Callout 1 of 3
Slate, composition stone tiles and the hips between them
Slopes make up most of the roof area, and the list entries for Llantilio Crossenny describe more than one covering. For the Church of St Teilo, Cadw records slate roofs, with the spire the exception because it is covered in wood. For Weir House it records a hipped roof of twentieth-century composition stone tiles. Composition tiles are factory-made to resemble cut stone. A hip is the ridge-like line formed by two slopes turning an outward corner. Because each covering hangs on differently, our survey names what is up there before anything is lifted, and the photographs let you see for yourself.
Working down from the ridge, we read the slope course by course for slipped, cracked or missing pieces, then look at what holds them. Natural slates hang from nails or hooks, and a corroded nail can release a slate that is perfectly sound, so the fixing is checked as closely as the slate. Cupa, a slate supplier, reports that BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 indicates a minimum pitch of 20 degrees for natural slate, subject to moderate exposure, a 500mm slate and a 115mm overlap, and that hook fixings "should not be used on any pitch below 25º". Pitch therefore enters the conversation before a new slate is ever chosen.
Hips get a separate inspection. Capping is bedded in mortar, but Marley, a tile maker, states that after the 2015 amendments "mortar could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering". A rebedded hip here is fixed mechanically too, and we photograph the old bedding so you can see exactly what it had lost.
This village is in Wales, which changes the rulebook. Of re-roofing, the Welsh Government says: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." Where a repair or re-cover touches "less than 25 per cent of the area of a pitch or flat roof", that department's roof page puts the work outside the normal need for an application. On the planning side, re-roofing in Wales is normally permitted development when the finished roof keeps the old roof's look, as far as is practicable. Swapping slate for another material should be raised with Monmouthshire County Council first, and the planning guide for roof windows covers the wider planning picture.
Checked across each slope
- Slipped, cracked or missing slates and tiles
- Nails and hooks holding each slate
- Capping and its fixings along each hip
- Battens and underlay seen from the loft
- How the covering meets its neighbours
Before we name a covering for any slope, we read what is already on it.















