Callout 1 of 3
Clay ridge tiles and the Welsh rule on matching
Cadw's listing description of the Parish Church of St Eigon, Grade II (record 6623, designated 28 September 1961), describes a stone church with clay-tile roofs, machine-made for the most part. Our survey of a clay roof opens with the ridge, where the two main slopes meet at the top, capped either by tiles bedded in mortar or by a dry system screwed and clipped down. Each capping tile is pressed by hand and the joints are traced for gaps, and the hips and the end tiles at each gable get the same treatment. Rain reaches the top course once a ridge has gone out of bed, so the bare course is photographed before new bedding goes on.
Machine-made and hand-made clay tiles look different in the hand, in their edges, their colour and the way they sit, which is why a repair on a clay roof begins with the tile already there. Marley, the tile maker, says "Installing to BS 5534 isn't required by law", but that since the 2015 amendments mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering". BS 8612 is the specification for dry-fix. For the tile itself, Marley reports that the BRE set a minimum life expectancy of 60 years for clay, and HomeBuilding's table gives clay tiles 60-80 years.
Welsh rules lean on appearance. The Welsh Government says that if a roof is re-covered in a different material, with slate to tiles as its example, approval under the Building Regulations is likely to be needed for structure, fire safety and energy. In planning terms, Welsh permitted development asks that the new materials match the look of the existing ones as far as practicable. A clay roof re-covered in clay is the simplest case, and a change of material is the one to talk through first, with the loft open and the old tiles in view.
Re-covering also raises the insulation question, which the survey answers with the loft open. Welsh Approved Document L, Table 11.1, sets 0.16 for a renovated roof, and no worse than 0.35 where 0.16 is not feasible. Our roof replacement page explains how a full re-cover is planned, and the survey says first whether a repair would do the job.
Matching an old clay roof
Why does a Llanigon repair begin with the existing tile?
Clay tiles differ in make, edge and colour, and Welsh rules ask new materials to match the old as far as practicable. Identifying the tile first lets the repair sit with the roof instead of standing out from it.
On a clay roof the repair starts with the tile that is already there.















