01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Choosing slate

Welsh or Spanish slate? Choosing natural slate for a Herefordshire roof

Both are natural slate, and either can go on a Herefordshire roof. They differ in lifespan, supply price and look, and the choice also depends on what is already on the roof.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

Natural slate is split from rock, cut to size and hung on battens, and the stone it comes from decides how long it lasts and how it looks. New natural slate comes from two sources here, the quarries of north-west Wales and those of Spain. A third option for an older roof is reclaimed Welsh slate taken from a building that has been stripped.

This post compares them on the points that decide a Herefordshire job: lifespan as published, the supply price, how well each matches the roof you have, and the pitch and fixing rules that apply to any natural slate. It also covers what changes when the house stands in Wales, where the wording of the planning rule matters.

The figures come from HomeBuilding and SPAB, named where they appear. Nothing here is a promise about your roof, which we would survey before we advised, so use the page as a fair side-by-side rather than a verdict.

What "Welsh slate" means

The SPAB's advice note for the region defines the term narrowly. Welsh slate now means slate from north-west Wales, cut in the belt that runs between Nantlle and Bethesda, with working sites at Bethesda and Blaenau Ffestiniog. So the label tells you where the stone was cut, not that it is old or new.

Spanish slate is quarried in Spain and sold in the same trade sizes, so the two are laid in the same way. They come in grey and blue-grey shades that look alike from the ground. Up close, the colour, the texture of the face and the sound they make when tapped differ a little.

Reclaimed Welsh slate is a third category. It is taken off an old roof, sorted and sold again. It carries the age of the roof it came from and the nail holes of its first life, so the quality of the batch matters more than the label.

Both new kinds come in graded sizes and thicknesses, and an order is made up to suit the roof, so it pays to settle the slate before the scaffold goes up. The three differ most in the figures below, and we set them out one at a time. Our slate pages carry a separate guide to reclaimed Welsh slate. Whichever you choose, the slate is only part of the roof. The battens, the underlay, the fixings and the lead round the chimney decide whether it reaches the lifespans quoted.

Lifespan as published

Lifespans are typical ranges, not commitments. HomeBuilding's cost guide, last updated on 30 September 2025, gives an approximate lifespan for each type of natural slate, and the SPAB adds a line about well-slated roofs.

Approximate slate lifespans as published
SlateHomeBuilding, approximate lifespan
Welsh slate100+ years
Spanish natural slate75-100 years
Reclaimed Welsh slate50-80 years

The SPAB's own estimate for a well-slated roof runs beyond 100 years, and it hedges that with the word likely. That describes the roof as a whole when it is laid well, and it does not rank one quarry above another.

Two things follow. A good Spanish slate roof is expected to last for generations, and the gap between 75 to 100 years and 100+ is narrower than the gap in price. And a reclaimed batch has a shorter range because it has already done its first life. Neither range is a promise for any roof. A published range describes sound slate laid on sound battens, and it leaves out frost damage, failed nails and poor workmanship, any of which can shorten a roof.

Neither figure says what will happen on a particular roof. A roof with sound slate but rusted fixings can fail in half the time, and one with good fixings can outlast its range. We read the nails and the battens from the loft as part of any survey, because the slate can outlive what holds it. The answer on how long Welsh slate lasts gives its range with the hedge attached, and a sister answer does the same for Spanish.

Supply price and what a whole roof costs

HomeBuilding's guide lists slate at supply only, per square metre, before any labour, scaffold or fixings. Welsh slate is shown at £185 per m² and Spanish at £72 per m². Both are supply prices, so they are not the cost of a roof, and we do not multiply either by the area of a house. The gap between them is real: the Welsh figure is the larger of the two by a wide margin.

For whole roofs, HomeBuilding prices a three-bedroom semi with 65 m² of roof in plain concrete tiles at £10,000 to £15,000, and says a Welsh slate roof on the same house "might reach £18,000". MyJobQuote, on a page dated 6 October 2026, gives around £7,800 as the average for a slate roof. The two guides differ widely, so we name both and treat neither as a price for your house. Where the roof is large the supply gap grows with the area, which is why the choice of slate is made before the quote and not after it.

What the gap tells you is where the money goes:

  • The slate itself, which is the part that differs between Welsh and Spanish
  • The scaffold, labour and underlay, which are the same whichever slate goes on
  • The battens and fixings, which are renewed with any re-slate
  • Lead work round chimneys and valleys, which depends on the house

Our written quote is one total after a survey, with the slate named. Ask any quote to name it, because "natural slate" on its own could mean either.

