Callout 1 of 3
Slate roofs, underlay and the air beneath them
Cadw's listing for Rock Cottage, Grade II (record 23829, listed on 27 July 2000), records only "Slate roofs". It is a useful reminder that a slate roof is more than its slates. Under them lie the underlay, a membrane that backs up the covering, and the battens, the timber strips the slates hang from. We read both from the loft and from the slope, because daylight through the boards and stained timber show a fault that the slates hide. Up in the loft, the underside of the underlay is checked for damp marks, and the battens for soft or darkened timber, with every mark photographed and located.
The air beneath matters too. Marley sets out the eaves gap for a cold roof under HR underlay: "25mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of 15° or less; 10mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of more than 15°." HR stands for high resistance, and Marley states plainly that such an underlay will not pass vapour, which leaves the gap to do the job. An air-permeable LR underlay beneath a tightly sealed ceiling can depend on "fortuitous ventilation at the eaves via normal eaves construction (3mm)", but only where the third-party certification requirements are met. A blocked eaves gap is therefore something we look for when a Gilwern loft feels damp.
Welsh rules govern any re-cover. The Welsh Government's page on re-roofing is blunt: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." Inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, the National Park Authority is the planning authority and Monmouthshire County Council keeps building control, so a re-cover can involve two bodies. We find out which questions apply to your address before the quote is written. A re-cover also raises the insulation question, because the Welsh Government says that "the work to re-cover a roof should also include for improving the thermal insulation properties of the roof."
Repair pays when the slates are sound and just a few have slipped. Fixed well, natural slate lasts: HomeBuilding lists Welsh slate at "100+ years", and SPAB says a well-slated roof is "likely to be more than 100 years". Our pitched roofing page explains how slopes, underlay and eaves work as one system.
The gap at the eaves
What is the gap at the eaves for?
In a cold roof with HR underlay, Marley gives 25mm along the eaves for pitches of 15 degrees or less and 10mm above 15 degrees, so air can move through the roof space and carry moisture out.
Daylight through the boards tells you what the slates are hiding.















