In brief
HomeBuilding lists fibre cement (Eternit) tiles at 30 to 40 years, an approximate range and not a promise. Natural slate is quoted far higher, from 50 to 80 years for reclaimed Welsh up to 100 or more for Welsh. On an older roof the opening job is identifying the material, because HSE advises presuming asbestos in a property built or refurbished before the year 2000. Nobody should drill, break or scrub the slates until that is settled.
The published range and what it compares with
Fibre cement slates are cement reinforced with fibres and pressed into thin slate-shaped tiles. They were made and fitted as a substitute for natural slate. Our page on natural or man-made slate sets out the trade between the two.
On lifespan, HomeBuilding's table puts fibre cement (Eternit) tiles at 30 to 40 years, and the same table prices other coverings against them:
| Covering | Range |
|---|---|
| Fibre cement tile | 30 to 40 years |
| Plain concrete tile | 40 to 50 years |
| Reclaimed Welsh slate | 50 to 80 years |
| Spanish natural slate | 75 to 100 years |
| Welsh slate | 100 or more years |
Sources do not always agree. Marley, a tile maker, describes roof tiles as lasting around 60 years, against HomeBuilding's 40 to 50 for concrete, and states that its figure is not a guarantee or warranty. Read every range as a typical life and nothing firmer. A well-fixed roof that gets looked after can beat the table, and a poorly fixed one can fall short of it, which is why the survey looks at nails, battens and condition as well as age.
On an old roof, asbestos comes before lifespan
For fibre cement that dates from the twentieth century, the question of asbestos has to be settled before the question of age. HSE's position on a building built or refurbished before 2000 is that asbestos should be taken as present, and its guidance calls asbestos cement roofs always fragile. No owner can tell by eye which kind of sheet is on the roof, and a slate that looks sound may still be hazardous to disturb.
So the rules for owners are plain:
- Do not drill, scrub, jet wash or walk on the slates.
- Do not snap one off to look at the break.
- Have the material identified before you rely on any quote for removal.
When our survey meets fibre cement of uncertain age, we stop at photographs and the identification step, and the written quote reflects whichever answer comes back. Our page on the asbestos survey before a re-roof covers the steps in detail, including how the waste is handled, where England and Wales part company.
Where a roof is certainly asbestos-free, it is treated like any other manufactured slate roof, and the rest of this page applies.
Repair, patch or replace as the slates age
A fibre cement roof ages slowly, and most of the signs can be photographed from the ground:
- slates cracked across, or missing a corner
- edges that crumble or flake
- a surface roughened by moss and lichen
- nail holes that have opened out, leaving a slate sagging in its row
One or two broken slates can be replaced if a match is found, and the questions of size and thickness are the same as on natural slate. Matching is harder here, since the product may have changed since the roof was laid. When the faults are spread over a slope, a new covering is the straight answer, and our guide to re-slating a roof covers that route.
For scale, HomeBuilding sets a 65 m² semi in plain concrete tiles at between £10,000 and £15,000, with the same property in Welsh slate possibly reaching £18,000. MyJobQuote gives an average of around £7,800 for fitting a slate roof. The sources differ widely, so they show a spread and not a price from us. A written total follows the survey, with a photograph of each fault, so you can set the pictures beside what you see from the garden.
Rules when the covering changes
Natural slate is one choice for a replacement, and its weight is set against the old covering. A heavier covering can bring in a structural check, so we look at the roof timbers before an order is placed. Approval works differently either side of the border:
- England: a replacement covering that weighs 15 per cent more or beyond brings Building Regulations approval, says the Planning Portal.
- Wales: the Welsh Government's page on re-roofing expects Building Regulations approval in most situations, and names slate swapped for tiles as one such change.
For a smaller job, such as swapping a few slates, neither of those is likely to arise, but we check the position for your address and note it on the quote.
Walking the roof is a risk of its own. A fibre cement slate that looks sound can snap underfoot, so access is by roof ladder or scaffold, and the weight is spread. Our page on standing on a slate roof explains why.
The wider picture of coverings, with their lives and costs, sits under slate roofing.
