Re-roofing looks like one job and meets three sets of rules. Building Regulations ask whether the work needs an application and what insulation the new roof must reach. Planning rules ask whether the change needs permission at all. Heritage rules ask whether the house sits in a conservation area, or is listed, in which case the answers shift.
This post covers England only, which includes every Herefordshire address. It follows the order of the questions. First comes the Planning Portal's test for when a re-roof needs an application. Then insulation, under Approved Document L. After that come permitted development and Class C, then conservation areas, listed buildings and Article 4 directions, and finally what happens on site once the paperwork is settled.
This post is a map, not a substitute for asking building control. Use it to put the right question, and to spot a casual "you won't need anything" from a roofer that deserves a second look.
Does a re-roof need an application? The Planning Portal test
The Planning Portal's roof guidance sets out when Building Regulations bite on re-covering. In its words, no application is normally needed where "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope' (walls, floor, roof, windows, door, roof windows and roof-lights) is affected", and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected." Both conditions apply together.
| Question | Where no application is normally needed | Where approval comes in |
|---|---|---|
| How much of the roof is affected? | Less than 50 per cent | 50 per cent or more |
| How much of the building envelope is affected? | Less than 25 per cent | 25 per cent or more |
| How heavy is the new covering? | Weight rises by less than 15 per cent | Weight rises by 15 per cent or more |
The weight limit is a Building Regulations matter and never a planning one. A heavier covering loads the rafters and walls, so a structural check goes with the approval.
A whole new roof is past the 50 per cent limit on the roof, so it needs an application. A repair of a few tiles is well under them. The cases in between are where a call to building control earns its keep. Re-covering one side of a two-slope roof, for example, is exactly half of it, and half is not less than 50 per cent.
Herefordshire Council runs its own building control service. Herefordshire Council Building Control is on 01432 261938, and its email address is bce@herefordshire.gov.uk. We use the Planning Portal test above for Herefordshire addresses, and ask the council when a job sits close to a limit.
Insulation: Approved Document L, Table 4.3 and paragraph 4.13
Regulation 2 of the Building Regulations 2010 defines a "thermal element" as a wall, floor or roof, and leaves out the openings: windows, doors, roof windows and rooflights. A roof therefore falls under Approved Document L (conservation of fuel and power) when it is renovated. The 2021 edition, with its 2023 amendments, "takes effect on 15 June 2022 for use in England".
The figures are U-values, a measure of how fast heat passes through a roof. A lower number means a better insulated roof.
Questions worth putting to building control before the quote is signed:
- Which table covers this roof, given what is being replaced?
- Will the insulation sit above the rafters, between them or at ceiling level?
- Does paragraph 4.13 apply here, and who works out the payback?
| Case | Table | Figure |
|---|---|---|
| Renovated roof, the threshold | 4.3 | 0.35 |
| Renovated roof, the improved figure | 4.3 | 0.16 |
| Roof windows | 4.2 | 1.4 or WER Band B |
| Rooflights | 4.2 | 2.2 |
| A newly built roof on an existing house | 4.2 | 0.15 |
Table 4.3 is the one to read when a roof is re-covered: a threshold of 0.35 and an improved figure of 0.16. A loft conversion falls under the same table and the same pair of figures.
Paragraph 4.13 is the relaxation. It applies where reaching the improved figure "is not technically or functionally feasible", or "would not achieve a simple payback of 15 years or less". The work then goes as far as is feasible, to a figure that "can achieve a simple payback not exceeding 15 years". The paragraph adds: "Generally, a thermal element once upgraded should not have a U-value greater than 0.7W/(m2·K)".
Until 24 March 2027 these AD L 2021 tables apply. From that date AD L 2026 takes over, with the figures renumbered as Tables 3.2 and 3.3 and the payback rule at paragraph 3.14.
