01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Swapping from inside

Can a roof window be swapped from inside?

It depends on what is being swapped. If the frame and flashing stay, some work can be reached from the loft; a new frame needs the covering opened outside.

In brief

Sometimes, but only where the frame and the flashing outside are staying. The seal between a roof window and the covering lies on the outside of the roof, so any swap that replaces the frame or the flashing means working on the slope, whatever is done from the loft. The new unit must still reach 1.4 or WER Band B in England (Table 4.2) and in Wales (Table 4.1), and a listed house, a flat or a Welsh conservation area changes the permissions.

What a roof window is fixed to

A roof window has three parts that matter here. Rafters are the timbers running up the slope beneath the covering, and the frame is fixed to them and to short cross pieces framed around the opening. The sash is the glazed part that opens. The flashing is the metal collar that tucks under the courses above the frame and lies over those below, and it closes the joint where frame and covering meet.

Only the loft side of that is reachable from indoors. The frame sits partly in the loft and partly under the covering, and the flashing is entirely on the outside, where it can only be reached by lifting the tiles or slates around it in the right order. On a stone-tiled or slated roof that means several courses, each of which has to go back exactly as it came off.

So the first question is which part is being changed. Replacing glass or a sash inside an intact frame is one job. Taking out the whole unit, frame and all, is a different job, and the flashing is part of it.

Which jobs can be reached from the loft side

The table gives a first reading of each job. It is a guide, and the survey decides every case.

Roof window jobs and where the work happens
JobFrom inside?Why
Inner lining or blindYesNothing outside is touched
Sash or glass, frame stayingPossiblyDepends on make and age
Whole unit, same openingNoFlashing and covering are lifted
Larger or smaller unitNoRafters trimmed and flashing renewed

An old frame can hold more trouble than the glass shows. If the timber around the opening is damp or soft, it is found from inside and repaired from outside, and a sash swap on top of it only hides the cause. The photographs go to you, and we tell you when the cheaper swap is the right call. Signs of trouble we look for include:

  • staining or flaking paint on the lining below the frame
  • timber around the opening that gives under a screwdriver
  • flashing lifted away from the frame at one corner

Those find the cause, and a new sash alone would leave it in place.

The rules that apply to a swap

The replacement is a new window, so it meets the window line in Approved Document L: 1.4 or WER Band B in England under Table 4.2 and in Wales under Table 4.1. A rooflight is held to 2.2 on both sides. Whether a swap in an existing opening needs an application sits with the council's building control service or a registered building control approver, so ask them before the work is booked.

On planning, England's Class C allows other roof alterations, as long as it stands no more than 0.15 metres out of the original plane of the slope, and a conservation area does not remove it. Welsh Class C.1(d) removes the permitted development right for a roof light on article 1(5) land, and the Welsh Government expects a new rooflight to need Building Regulations approval in most cases, so check before assuming that a swap is outside both rules. Listing adds listed building consent on either side.

If the window is also the way out of a loft bedroom, the new unit must keep an openable area of at least 0.33 m², 450 mm high and 450 mm wide, as the escape window page explains.

Cost and what we do first

MyJobQuote says Velux window replacement costs "around £100 less for a straightforward swap, as the opening is already in place". The word straightforward matters. A swap that reuses the opening and lifts only a small area of covering is cheaper than one that opens up the slope, and rot found on the way changes it again.

Before any price is named, we look at the roof from outside and the opening from the loft, because the two views can disagree. We note the make on the frame, photograph the flashing and the timber, and measure the opening. You then get one written total with scaffold in it, and the old unit and the waste go with us when we leave. A scaffold that stands on the road or footway falls under the Highways Act 1980 s169, and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder, so you do not chase that paperwork. The old frame is photographed as it comes out, in case a question arises later about what was there. The guide to swapping an old roof window sets out the steps, and Velux and skylights has the whole range.

Related questions

Can I change my own roof window from the loft?

Parts such as a blind or inner lining, yes. The sash, frame and flashing involve work on the slope at height, which we do from a scaffold with the tiles lifted in order. If you plan to do it yourself, ask building control first, because the new unit still has to meet 1.4 or WER Band B.

Does a like-for-like swap need Building Regulations approval?

The Welsh Government expects a new rooflight to need Building Regulations approval in most cases, and England's Approved Document L sets the window figure for a new window. Whether a straight swap counts as new is for the council's building control service or a registered building control approver to say, before the work starts.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing