In brief
Slate is a layered rock, and a slate that flakes is coming apart along those layers. Age, stress around the nail holes, weather working into the stone and rough treatment such as hard cleaning or being stepped on can each start it. A flaking slate cannot be repaired and is replaced with one matched in size, thickness and colour. A few flaking slates are a local fault. Many across a slope suggest the covering is wearing out.
What flaking and splitting look like
Slate forms in thin layers, which is why it splits so cleanly into roofing slates. A slate that has weathered badly splits the same way, but where nobody wants it to.
The signs on a roof are specific:
- thin sheets peeling from the face or edge of a slate
- a slate that has lost its corner, or is chipped along the bottom edge
- a crack across the slate, running out from a nail hole
- a slate that sounds dull or soft when tapped, where sound ones ring
- fragments in the gutter that match the slates above
From the ground, a flaking slate can show as a pale or rough patch on an otherwise even slope. Up close, the face is no longer smooth. A split slate is broken across or along its length and may still sit in its course for a while, held by the slates around it.
The page on repairing a slate roof shows how a failing slate is replaced without disturbing its neighbours, and the signs above are what we photograph on the survey.
What can make old slates flake and split
No single cause fits every roof, and a survey looks for the one at work on yours. The ones that can bring on flaking are these:
- Age and weathering. Slate is long-lived, with HomeBuilding giving Welsh slate 100+ years and reclaimed Welsh slate 50 to 80 years, but nothing lasts for ever.
- Moisture working into the stone. A slate that holds water between its layers can be pushed apart when the water freezes.
- Stress at the nail hole. A slate hung by a corroded or tight nail can crack out from the hole.
- Rough cleaning. Marley does not recommend jet washing a slate roof, and says a powerful jet can cut a slate's expected life considerably.
- Foot traffic and impact from ladders, branches and debris.
The kind of slate counts as well. HomeBuilding separates Welsh, Spanish and reclaimed slate, and each ages in its own way. A reclaimed slate may already have lived a long time, so its remaining life is shorter, which is part of why the source is checked before it is reused.
Replacing flaking slates, or stripping the slope
A slate that has begun to flake is not mended. It is lifted and replaced, and a replacement is chosen for length, thickness and shade. A few such slates, scattered across a roof, are a local repair, held in place with a hook or a tingle where the old nails cannot be reused.
Where flaking spreads over a whole slope, the slates left in place are of the same age and have had the same weather, so replacing them one at a time only chases the problem. At that point the photographs go on the table beside the choice between patching and re-slating, and where patching wins on value we recommend it.
Which? gives £75 to £400, excluding VAT, for replacing broken or missing standard roof tiles in a small group. That is a figure for tiles, so it is a rough guide only, and slate replacements are priced after the survey. For a whole slate roof, MyJobQuote's page gives an average of around £7,800 for fitting one, and the guide to re-slating a roof sets out the work. Both are third-party figures, never our prices.
Rules for replacing slates in England and in Wales
A scattering of replacement slates is a repair. A full re-slate is re-roofing, and the rules diverge at the border.
- England: the Planning Portal's no-application test pairs under 25 per cent of the building envelope with under 50 per cent of the roof, and a handful of slates falls inside both.
- England: a new covering carrying 15 per cent or more extra weight triggers the Planning Portal's approval rule, as it could with any switch to a weightier covering.
- Wales: the Welsh Government's guidance asks for approval in most situations and singles out slate replaced by tiles as likely to need it.
Listing adds a further consent to either route: section 7 of the 1990 Act in England, and sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 in Wales. We check which applies before any slate comes off.
The slate roofing page covers the wider subject. The survey leads to a total price on paper, with the pictures attached. Between the photographs and that price sits the question you actually asked, which is whether these slates have years left. We answer it for your roof, not for slate in general.
