A roof window that has done its time announces itself: a sash that sticks, a seal that has failed and left mist between the panes, a stain on the lining below, or a flashing lifting off the covering. The cure can be a new unit in the same opening, which is what a like-for-like swap means. The frame goes in the same place, at the same size and the same pitch, and the rafters stay as they are.
Because the hole already exists, a swap avoids the structural work that makes a first opening complicated. It does not avoid the other questions. The new unit has an energy figure to meet, the flashing has to suit the covering around it, and planning and Building Regulations are still in the background. The answers differ on either side of the Welsh border.
This guide follows a swap from the first look at the old window to the finished lining. For the wider service, see our Velux and skylight installation page. If you are not sure whether your glass is a roof window at all, the guide on rooflights and roof windows compared will settle it.
What like for like means, and where it ends
A like-for-like swap keeps three things fixed: the position of the opening, its size, and the slope it sits in. The new frame lands in the old frame's place, the existing trimmed rafters carry it, and the covering round it is lifted and relaid at the edges only.
It stops being like for like the moment one of those changes. A larger window needs the rafters cut and re-trimmed. A window moved up the slope needs a new opening and a patch where the old one was. A switch from a roof window to a rooflight on a kerb is a different product altogether, and the guide on rooflights and roof windows explains why. Each of these is treated as a new opening, and the approval question changes with it.
MyJobQuote puts the difference in money: Velux window replacement costs "around £100 less for a straightforward swap, as the opening is already in place". That saving only holds while the opening stays the same.
Signs that a swap will work, found at the survey:
- the rafters either side of the old window are sound and dry
- the opening is square, so the new frame will sit true
- the covering round the frame is in a condition to be relaid
- the timber below the sill shows no soft patches
If the old unit leaked for years before anyone noticed, the timbers need a look before a new frame is bolted to them. We lift the lining where needed and photograph what is behind it.
Reading the old window before you order
The old unit tells you most of what the new one must be. A label on the frame, where it survives, gives a size code and the make. A code such as FK04 is the name of a particular small centre-pivot Velux; MyJobQuote prices that model at around £330 as a product, with standard options and manual operation. Sizes are set by code, so a code read off the old frame points to a window of the same opening size.
If the label is gone, or the unit is from a maker that no longer trades, we measure. A good measurement takes in:
- the width and height of the frame, outside edge to outside edge
- the roof pitch, read with a digital level
- the depth of the covering at the frame, since tile, slate and stone slate vary
- the distance from the frame to the nearest rafter on each side
The measurements go to the supplier along with a photograph of the label, if there is one, and a photograph of the flashing as fitted.
It also helps to know why the old unit is being replaced. A cracked pane, a failed seal and a rotted sash are all reasons to swap. A stain beneath a window that is otherwise sound may point to the flashing or even to condensation, not the unit. Our guide to flashing kits for tiles and slate covers the flashing side. Replacing a sound window to fix a flashing fault is money spent on the wrong part.
Flashing: the metalwork that seals the opening
A roof window is kept dry by the flashing round it, more than by the glass. The flashing is a set of metal pieces, supplied as a kit, that laps under the covering above the window, over the covering below it and into the sides. Each side of the frame has its own piece, and the pieces overlap in a set order so water is always shed outwards.
The kit has to suit the covering. A kit made for plain tiles will not lap properly over slate, and neither suits a profiled tile or a stone slate. When an old unit is swapped, the kit goes too, because a new frame cannot sit well in an old flashing that has been bent to fit the last one. The covering near the frame is lifted, the new kit laid piece by piece, and the tiles or slates are relaid with any broken ones replaced.
On a slate or stone slate roof the lifting needs care. Slates are held by nails that may have corroded, and a stone slate that cracks cannot be replaced from a shelf. SPAB says that "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries", which is a fair reminder to check before promising a match. Where a slate breaks, we photograph it on site and tell you what the repair needs.
A kit keeps water out at its laps. We photograph each lap before the covering goes back, so the finished roof does not hide how it was built.
The energy figure the new unit must reach
The new unit must reach a thermal figure, and the figure matches on both sides of the border. England's Approved Document L 2021, in its Table 4.2, gives windows including roof windows "1.4 or Window Energy Rating Band B minimum". Welsh Table 4.1 sets "1.4 or minimum WER Band B" for a window or roof window, and Table 10.1 repeats it for windows and roof windows. A rooflight is a separate product with a figure of 2.2.
WER stands for Window Energy Rating, a band given to the unit by its maker, so ask for it in writing with the quote. For a swap, the practical effect is that the new unit's data sheet should show either a U-value of 1.4 W/(m²K) or better, or a WER of Band B. Choose the unit by that label, not by the shop description alone, and keep the data sheet with your papers.
| Nation | Document | Roof window |
|---|---|---|
| England | AD L 2021, Table 4.2 | 1.4 or WER Band B |
| Wales | Welsh AD L, Table 4.1 | 1.4 or WER Band B |
The editions change soon. England's AD L 2026 takes effect on 24 March 2027, and Wales's new edition on 4 March 2027. Our guide to roof window energy rules explains both. The roof around the window is a separate matter: re-covering the slope as well brings the renovation rules into play.
Planning and approval for a swap, England and Wales
England first. A roof window is an alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse, and Class C of the 2015 Order makes such alterations normally permitted development. For a swap, the points to watch are the 0.15 metre projection limit, measured from the original slope, and the rule that no part may rise above the highest part of the original roof, since a new frame can be a little deeper than the old. Class C has no article 2(3) exclusion, so a conservation area does not remove it. A listed house also needs listed building consent, under section 7 of the 1990 Act. On the Building Regulations side, ask the council's building control team or a registered building control approver before ordering. Herefordshire Council Building Control is on 01432 261938.
Now Wales. Class C.1(d) of the 1995 Order concerns the insertion of a roof light, and takes the right away on article 1(5) land and within a World Heritage Site. Whether replacing an existing roof light amounts to inserting one is for the council to say, so on a Welsh house in a conservation area or in Bannau Brycheiniog, the council or the National Park Authority should confirm before you order. The Welsh Government's roof light page puts approval for a new rooflight this way: "Approval under the Building Regulations will generally be needed". Monmouthshire's Duty Planning Officer, on 01633 644831, answers questions about whether permission is needed, Monday to Friday, 10am to 2pm. Listed buildings in Wales fall under section 88 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023.
If the old window sits in a side slope, the glass condition in our guide to side-slope windows may apply to the replacement too, so read it first.
What a swap costs and what you are shown
Published figures show the range, and none is ours. MyJobQuote gives the straightforward-swap saving above and a small FK04 at around £330 as a product price. In Checkatrade's repair rates, rooflight replacement such as a Velux is priced "from £1,000" (June 2026, ex VAT). The two sources describe different things, so do not read a difference between them as a quote for your roof.
What shapes the price of a swap:
- the size and type of unit
- the flashing kit for the covering
- whether the covering round the frame needs more than relaying
- access, with any scaffold named on the quote
- the condition of the timbers and lining behind the old frame
Once the survey is done you get a single written total, with photographs of the old unit, the flashing and the timbers behind it. We protect the room below, take away the old window and the waste, and leave the lining finished. If the old window can stay and only a flashing fault needs fixing, that is the repair we recommend, since a new unit would not cure it.
Where the old frame has rotted, the timbers behind it can cost more than the unit, and we show you those photographs before you agree a total. Condensation is a different complaint from a leak, and a misted unit may or may not need replacing. Our guide to misted roof windows explains what to look for before you decide.