Matching the roof you already have

On a repair or a part re-roof, the first question is what is already up there. The SPAB warns that old roofs have often had the covering swapped: "Unfortunately, many are changed to different stones or even to slates or fake stone slates." Before you pick a slate, work out what you have, because a new batch laid beside the old can show as a patch.

Welsh border roofs are varied. According to the SPAB, double lapping predominates across Welsh slate and stone roofs. It adds that the stone slates of the region run from grey through to brown, with purple ones found in Herefordshire.

Herefordshire's own stone roofing comes from local sandstone tilestones, with the St Maughans sandstones around the Golden Valley named in the county's stone atlas as the chief source. Those are stone, not slate, and a swap to Welsh or Spanish slate changes the look of the roof.

For a house that has had slate since it was built, the choice is simpler:

  • Match the size, the thickness and the shade of the slate that is there
  • Hold a sample against the roof in daylight before ordering
  • Keep any sound slates removed from the roof, for repairs later

The SPAB also says "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries." If someone tells you the slate cannot be had, ask for the supplier's reply in writing. Our guide to re-slating in Wales and matching adds the Welsh side, and a surveyor's sample board makes the comparison easy.

Pitch, fixing and the approval rules by nation

Natural slate needs a minimum pitch, and the rule is the same whichever country it came from. Cupa, a slate maker, says BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 "also indicates that the minimum roof pitch for natural slate is 20 degrees in the case of a project situated in an area with moderate exposure and with a slate 500mm long and a 115mm overlap", and adds that hooks should be kept off pitches below 25 degrees. Our guide on slate pitch and headlap covers those conditions in turn.

On fixing, Marley says installing to BS 5534 "isn't required by law", yet notes that the 2015 amendments ended reliance on mortar as the sole fixing. We fix to the standard either way.

Approval works differently in each nation:

  • In England, the Planning Portal sets two limits, under 25 per cent of the building envelope and under 50 per cent of the roof, inside which an application is not normally needed. A covering that adds 15 per cent or more to the weight brings approval in.
  • In Wales, the Welsh Government's re-roofing page opens with "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval" and cites slate to tiles as a change of material.
  • In Wales, permitted development for re-roofing wants the new materials to resemble the old to the extent that is practicable, which matters if you want to move between Welsh and Spanish slate.
  • In England, Class C normally covers re-covering a house, though a listed house or a conservation area calls for a check with the council first.

Slate is heavy, so moving to a lighter or heavier covering raises structural points as well as questions of looks. These are raised at the survey, never after the quote.

Choosing between them for your house

There is no single right answer, because the advice depends on the roof. Use the points below to narrow it down before a survey.

  • For a house that has Welsh slate now, matching it keeps the look and avoids a patchwork.
  • For a roof being redone from scratch with a tighter budget, Spanish slate is the lower supply price, and HomeBuilding gives it a range of 75 to 100 years.
  • For a period house where appearance matters, ask for samples of each and look at them wet and dry.
  • For a repair of a few slates, reclaimed Welsh slate can match an old roof better than a new batch, subject to the quality of what is on offer.

None of these is a ranking. A Spanish slate roof laid on sound battens with the right fixings will outlast a Welsh one laid badly. What costs a roof its life can be the fixings, the underlay or a lead detail that was not renewed at the time, and not the quarry.

When we survey a slate roof, we photograph the slate, the nails, the battens from the loft and the lead, then give one written total with the slate named. If a repair beats a re-slate on value, the report says that. For the wider picture, see our slate roofing page, which covers every kind of natural slate job we take on across Herefordshire and the border.

Questions on choosing slate

Can Spanish slate be laid next to Welsh slate on one roof?

It can, but the two differ a little in colour and face, so a mixed slope may show a patch from the ground. On a Welsh address, the permitted development rule asks new materials to match the look of the old as far as practicable. A sample held up to the old roof in daylight settles it.

Is a longer lifespan a reason to pick Welsh slate?

Only in part. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate 100+ years and Spanish 75-100 years, and the SPAB says a roof that has been slated well can be expected to last more than 100 years. Those are ranges for the stone, and the nails, battens and lead decide how much of the range a roof gets.

Does re-slating need approval?

In England, the Planning Portal looks at what share of the building envelope and the roof is touched, and a heavier covering brings approval in. In Wales, the Welsh Government expects approval in most situations. Either way, we check with building control before work starts.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing