The question of what a new roof costs gets very different answers because the published guides measure different roofs. One prices a house of average size, another a semi with a roof of 65 m² and plain concrete tiles, and a third averages whatever roofs came its way across the whole UK. A reader in Hereford is left comparing numbers that were never built to be compared.
This post sets out three guides with their dates, then looks at what moves the price of a new roof: the covering, the access, the chimneys and other details, the insulation the rules ask for, and the waste. It explains how the rules part company in England and in Wales where they change the work. It ends with what a single written total ought to state. None of the figures belongs to us.
A survey is what turns a range into a price. Until someone has been up on your roof and photographed what is there, every number below is a guide to scale and nothing more.
What three guides say a new roof costs
Each source states a date, but each also measures something different, so the table names the roof being priced. Which? gathered its figures in a November 2025 survey and says they cover labour and materials but leave VAT out. HomeBuilding updated its guide on 30 September 2025. MyJobQuote dates each page and gives no VAT basis.
| Source and date | Roof described | Figure |
|---|---|---|
| Which? (November 2025, excluding VAT) | A complete new roof for an averagely sized three-bedroom house | £7,000 to £21,000 |
| HomeBuilding (30 September 2025) | A three-bedroom semi, standard, with a 65 m² roof in plain concrete tiles, including labour, scaffolding and insulation | between £10,000 and £15,000 |
| HomeBuilding (30 September 2025) | The same property with a Welsh slate roof | might reach £18,000 |
| MyJobQuote (3 November 2026) | The average new roof in the UK | around £5,250 |
| MyJobQuote (6 October 2026) | The average slate roof, fitted | around £7,800 |
Read across the rows and the spread is plain. MyJobQuote's average of around £5,250 sits below the bottom of the Which? range, while HomeBuilding's slate figure sits inside it. None of them is wrong. Each answers a slightly different question.
One more thing to hold in mind: a figure for a new roof is for a typical job, and typical jobs are smooth. A roof with rotten battens, a chimney that needs rebuilding or a leaning gable can move well away from any average. That is not a reason to distrust the ranges. It is a reason to read them as a place to start.
Why the published figures disagree
It helps to ask what each number is the number of. The three guides above differ in at least these ways:
- The roof. Which? speaks of an average three-bedroom house, HomeBuilding fixes a 65 m² semi, and MyJobQuote averages whatever roofs its readers sent in.
- What is included. HomeBuilding counts labour, scaffolding and insulation in its range. Which? counts labour and materials.
- VAT. Which? excludes it, and MyJobQuote gives no basis, so those two cannot be added to or subtracted from one another with confidence.
- The date. They were gathered between late 2025 and November 2026, and material and labour costs move.
- The place. HomeBuilding points out that London and the South East pay higher labour rates, and none of the three is a Hereford survey.
The sensible way to use them is to see where a written total lands against the whole spread, and to ask about the gap if it is a wide one. A total near the middle of the Which? range for a three-bedroom house in concrete tiles is not alarming. A total far outside every range deserves a conversation about what the roof actually needs.
A three-bedroom house is the usual yardstick, but it covers a lot of ground: a gabled semi with one chimney and a hipped detached house with three are the same size on paper and different jobs on the roof. Say what is on your roof when you ask for figures, and the answer will be closer to your own.
What moves the price of a new roof
Once the headline is set aside, a few things decide where a particular roof falls. They push the price up or down, and the quote you hold is still a single total.
- The covering. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate at £185 per m² supply-only against £72 per m² for Spanish slate, and the choice also changes the weight on the rafters.
- The size and shape. Hips, valleys, dormers and a second storey all add slopes and joins to a roof.
- Access. A roof that can be reached from a drive is a different job from one behind a terrace, with the scaffold fitted to the house.
- Chimneys and lead. Flashings, soakers and the stack itself are renewed or checked as part of a re-roof.
- Roof windows and flat sections. Each opening needs its own detailing.
- Insulation and ventilation, where the rules ask for them, and the clearing away of the old covering.