Planning permission: Class C and the roof
Planning is a separate test from Building Regulations, and for a house in England the answer can be short. It is also worth saying what Class C does not govern: it is a planning permission, so it says nothing about whether the roof structure can carry a heavier covering or whether the new roof meets the insulation figures above. Class C of the General Permitted Development Order 2015 (Schedule 2, Part 1) covers "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse". Re-roofing falls under it, so swapping one covering for another is normally permitted development. In England, Class C does not require the replacement to resemble the old covering.
The conditions that Class C does carry are about additions to a roof, such as roof windows. Our planning guide lays them out word for word under Do I need permission to fit a Velux window?, with the side-slope conditions in full.
Three points are worth keeping apart:
- Land under article 2(3) of the Order, which includes conservation areas, National Parks, National Landscapes and World Heritage Sites, removes permitted development for dormers under Class B. It does not remove Class C.
- A listed house retains Classes B and C, since neither excludes listed buildings, though consent for listed buildings is a second, separate requirement for works that touch its character.
- Flats have no householder permitted development rights at all, since the Order says a dwellinghouse "does not include a building containing one or more flats, or a flat contained within such a building".
For a flat, then, the council's planning team says whether permission is needed for the change. Owners of a house in a terrace face a different practical point: the roof is continuous, so a new covering has to meet the neighbour's at the party line, and a conversation next door saves trouble later.
Conservation areas, listed houses and Article 4 directions
Herefordshire Council's conservation areas page says: "There are currently 64 conservation areas in Herefordshire." They include Hereford's historic centre, and the council holds the designation dates in its own list. A conservation area does not stop a re-roof, and it does not remove Class C, but it does mean the council has an interest in how the roof looks.
The term to watch is Article 4. GOV.UK says: "An article 4 direction is a direction under article 4 of the General Permitted Development Order which enables the Secretary of State or the local planning authority to withdraw specified permitted development rights across a defined area." Such a direction can remove rights the Order would otherwise grant, so check whether one applies to your address with Herefordshire Council before you assume Class C protects the job.
For a listed house, section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 requires consent for works "in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest, unless the works are authorised". A change from stone tiles or slate to a different covering is just the sort of work that can change character. Our post on re-roofing a listed building in Herefordshire goes into it.
The Malvern Hills and Wye Valley National Landscapes reach into Herefordshire. These are designations rather than planning bodies, and the Malvern Hills team states that applications are decided by the individual Local Planning Authorities. Our answer on re-roofing in a conservation area sets out what to ask the council. The practical advice is the same in each case. Before you sign anything, ask Herefordshire Council in writing:
- whether the address sits inside a conservation area
- whether an Article 4 direction applies to it
- whether the house is listed
A written answer settles the point, and it protects you if the roofer's assumption turns out to be wrong.
What to expect on site once the rules are settled
With the paperwork clear, a re-roof follows a fixed order. A survey comes first, with photographs of your own roof. The one written total follows, naming the covering and the access. Then comes the scaffold, the strip, the re-cover and the clear-up. Our roof replacement page sets out the stages.
Some points that catch people out:
- The scaffold. When scaffold will block the pavement or road, Highways Act 1980 section 169 applies, and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. Herefordshire Council's fee is £167, valid for a maximum of 1 month, and £123 for each extra month, with applications due at least 10 days ahead.
- Asbestos. HSE advises assuming there is asbestos in a building constructed or refurbished before 2000, so garage and outbuilding roofs of that age are checked before they are touched.
- Paperwork on the client's side. Under regulation 7(1) of CDM 2015, the responsibilities of a domestic client move across to the contractor where there is one contractor only. Regulation 15(5) asks that lone contractor for a construction phase plan.
- Cancellation. If you sign at home after the survey, you have 14 days to cancel. An early start needs your request in writing.
When the roof is finished, file the written total, the photographs and whatever building control sent you alongside the deeds. A buyer's solicitor may ask for them years later, and a folder that is complete saves a search through emails and old envelopes. If the work changed the look of the roof in a conservation area or on a listed house, keep the council's written answer with the same papers.
Once the work is finished the debris is removed and the garden or yard is left tidy. If you are weighing up the choice between repairing and re-covering, the Planning Portal test above is the first question to answer.
