A chimney has two halves. Below the roof it is part of the house, with the breast, the flue and the fireplace. Above the roof it is a free-standing tower of brick or stone, taking wind and rain on every face. Rebuilding above the roof line deals with the second half only: the shaft comes down to a level where the masonry is firm, the flue is left alone and the stack is built up again to its old height and pattern.
It is a bigger job than repointing and a smaller one than removing the whole chimney. It comes up when bricks have frozen and flaked, when the courses have shifted, when a lean has started above the roof, or when a stack has stood open to the weather long enough that the mortar has gone from deep inside the joints.
The sections below cover where "above the roof line" begins, how to tell rebuilding from repair, what the planning rules say in England and in Wales, the steps in order, how a stack is matched, and the scaffold, neighbour and listed-building points. Our chimney repairs page sets the job among the other work on stacks.
Where the roof line cuts the stack
The roof line is where the shaft leaves the slope, and the lead flashing sits at that joint. Everything above the flashing is exposed to the weather and belongs to the roofer's side of the work. Everything below is inside the house and belongs to the flue and the breast.
A rebuild of the exposed part has a handful of layers to think about, and each one has to be dealt with in turn.
- The pots and the mortar collar at the top, which come off first and are put back last.
- The shaft: the brick or stone courses between the roof and the pots.
- The base of the shaft, where it passes through the slope and the lead tray and flashings dress round it.
- The flue lining or the bare flue inside, which stays in place and is protected while the courses come down.
Rebuilding stops at a level the survey chooses, where the masonry becomes sound again. That may be a few courses below the pots, or it may be down to the roof. The lower the line is set, the more of the original stack is lost, so we aim to keep every course that is firm and take down only what has failed.
The rest of the chimney below stays in place. Taking out a chimney breast in the rooms is another kind of work altogether, with its own Building Regulations route.
Repair or rebuild: reading the stack
A survey decides between the two, and the decision is made from what the masonry itself is doing. We start at the skyline and work down, photographing each face of the stack, then follow the shaft into the loft to see where the damp comes from.
| What we see | Repair may do | Rebuild is likely |
|---|---|---|
| Mortar | Soft or recessed joints on sound brick | Joints gone deep, bricks sitting loose |
| Faces of brick or stone | Light weathering | Faces flaking away, hollow when tapped |
| Line of the shaft | Straight and plumb | Leaning or bowing above the roof |
| Cracks | Hairline, at the joints only | Running through the bricks, or open at the corners |
| Pots and collar | Loose but the course beneath is firm | Top courses shifting under the pots |
A stack that leans cannot safely be pushed back into line, and our guide to a leaning chimney stack explains what the lean tells us. Repointing is the right repair where the units are good and only the joints have failed,.
If rebuilding is the better buy, the photographs show why. If repointing is enough, that is the repair we put in writing, and its total price is the smaller one. Either way the decision rests on what the masonry is doing, and a stack can be sound on one face and failing on another, so each face is read separately. A quick look from the ground can mislead, which is why the survey takes in the loft as well.
Planning on each side of the border
A chimney is treated differently from a roof covering in the planning Orders, so a stack rebuild is not simply "re-roofing" for planning purposes.
- In England, Class C of the 2015 Order permits other roof alterations, but condition C.1(d)(i) removes cover where the work "would consist of or include" the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney, flue or soil and vent pipe.
- In Wales, Class C.1(c)(i) of the 1995 Order takes out "the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney" in the same way, and C.1(c)(vii) takes out "the removal of a chimney from a dwellinghouse on article 1(5) land or within a World Heritage Site".
Article 1(5) land in Wales means a National Park, an area of outstanding natural beauty or a conservation area. The alteration and replacement wording applies in both countries; the removal wording is Welsh.
What does that mean for a rebuild? A like-for-like rebuild in the same bricks to the same height reads as a repair in everyday speech, yet the wording above covers alteration and replacement, so whether your project sits inside or outside the permitted class is a question for the council. Ask before work starts, and ask in writing so that the reply is on record. For a house in a conservation area or a National Park, the question matters more, and the council or the National Park Authority is who to put the question to.
Our answer to does rebuilding a stack need planning keeps the question short, and a rebuild that adds a new flue or changes the height is more clearly a planning matter than one that copies what stood before.
The steps of a rebuild, in order
The order of work protects the house below as well as the new masonry. A typical sequence on a stack of ordinary size runs like this.
- Survey and photographs: each side of the stack, plus the pots and flashings, with the level for the rebuild marked.
- Scaffold: a platform around the stack, with a covered way over the roof below and the garden cleared underneath.
- Dismantling: pots off first, then the courses one at a time from the top down, bricks or stone stacked and sorted for re-use.
- Protecting the flue: the opening is covered while the work goes on, so that debris does not fall into it.
- The base: the course at the roof line is checked, the lead tray and flashings are looked at, and loose or perished lead is renewed.
- Building up: courses are laid in a mortar chosen for the stack, plumb and in line, with the old pattern and bond kept.
- Top course and collar: a final course is laid, the pots are bedded in a sloped collar and the stack is allowed to cure.
- Clear-away: the debris goes, the roof is swept and the scaffold comes down.
The flashing at the base deserves a note. A rebuilt shaft sitting on tired lead leaks at the join, which is the very place a rebuild is supposed to make dry. Lead at the base is checked and renewed as part of the rebuild.
The length of a job depends on the size of the stack, the number of flues and the weather, because mortar must not be laid in hard frost or left to dry too fast in sun.
Matching the stack to the house
A rebuilt stack that looks new on an old house stands out for the wrong reasons. The aim is for it to look as if it has always been there, and that comes down to matching four things.
- Bricks or stone: the original units are re-used wherever they are sound, and replacements are chosen to match the colour, size and texture of the rest.
- Bond and pattern: the courses go back in the original bond, with any corbelling, banding or decorative detail rebuilt as it was.
- Mortar: a mix that suits the stone or brick and the age of the house, with the joint finish copied from the old work.
- Pots: the old pots are reset if sound, or matched if not, so the skyline stays as it was.
Take the timber-framed houses of Herefordshire. Their big outside stacks are "commonly of local sandstone" according to the county's stone atlas, so a rebuild with brick or a hard cement mortar would look out of place. The mortar has to suit the stone and the age of the house, and it is chosen at the survey.
Clay has a long local history as well, so reclaimed brick or a close new match can be sourced for a rebuild, and we take the original bricks to the supplier so they can be compared.
An old stack rebuilt in the wrong materials ages badly, and the repair that follows costs more than matching would have in the first place. The same care applies to the lead and the collar, which are made to suit the stack and not taken from a standard kit.
Scaffold, neighbours and listed houses
Three practical matters come with a rebuild, and each can set the timetable.
Scaffold comes first. A stack rebuild needs a safe platform, and a scaffold on the street needs a licence under section 169 of the Highways Act 1980 is needed. We arrange the licence with our scaffolder. The date for starting follows the licence, not the other way round.
Neighbours come second. Where houses are joined, a stack can sit on the party wall and serves both. Rebuilding the shaft may not touch the shared wall, but cutting into it for flashings or altering the breast below does. Under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, which covers both countries, the building owner gives notice, and at least two months' warning is needed when a chimney breast is to be cut away. Our guide to chimneys on a party wall sets out how that works.
Listing comes third. If the house is listed, rebuilding or altering a stack can need consent whatever the planning position.
- In England, section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 applies to works that would affect its "character as a building of special architectural or historic interest".
- In Wales, the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 sets the route: section 88 on authorising works and section 89 on the consent itself.
Ask the council before ordering materials, because a listed stack may be consented only on the original materials and pattern.
If a storm brought the stack down, your insurer should hear about it first, before anything permanent is done; keep the photographs and receipts.
