Callout 1 of 3
Tile, slate or stone: naming the covering first
The Royal Commission's 1934 inventory of Herefordshire grouped monuments 4 to 21 in Kimbolton parish and, unless it said otherwise, described them as buildings of the 1600s, timber-framed, with roofs of tile, slate or stone. Three coverings in one line means a survey cannot assume. The first task on a Kimbolton roof is to name what is there, because the repair, the weight on the frame and the supplier all follow from that answer. Each covering also leaves a different pattern of wear under the surface, so we look at the underside from the loft as well as the top from the slope, and the report shows both views of any fault.
Stone needs the closest reading. Local sandstone tilestones are the traditional stone roofing of Herefordshire, and the county's atlas of building stone points to the St Maughans sandstones as the principal source. SPAB notes purple stone slates in Herefordshire among the usual greys and browns, so colour alone will not tell you the stone. Its advice is to put any story of shortage or delay to the quarries directly. That phone call comes before any talk of another material, since a substitute alters the look of the roof.
Tile and slate fail in familiar ways. A tile slides when its nib snaps or the nail rusts. A slate slips when its fixing corrodes or the slate cracks across. Moss and lichen collect on all three coverings. Marley does not recommend pressure washing a slate or tile roof, as the surface is easily damaged, so we brush and treat, and we photograph the surface before and after.
A roof repaired over the years can carry patches of different material: a run of tiles set into slate, say, or new stone beside weathered stone. We mark each patch on the photographs, because it shows where earlier repairs were needed and what the roof was repaired with, and that history helps decide whether the next job is a patch or a larger one.
Changing one covering for another alters the load on the frame. The Planning Portal puts the line at a covering that increases the weight by 15 per cent or more, and AD A, paragraph 4.4, calls an increase of more than 15% a significant change in roof loading. Either way, a structural check comes before an order. In a timber-framed house with a stone or tile roof, the frame is old and the survey says what it can carry. Our pitched roofing page covers re-covering in tile, slate and stone.
Three coverings, three checks
- Tile
- Nibs, nails and battens at every gap
- Slate
- Corroded fixings and slates cracked across
- Stone
- Weight on the timbers and the source of any match
Three coverings in one parish means the survey cannot assume.















