In brief
Yes. For England the Planning Portal is unambiguous: Building Regulations approval "will always apply", because a breast is "part of the building's structure". In Wales, Building Regulations are devolved and the Welsh Government issues its own approved documents, so we start with the council's building control service or a registered building control approver. Planning permission, listed building consent and a party wall notice are separate matters that may also be needed.
Why the Portal's answer is so firm
Most building questions get a "depends". This one does not. The Planning Portal says, for England, that approval "will always apply" when chimney breasts are removed, and it gives the reason in the same sentence: a breast is "part of the building's structure".
The reason becomes clear in the loft. A breast is more than a hollow for a fire. It can carry the weight of the stack above it, it may be bonded into the masonry beside it, and the floors and ceilings that pass close by may rest on it or be braced against it. Take it out carelessly and a stack that has stood for a century or more can lean, crack or come down onto the roof below, and the damage reaches the rooms underneath as well.
That is why approval comes before the work, not after, and why the work on a breast waits for it. Building control looks at how the load above will be carried once the breast has gone. It is a check on the structure of your house, made in advance, and it leaves a record for the next owner as well as for you.
Who gives approval in England and who in Wales
The route differs a little between the two countries, though the question is the same: who checks the structure?
| Country | Who can give it |
|---|---|
| England | The council's building control service, or a registered building control approver; approvers have been on the Building Safety Regulator's register since 6 April 2024 |
| Wales | The council's building control service, or a registered building control approver; the Welsh Ministers regulate the councils |
For Herefordshire addresses, Herefordshire Council Building Control is on 01432 261938. Forest of Dean Building Control is on 01594 812315, and Shropshire Council Building Control on 01743 258710. Monmouthshire County Council runs its own building control service; for a Powys address, ask the council's building control service or a registered building control approver. In both countries an approver or council needs the loft photographs before it can say what the application must contain.
Private building control existed well before 2024. What began in April 2024 was the register, not the option itself, so both routes have long been open to an owner who wants a choice.
Three other consents that may sit beside it
Building Regulations approval is the one that always applies to a breast. Three more may apply as well, and each has its own office:
- Planning. The roof class of permitted development leaves chimneys out: C.1(d) in England, and C.1(c)(i) in Wales, where C.1(c)(vii) adds a bar on dismantling a chimney at a house on article 1(5) land or a World Heritage Site. When the stack up above is to be dismantled too, put the question to the council.
- Listed building consent. Taking out a breast can affect a listed house's character, so LBCA 1990 section 7 applies in England, and sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 apply in Wales.
- A party wall notice. Cutting away a projecting breast on a party wall falls under section 2(2)(g) of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, and the owner serves it giving at least two months before the work, as section 3(2)(a) requires.
Questions about a party wall notice go to a party wall surveyor, not to building control. When the stack above the breast comes down as well, the English permitted development page and the page on removing a chimney in Wales go further into the planning side.
What we prepare before an application is made
You do not need drawings to open the conversation. A visit to the loft and the roof gives building control what it asks for first:
- photographs of the stack inside the loft, from the breast up to the roof timbers
- the height of the stack above the roof, and the material it is built from
- whether a fire or stove elsewhere in the house still draws through the same stack
- whether the breast is shared with the neighbouring property
- the condition of the masonry where it can be seen
With those in hand, the council or a registered approver can say what the application needs. It may have to show how the stack above is to be supported or taken down, because that is where the structural judgement lies.
If the stack is coming down, the chimney breast removal cost page sets out published figures, and our chimney repairs hub explains how a survey runs. You get a written price after that visit, and the approval is dealt with before the first brick moves.