- Timber. Battens are renewed with a re-cover, and any rafter or wall plate found rotten is dealt with while the roof is open.
Life expectancy is part of value as well as price, and it comes with hedges. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate as 100+ years and Spanish natural slate as 75-100 years. For concrete, HomeBuilding gives plain tiles as 40-50 years while Marley says around 60 years, so the two sources are named side by side. The BRE's 60-year minimum is for clay only, and Marley's figure is explicitly not a guarantee. These are typical ranges, never promises about a particular roof.
Rules that add to the work on each side
Re-covering a roof brings Building Regulations into play, and the border changes how. The rules affect the work and, in turn, sometimes the figure.
- In England, the Planning Portal sets a test of under 25 per cent of the total building envelope and under 50 per cent of the roof, within which no application is normally required. A whole new roof goes past both limits.
- In England, the Planning Portal says a new covering that weighs 15 per cent or more beyond the existing one brings approval in, and a structural check with it.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." It adds that a change of material from the original makes approval likely, and offers slate swapped for tiles as the example.
- In England, AD L 2021 Table 4.3 sets a roof U-value of 0.35 as the threshold and 0.16 as the improved figure for renovation, and paragraph 4.13 relaxes that where an upgrade cannot feasibly be done or would take longer than 15 years to pay for itself.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government notes that a roof is a thermal element in law, so re-covering "should also include for improving the thermal insulation properties of the roof".
The next editions of Approved Document L do not apply yet. In England the 2026 edition takes effect on 24 March 2027, and in Wales the successor takes effect on 4 March 2027. The current editions stay in force until those dates.
Our post on re-roofing rules in Herefordshire takes the English rules step by step. For a house in Wales, we check with the council's building control team before a quote is finalised, so that any insulation requirement is in the total from the start and not added later.
One written total price: what to ask for
A roofer who has surveyed your roof should give you one written total, with the covering named, the work described and the access dealt with. Put the questions below to every quote you collect, ours included. Our answer on how many quotes to collect for a new roof says how far to take the comparison.
- Does it say which covering, and in what grade or make?
- Does it say if a scaffold is included, and whether the licence for the highway is dealt with?
- Does it say whether VAT is in the figure?
- Are the chimney, the lead and the roof windows covered by it?
- Does it say who clears the old covering away?
On the licence, a scaffold on the highway needs one under the Highways Act 1980 section 169, and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. The councils set their own fees and notice, in their own units:
| Council | Fee | Notice |
|---|---|---|
| Herefordshire Council (England) | £167, lasting a maximum of 1 month, then £123 for each extra month | A minimum of 10 days |
| Monmouthshire County Council (Wales) | A £108 administration fee, and £27 per week to extend | At least 5 working days |
Sign the contract at home and the 14-day cancellation period of the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 runs the same way in England and in Wales. Read more about scaffolding for a roof replacement, and about the whole job on our roof replacement page.
What the survey adds that a guide cannot
A published range cannot see your roof. The survey can, and it is where a figure stops being a guess. It starts at the top, with the ridge line, the verge edges, the stack and the valley folds, since those details decide how much of a re-roof is straightforward. Then it moves down the slopes to the eaves and gutters, and into the loft to check the battens, the underlay and the roof timbers from underneath.
The survey produces photographs of your own roof along with a single written total. A new roof is proposed only where the survey shows one is needed, and where a repair would do, the quote is for the repair.
Two checks are worth asking about before any new roof goes on:
- Asbestos. HSE's line is that a building put up or refurbished before 2000 should be assumed to contain asbestos, and it warns that asbestos cement roofs are always fragile. A garage or outbuilding roof of that age should be checked before it is stripped.
- Wildlife. Birds' nests and bat roosts are protected, and a check at the eaves and ridge happens before the covering comes off.
The old covering and everything else that comes off the roof goes off site with us, and the finished job is left clean. If something unexpected is found once the roof is open, such as rot in a wall plate, you see the photograph and agree the next step before the figure changes.
