets therefore needs to be planned before a ladder goes up.

The sections below cover what a survey does first, the HSE categories of work, how waste is handled in England and in Wales, the choices for an ageing sheet roof, and how a job on a unit is organised. Roofs of this kind belong to our commercial roofing work, and each rule is labelled by country.

Assume asbestos until a test says otherwise

A sheet cannot be identified by eye. Fibre cement sheets made without asbestos look much like those made with it, and weathering, moss and paint hide the surface. For that reason the HSE's advice is to begin from the assumption, not from a guess, and for a unit built or refurbished before 2000 that means treating the roof as asbestos cement.

What this changes in practice:

  • nobody walks on the roof, and nothing is dragged across the sheets, until the survey says how to reach them safely
  • sheets are not drilled, cut, broken or pressure-washed
  • moss is left alone, because brushing or scrubbing a sheet disturbs its surface
  • a sample is sent for analysis if a definite answer is needed before work is priced

The roof is only one part of the building. Under the eaves, white soffit panels may be asbestos insulating board, a different material, and the HSE location list names "AIB white soffit panels to underside of roof eaves". Board of that kind is dealt with differently from the sheets, as the third section explains.

An answer on assuming asbestos in a unit's roof covers the question in brief. On a commercial job we write down what the survey assumed and why, and you receive that note with the photographs. If a sample is taken, it is cut and sealed by someone trained to do it, never snapped off with a bar.

It also helps to gather what the building already holds before we visit: an asbestos register if one exists, any earlier survey, and the date of the last roof works. A register that names the roof sheets saves a visit. One that is silent about them does not mean they are clear.

Fragile roofs: before anyone walks across the sheets

The HSE's own guidance on asbestos cement roofs says they are always fragile. A sheet that carries a person's weight on one visit may give way on the next, and a fall through a unit roof onto a concrete floor is the most serious risk on the job, ahead of the fibre.

That is why the first look is taken from below or from a safe platform. We use the loft or the underside of the roof where there is one, ground-based photography with a long lens, and a mobile platform or scaffold at the eaves when the edge must be seen close up. Rooflights are a particular worry, since an old rooflight sheet can look the same as the sheets beside it and carries far less weight. Our guide to fragile roofs and rooflights deals with them in full.

The planning for the work is set by the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015, regulation 15(5): where one contractor works on the project, the contractor must draw up a construction phase plan, or arrange for one to be drawn up, before setting up a construction site. In a business building the client is a business, not a domestic client, and the HSE's definition of a domestic client is a person who has work carried out at their own home. So the transfer of a domestic client's duties in regulation 7 does not describe a unit.

The plan records who can go on the roof, how far, and with what edge protection and platforms.

Which HSE category the work falls in

The HSE sorts asbestos work into three bands, and the band depends on the material and on what will happen to it. The categories below come from the HSE, whose rules cover England and Wales alike.

HSE categories for work on asbestos cement and board
SituationCategory
Asbestos cement sheeting carefully removed without breaking up, including weathered sheets not otherwise substantially damagedNon-licensed work
Sheeting substantially damaged or broken up, or removal that would break the material up, such as dropping a roofNotifiable non-licensed work
Asbestos insulating board, other than short-duration jobsLicensed work

The HSE page on non-licensed work names asbestos cement products, "eg roof sheeting and rainwater goods", when they are lifted with care and not broken. The page on notifiable non-licensed work picks out damaged sheets and the case where removal "will mean that the material will be substantially broken up".

Most work on roof sheeting that is sound enough to lift whole falls in the first row. If the survey finds sheets in the second row, the work is notifiable, and it must be notified before it starts. Insulating board in soffits generally sits in the licensed band, and we refer that part of a job to a firm that holds the right licence. The question of licensing for asbestos cement sheets has its own answer, with a separate one for the notifiable category.

The band is decided by the survey, not by the contractor's preference, and it can change on the day: a sheet that cracks as it is lifted moves the job from the first row to the second. We therefore note the condition of the sheets in photographs before any work starts, so there is a dated picture of what the roof was like when we arrived.

Skips, consignment notes and carriers by country

Asbestos waste does not go in an ordinary skip. HSE guidance on carrying waste asks for a sealed skip, a lockable one for asbestos, and it does not accept sheeting thrown over an ordinary skip as enough. Sheets are wrapped or double-bagged, kept whole where possible and taken to a site that accepts asbestos.

The paperwork follows the country the waste starts in:

  • In England, a household's own hazardous waste is exempt from consignment notes "other than asbestos waste", and England divides waste carriers into an upper and a lower tier.
  • In Wales, Natural Resources Wales says "contractors moving asbestos from a domestic property will need to use consignment notes", and a business based in Wales "must register with us".
  • In both countries, a unit is a business premises, so the waste is trade waste and the household routes do not apply.

Herefordshire Council's household recycling centres at Hereford and Leominster accept asbestos only when it is double-bagged and the resident has booked, and Herefordshire Council states that no commercial or business waste is taken. Monmouthshire's household centres at Five Lanes and Llanfoist take small amounts from residents only. Those routes are for a householder's few sheets, not for a roof.

The lockable-skip rule has its own answer, on whether asbestos sheets can go in a skip, and the written price covers the waste being taken away.

Ask any contractor who quotes you for the carrier registration number and where the load is going, and keep the consignment paperwork with the building records. It shows, years later, where the sheets went.

Repair, overclad or replace: what the survey weighs

An asbestos cement roof does not have to come off the day it is found. The survey weighs the options against each other and shows you the evidence for each one:

  • leave the sheets in place and manage them, with a plan for who may go up
  • repair local damage without breaking the surrounding sheets
  • overclad, which fits a new sheet over the old, a choice our guide on overcladding an industrial roof explains
  • strip and replace, which is the answer when the sheets are failing across the roof

Replacing a roof covering also touches the Building Regulations, and the two sides of the border differ. In Wales, the Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." In England, the Planning Portal's test for a home is that no application is normally needed where "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof" is affected, which was written for houses, so on a unit ask the council's building control or a registered building control approver before the covering changes.

The roof counts as a thermal element under regulation 2 of the Building Regulations 2010, which is the same in England and in Wales, so insulation is part of the discussion. The dwelling tables in Approved Document L Volume 1 are not the ones for a business building, and building control will confirm the standard that applies.

We show you the photographs of what we find, and we recommend replacement only where the survey shows that nothing smaller will last.

Organising the job on a unit, and the price

A unit job has more moving parts than a house roof, and the order matters. The survey comes first, then the plan, then access, then the removal and the waste, and only then the new covering. Tenants, stock and machinery below the roof may need moving or protecting, and the people who work in the building need to know when the sheets will be lifted.

Where a scaffold or platform stands on the highway, a licence under section 169 of the Highways Act 1980 is needed, and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. The fee and the notice period depend on which council covers the road, whichever side of the border it is on, so the scaffold date can hang on the council as well as on the weather.

The other thing to expect is a nest. Birds' nests are covered by section 1 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 while occupied or under construction, in both countries, and the offence needs the act to be done "intentionally". Bats are licensed by Natural England in England and by Natural Resources Wales in Wales, so a barn-style unit with gaps under the eaves gets a look before sheets come off.

On cost, the price for a commercial roof only follows a survey, because the area, the access, the condition of the sheets, the building below and the route for the waste all differ from unit to unit. You are given a single written total that has the scaffold, the waste and the tidy-up in it.

Unit roofs and asbestos: your questions

How can I tell whether my unit's roof sheets contain asbestos?

You cannot tell by looking. The HSE's rule is to assume asbestos wherever a building dates from, or was refurbished, before 2000. A sample analysed by a laboratory is what confirms it, and until then the sheets are treated as asbestos cement and nobody goes on the roof.

Is it safe to walk on a sound-looking asbestos cement roof?

No. The HSE says asbestos cement roofs are always fragile, and age, moss and weathering hide how weak a sheet has become. Work is done from a platform, from below or with proper edge protection, never by stepping across the sheets, and nobody else should go up either.

Where do the old sheets go once they have come off?

They are wrapped, kept whole where possible and carried in a lockable skip to a site that can take them, with a consignment note as trade waste. In England and in Wales a business roof is not a household load, so the household recycling centres are not used.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing