Callout 1 of 3
Stone, slate and tile: what the 1934 inventory found
The Royal Commission on Historical Monuments walked Stoke Prior parish in the early 1930s. Its 1934 inventory grouped the parish's monuments 5 to 23 as two-storey, timber-framed buildings of the seventeenth century, roofed in stone, slate or tile. One sentence naming three coverings is a useful warning to a surveyor, and to an owner reading a quote. A repair that suits a tile slope can be wrong for a slate one, and wrong again for stone, so the first thing we do on a Stoke Prior roof is identify what is actually up there. Each slope is photographed for the report, with the covering noted, since a quote that treats stone, slate and tile alike has not looked closely at any of them. The eaves and the ridge are read as well, since a ridge bedded in mortar and a ridge fixed dry are repaired in different ways.
In the county's building stone atlas, the St Maughans sandstones lead the list of sources for the county's stone roofing slate, with quarry permissions still active out in the Golden Valley, which matters whenever a stone roof here needs matching. A tilestone's age says little by itself, so the survey judges each one on its condition. We read each one for delamination, which is the splitting of the stone into layers, and for slipped pegs or nails, and photograph the worst of them. SPAB says Welsh slate and stone roofs "are predominantly double-lapped", meaning every course covers the joint of the one below by a margin, and that there are "some purple types in Herefordshire".
When a stone or slate roof needs new material, SPAB's warning applies: "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries." We check with the supplier before telling you a match cannot be found. Reclaimed slate or stone can be the right answer for a patch. A full new covering is the right answer only when the battens, the fixings or the timber beneath have gone.
For a tiled slope we count cracked and slipped pieces course by course, then check the battens under any tile we lift. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate as "100+ years", and Marley says concrete tiles "are expected to last for around 60 years" while HomeBuilding gives 40-50 years. The photographs go in the report beside the findings. Our pitched roofing page explains how each covering is laid, from the first batten to the ridge.
Which covering is it?
How do you tell stone, slate and tile apart from the ground?
Stone tilestones are thick, uneven and irregular in size, with a rough edge. Slate is thin, flat and even, and tile has a visible camber or nib. A photograph from the lane, or a look from the loft at the underside of a slope, can settle it before we go up.















