In brief
No, not while the slates stay where they are. The underlay, also called felt, is laid over the rafters and pinned beneath the battens, and the slates hang from those battens. To renew it, a slope is stripped, the sound slates are sorted and kept, new underlay and battens go on, and the slates are relaid. Slipped or cracked ones are replaced to match. It is done a slope at a time, so the whole roof need not be opened at once.
Where the felt sits, and why the slates come off
Underlay is a membrane stretched over the rafters, under the covering. It is a second line against wind-driven rain and snow that gets past the slates, and it carries any moisture that does reach it down towards the gutter. The battens, the timber laths that hold the slates, are nailed through the underlay into the rafters.
That layering is why the felt cannot be swapped with the slates in place. Slipping new felt up from the eaves is not possible, because the battens pin it down on every course. Cutting the old felt away from inside the loft would leave the battens and slates hanging with nothing beneath them.
A tear in the underlay found from the loft can sometimes be dealt with from the slope above it, by lifting only the slates that cover the tear. That is a repair to one place. It is not a renewal of the felt over the roof, and we say which of the two we are quoting for.
If the slates themselves are failing at the nails, the same strip gives a chance to deal with nail sickness at the same time.
How a slope is stripped and relaid
A slope-by-slope job keeps the house covered while the work moves across it. The order on a typical slope is:
- Take off the ridge, hips or verge pieces on that side and set them aside.
- Lift the slates course by course and stack them by size, so sound ones can be reused.
- Remove the battens and the old underlay, and look over the rafters beneath.
- Lay the new underlay, then new battens set to the gauge the slates need.
- Relay the sound slates, add matching ones where needed, and refit the ridge or verge.
Reclaimed slates are not all alike. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate 100+ years, Spanish slate 75 to 100 years and reclaimed Welsh slate 50 to 80 years, as typical ranges, so a mixed batch is sorted before it goes back.
Where lead meets the slope at a chimney or valley, it is lifted and dressed again with the slates, which is why the survey photographs the leadwork beside the felt. The same visit records the state of the rafters, because a damp or sagging timber is far easier to deal with while the slope is open than after it is closed.
Choosing the underlay: ventilated or breathable
Underlays are not interchangeable. The choice is between HR, which stands for high resistance and does not pass vapour, so the roof space needs ventilated eaves, and an air-permeable type that can manage on far less. Marley, a tile and slate maker, publishes the openings for a cold roof, one that has its insulation at ceiling level:
| Underlay | Pitch | Eaves opening |
|---|---|---|
| HR | 15 degrees or less | 25 mm along the eaves |
| HR | More than 15 degrees | 10 mm along the eaves |
| Air-permeable | Well-sealed ceiling | 3 mm from normal eaves construction, if third-party certification is met |
Slate is laid well above 15 degrees, so the 10 mm row applies to a slate roof with an HR underlay and a cold roof space. Cupa, the slate producer, works from a minimum of 20 degrees for a 500 mm slate in moderate exposure. The choice of underlay is made against the roof beneath and the insulation in it. The written quote names the product, so you can read its data sheet and see what the roof is being given.
Rules for relaying a roof, England and Wales
Lifting a slope to renew the felt counts as re-roofing, and the border changes what that triggers.
- England: the Planning Portal asks whether the work touches under 25 per cent of the building envelope and under 50 per cent of the roof, and where it does, a Building Regulations application is not normally needed.
- Wales: the Welsh Government's guidance says re-roofing will need approval in most situations, so a call to building control comes before the first slate is lifted.
- Wales: that guidance also asks for better insulation as part of a re-cover, because roofs rank as thermal elements.
The 2010 Regulations list roofs among the thermal elements in England and Wales alike, so a relay that opens a whole slope is the moment to ask building control about insulation. Our page on re-slating a roof shows the full sequence from first slate to last; the guide to repairing a slate roof covers the smaller jobs, and slate roofing sets it in context.
After the survey, one written total covers the lot, whether it is one slope or the whole roof.
