01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Welsh roof lights

Roof lights in Welsh conservation areas, National Parks and National Landscapes

Across much of Wales a householder can fit a roof light without a planning application. In a conservation area, a National Park or a National Landscape the answer reverses, and this guide shows why.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

The Welsh rules for roof lights have a sharp edge. For an ordinary house on ordinary land, the Welsh Government's householder guidance treats planning permission "to re-roof your house or to insert roof lights or skylights" as not normally needed. On one kind of land that stops being true. Within a conservation area, a National Park, a National Landscape or a World Heritage Site, inserting a roof light needs a planning application first.

That kind of land has a legal name, article 1(5) land, and it takes in some of the best-known places on the Welsh side of our patch: the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, the Welsh bank of the Wye Valley, and the conservation areas of the market towns and villages of Monmouthshire and Powys. A roof light that would be routine a few miles away can be a refusal waiting to happen if it is fitted without asking.

This guide sets out the Welsh rule as written, the places it reaches, who decides, the neighbouring rules on dormers and chimneys, and what to prepare. It deals with Wales only. The wider range of window work is on our Velux and skylight page.

The rule: article 1(5) land and Class C

Welsh householder rights sit in the 1995 General Permitted Development Order, as amended for Wales. Class C covers "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse", and condition C.1(d) carves out one case. An alteration that would include inserting a roof light into a roof slope is not permitted where the dwellinghouse stands on article 1(5) land, or in a World Heritage Site. Everything else in Class C carries on as before. The Welsh Government's summary says the same in plain words: roof lights "are not permitted" in conservation areas, national parks, areas of outstanding natural beauty or World Heritage Sites.

The Welsh Government's technical guidance defines the land as "land in Wales within a National Park, an area of outstanding natural beauty and an area designated as a conservation area". Its paragraph 9.7 puts the result plainly: "Where houses are located on article 1(5) land or within World Heritage Sites, roof lights are not permitted." The Order itself is on legislation.gov.uk.

Roof lights under Welsh Class C, by land
Where the house standsRoof light as permitted development?
Ordinary landYes, within the Class C limits
Conservation areaNo: planning permission needed
National ParkNo: planning permission needed
National Landscape (AONB)No: planning permission needed
World Heritage SiteNo: planning permission needed

Even on ordinary land, Class C sets limits. The alteration may not stand more than 15 centimetres proud of the slope, and may not finish higher than the highest part of the original roof.

Which parts of our patch the rule reaches

In the Welsh part of our patch, three kinds of land matter most.

  • The Bannau Brycheiniog National Park. Hay on Wye, Talgarth, Llanigon, Llanbedr, Llanvihangel Crucorney, Govilon, Gilwern and Clydach all sit inside it, so every house there is on article 1(5) land.
  • The Wye Valley National Landscape, which crosses the border. On the Monmouthshire side it takes in places such as Trellech, Llandogo and Mitchel Troy.
  • Conservation areas, designated under Part 4 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023. Monmouthshire County Council publishes appraisals for several of its areas, and the council holds the list for any address you are unsure of.

Who decides depends on the address. Inside the National Park, the National Park Authority is the planning authority, so a roof light application there goes to the Park Authority. Outside it, the county council decides, whether the house is in a conservation area or a National Landscape. A National Landscape names an area. It does not take planning decisions; the local planning authority for the address does.

On names: National Landscape has replaced Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) as the everyday label, while the Order and the Welsh Government's guidance keep the older term. The land is the same.

If you are unsure which land your house is on, ask the council before you order a window. Monmouthshire County Council has a Duty Planning Officer on 01633 644831, Monday to Friday, 10am to 2pm, for questions about whether a project needs planning permission. For an address inside the Park, check with the National Park Authority instead.

Dormers, chimneys and listed houses next to it

The same land brings other limits, and they are worth knowing before a design is fixed.

  • Dormers. Class B, which covers enlargements to a roof, does not apply on article 1(5) land. Condition B.1(g) excludes houses on that land and houses within World Heritage Sites, so a new dormer needs planning permission too. Our guide on roof window or dormer compares the two routes.
  • Chimneys. Class C.1(c)(vii) also withholds taking a chimney off the house on that land, or in a World Heritage Site.
  • Listed buildings. A listed house keeps Class C, but a roof light that changes what makes the house special as a listed building also needs listed building consent. Under section 88 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023, in force from 4 November 2024, works must be authorised under section 89.

Article 4 directions can narrow the rules further. The Welsh Government says that "Permitted development rights may also have been removed by an 'Article 4' direction" and that these are "most common in conservation areas". Check whether an Article 4 direction applies with the council, or with the Park Authority for a house inside the Park, before a design is fixed.

