Callout 1 of 3
Tile, slate or stone: reading an Eardisley slope
Naming the covering comes first, because tile, slate and stone are each repaired in their own way. The Royal Commission's inventory of Herefordshire, published in 1934, recorded the monuments it numbered 6 to 68 in Eardisley parish, apart from any it noted separately, as 17th-century timber-framed buildings of two storeys, with "tile, slate or stone-covered roofs". Three coverings in one phrase are a reminder to check every roof for itself, and a covering may have been replaced after the inventory was written. So the survey lifts an edge, photographs the underside and writes down what is really there.
The covering sets the repair. Stone roofs in the county are laid with tilestones cut from local sandstone, and Herefordshire's stone atlas gives the St Maughans sandstones as the main source, with permissions for quarrying still recorded around the Golden Valley. When a supplier pleads shortage or a long wait, SPAB's guidance for this region says to take the claim to the quarries themselves. We follow that advice before suggesting any change of material, because a replacement that looks different changes the house.
Lifespans are ranges and never promises. For clay tiles, Marley cites a minimum life expectancy of 60 years from the BRE, a figure that applies to clay only. Marley expects concrete roof tiles to last "around 60 years", while HomeBuilding gives plain concrete tiles "40-50 years", so both figures sit side by side here. HomeBuilding puts Welsh slate at "100+ years" and Spanish slate at "75-100 years". A stone tile is judged on its own condition when we handle it, and sound ones are kept and rehung. Moss on a shaded face is cleared by hand, since Marley recommends against high-powered jet washes on tile and slate, which can damage the surface and shorten its life.
Swapping one covering for another carries consequences. If the replacement weighs 15 per cent or more above what it replaces, the Planning Portal says Building Regulations approval is needed, and AD A regards a rise of over 15% in the loading upon the roof as significant. A structural check therefore precedes any swap from slate or stone to a heavier tile. Our slate roofing page describes slate work in more depth, and every slope we open is photographed for you.
Noted on each Eardisley slope
- Which covering is actually on the roof
- How far each unit laps the next
- Cracked, slipped or missing units
- The batten and underlay beneath
- Moss and shade on the damp face
Three coverings are on record in this parish, so every slope is identified before it is priced.















