In brief
Two or three written quotes are enough. Fewer leaves you without a comparison, and more adds paperwork without adding information unless the quotes are for different jobs. What matters is that every firm prices the same roof, the same covering and the same scope, after a survey. Published guides disagree widely on what a new roof costs, so a single figure from a website tells you little about your own house.
How many is enough, and what makes a fair comparison
One quote tells you a price and nothing else. Two begin to show a spread, and three show whether one is out of line. Beyond three, each extra quote costs you a survey visit and a day of someone's time, and the added information shrinks, unless the quotes disagree about what the job is.
That last point is the real test. A comparison is only fair when each firm has been shown the same things and asked the same question. So give each one the same brief:
- the covering you want, or the choice you are weighing
- whether the chimney, the gutters and the roof windows are in the job
- any known problems, such as past leaks or sagging
Then ask each firm to survey in person, up in the loft and along the roof edges where it is safe to look. A price given over the phone from a photograph is a guess, and it cannot be compared with a surveyed figure. Our own order is survey, photographs shown to you, then a written quote that gives a single total.
Why published figures vary so much
Cost guides disagree, and the disagreements are large. They are not Hereford figures, and they are not ours, but they show the range you may see.
| Source | Figure | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Which? | £7,000-£21,000 | Entire roof, average three-bedroom house, excluding VAT (survey of 11 Trusted Traders, November 2025) |
| HomeBuilding | £10,000 to £15,000 | 65m² semi in plain concrete tiles, with scaffolding and insulation (30 September 2025) |
| MyJobQuote | Around £5,250 | Its UK average for a new roof |
HomeBuilding adds that the same house in Welsh slate could cost as much as £18,000. The gaps between these are wide, because each source measures a different thing: a different house, a different covering, a different list of inclusions. A quote for your own house will rest on your own roof, so read these figures as background and nothing more.
What sets your own figure is the roof's area and shape, the covering, the state of the timbers under the old one, and the access. That is why a survey is needed before any firm can name a price worth comparing.
What every quote should say
A quote you can compare tells you in writing:
- The covering by name and make, and the underlay under it.
- Whether VAT is in the total.
- Whether scaffold is part of the total as well, and who arranges any highway licence.
- The fixings used along the ridge, hips and verges.
- What happens to the old covering and the waste.
- Who deals with Building Regulations approval, and under which side of the border's rules.
- How extra work found under the old covering will be agreed.
On approval, an English address uses the Planning Portal's test: under 25 per cent of the total building envelope and under 50 per cent of the roof. A Welsh address starts from the Welsh Government's position: approval for a re-roof will be needed in most situations. A firm that cannot say which applies has not done the groundwork.
A quote that gives one total and names what it covers is easier to compare than one that leaves the scope to be guessed. Where two prices differ, look first at these seven points, and ask about them before you ask about the sum.
Your rights once you have chosen
Whichever firm you pick, some protections stand. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 s49, the roofer must work with reasonable care and skill. A contract agreed at your own front door has a 14-day cooling-off period, and the work can begin earlier only on your written request. A repair visit you asked for in an emergency falls outside the right to cancel.
If a dispute does arise, Citizens Advice runs the consumer helpline on 0808 223 1133, with a Welsh-speaking adviser on 0808 223 1144. The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 308, also obliges a trader to point you to any alternative dispute resolution on offer when you are dissatisfied with the outcome of a complaint.
Write down the date and the name of the person who surveyed each time, and keep every quote you collect, including the ones you turn down, until the job is signed off, so that you can see later what was and was not promised. For the whole subject, see roof replacement, with the cost of a three-bed re-roof and choosing a new roof covering alongside.