A new roof light has a Building Regulations side as well. On the Welsh Government's roof-light page, "Approval under the Building Regulations will generally be needed for the installation of a new rooflight". Planning permission and Building Regulations approval are two separate consents, and having one does not give you the other.

Re-roofing, matching materials and the energy figures

Re-roofing is its own question, and it can arrive alongside the roof light. Under Class C.2(a), "the appearance of the materials used in each element of any exterior work must so far as practicable match the appearance of the materials used in the equivalent element of the existing dwellinghouse". So a Welsh re-roof is normally permitted development where what goes on resembles what came off, and a change of look is a point to settle with the planning authority.

For the Welsh Government, slate replaced by tiles is the worked example of a different material; under the Building Regulations, approval is then likely, covering structure, fire safety and energy. In a conservation area or the National Park that change of look is also the sort of thing a planning officer will want to see, because the roofline is part of why the area was designated.

When a window is fitted, the energy standard applies.

  • Welsh Approved Document L, Table 4.1, covers a new fitting in an existing home: "Window or roof window" at 1.4 or minimum WER Band B, a roof-light at 2.2.
  • When a roof is renovated, Table 11.1 sets 0.16, and not worse than 0.35 where 0.16 is not feasible. A new roof in an existing home is 0.13 under Table 4.1.
  • A new Welsh edition of Approved Document L takes effect on 4 March 2027.

For a roof window, use the 1.4 window figure; 2.2 belongs to rooflights alone. Our guide to roof window energy rules goes through the split.

Applying: what to have ready

A planning application for a roof light on article 1(5) land is a small one, and a well-prepared one goes through more smoothly. Monmouthshire County Council says applications are submitted through the planning portal or sent to its planning team, and its Duty Planning Officer can say whether you need one. For an address inside the National Park, ask the Park Authority. For Powys, ask Powys County Council.

The photographs and measurements an application needs are the ones we take at the survey:

  1. the front, side and rear of the house, with the roof slope in view
  2. the position of the proposed window on the slope, measured from the ridge, eaves and nearest edges
  3. the window model and size, and the flashing kit that goes with the covering
  4. the existing covering and its condition, close up
  5. the listing status, if any, and the name of any conservation area

A flush-fitting window that sits close to the covering keeps the roofline cleaner than one that stands proud, and a position on the rear slope is less visible from the street. Neither guarantees consent, and the decision is the authority's.

We survey the slope, photograph what is there and tell you which kind of land the house is on. We do not decide the consent, and no window is ordered until the answer is back. The survey ends with one written price, and the site is cleared before we go. Our guide to new rooflight approval in Wales covers the Building Regulations half of the process.

Four common mix-ups about Welsh roof lights

Advice that travels across the border tends to arrive wrong. These are the slips to watch for, set against the Welsh position.

  • "Roof lights are permitted development." Only outside article 1(5) land and World Heritage Sites, and only within the Class C limits.
  • "A conservation area only restricts the front." The Welsh rule is about the house being on that land at all. Front or rear, the roof light needs planning permission.
  • "Any change of covering is permitted development." Class C.2(a) wants the appearance of the new materials to match the existing so far as practicable.
  • "Planning permission covers the window." It does not cover the Building Regulations approval a new rooflight generally needs, or the listed building consent a listed house needs.

A fifth point concerns timing. Planning decisions take time, and the covering, the flashing and the window are all ordered after the answer, not before. If a re-roof is planned in the same year, settle the roof light question first, so that the scaffold, the covering, the flashing and the window can be fitted in one visit and not two. A window ordered early can sit in a store for weeks, and a covering ordered before the answer may need re-ordering if the authority asks for a different look. Neither mistake is expensive to avoid, and both are tedious to put right once the scaffold is up.

Welsh roof lights: your questions

Can I fit a roof light in a house inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park without planning permission?

No. The Park is article 1(5) land, and Class C.1(d) of the 1995 Order does not permit inserting a roof light there. An application goes to the National Park Authority, which is the planning authority for addresses inside the Park. Building Regulations approval is a separate consent.

Does the rule cover swapping an old roof light for a new one?

The wording is about the insertion of a roof light. Whether a like-for-like replacement counts is for the planning authority to say, so photograph the existing window and its position, send both to the council or the Park Authority, and ask before ordering anything. A listed house needs listed building consent as well, whatever the answer.

Who decides a roof light application in the Wye Valley National Landscape?

The local planning authority for the address, which is Monmouthshire County Council for a house on the Monmouthshire bank. A National Landscape is a designation, not a planning body. The designation is what takes permitted development for roof lights away, in the same way as a conservation area does, so a planning application is needed.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing