In brief
The roof is made good. Once the masonry is lowered to below the slope, the opening is closed with new timber, a fresh waterproof layer and a covering that matches its neighbours, and the old flashings go with the stack. Whether the job needs approval depends on the country and the address, so we check with the council before the first brick comes off.
From open hole to closed slope
A stack that rises through a pitched roof is built into it. Rafters and battens are framed around the masonry, and lead flashings, the strips of metal that seal the joint, run up each face. Lower the masonry to below the slope and every one of those details is left cut, exposed or redundant.
Closing the opening goes in a set order:
- The masonry is lowered in pieces, never dropped, and the flue openings are sealed so nothing falls into the house.
- The timbers round the opening are checked for rot or damage where water has run down the stack.
- New timber is fixed so the rafters carry the loads they carried before.
- A fresh waterproof layer, the underlay, is lapped under the covering above and over the covering below.
- Battens and the covering go back, laid to the course of the neighbouring tiles or slates.
Last, the ridge or hip nearby is checked, because a stack can stand close to one. We photograph the closed slope beside the old one so you can compare the two, and the loft side of the patch is photographed too, where the new timbers can be seen.
Matching the covering you already have
The patch is judged by eye from the lane, so the covering has to match. A roof of local sandstone tilestones needs stone to fill the gap, so the question of where matching stone comes from goes to the quarries before the work is booked. A clay or concrete roof needs tiles of the same profile and a close colour, and reclaimed tiles can blend better than new ones.
Slate is a matter of lap and gauge. Each slate overlaps the course below, and the patch must repeat the lap of the slope around it or it will not shed water properly. We lay the new covering to the existing lap and avoid squeezing a different size into the course. Where the old slates are thin or worn at the edges of the patch, the survey photographs show which ones are sound enough to keep.
In Wales, Class C asks that exterior materials "so far as practicable match the appearance" of the existing ones. In England, Class C carries no matching condition, but a listed house or a conservation area makes matching the sensible rule anyway.
What the regulations ask of the infill
In England, the Planning Portal sets the test: an application is not normally required where less than 25 per cent of the building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof is touched. Closing the opening where one stack stood is a small area against that test. The Planning Portal also states that "Building regulations approval will always apply when removing chimney breasts", so the breast below the roof is a separate question.
In Wales, the Welsh Government states: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." Its roof guidance adds that structural alterations need approval. We therefore check with the council's building control service or a registered building control approver before we start on the Welsh side.
| Point | England | Wales |
|---|---|---|
| Class C and a chimney | C.1(d)(i) excludes replacing one | C.1(c)(i) excludes replacing one |
| Removal on protected land | No separate entry | C.1(c)(vii) excludes it |
A listed house needs listed building consent in both countries, whatever the table shows. A rebuild above the roof line is a separate question again, set out in rebuilding a chimney above the roof.
Bats, nests, a shared wall and the total
Take the stack down at the wrong moment and you can disturb something living in it. Section 1 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 covers a bird's nest that is under construction or occupied, and to intentionally destroy one is an offence. Bats are protected too: Natural England licenses work that affects them in England, and Natural Resources Wales does in Wales. We look into the pot and the cavity from the scaffold before anything comes apart.
If the breast backs onto the house next door, the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 applies across England and Wales. Cutting away a projecting breast needs a notice served at least 2 months in advance, and the notice page says who serves it.
The price for the roof side forms part of one written total after the survey. MyJobQuote (03/11/26) puts the average cost of removing an entire stack with its breast at around £3,000 to £3,500. For the planning side, see chimney removal permitted development in England, and for the wider service, the chimney repairs hub.
