In brief
Choose by what the room lacks. A roof window is Class C, the permitted development class for other alterations to a roof. A dormer is Class B, an enlargement with volume limits. In England, a conservation area removes the dormer right and leaves the roof window right standing. In Wales, a conservation area or National Park removes both rights, so each needs planning permission there.
Class C and Class B in England
In England, Class C of the General Permitted Development Order 2015 covers "any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse", and fitting a roof window is one. Under C.1, the glazing may sit no more than 0.15 metres out of the original roof plane, and nothing may stand taller than the original roof at its peak, so a roof window cannot poke up past the ridge. Where it faces a side elevation, it must be obscure-glazed; the 1.7 metre height relaxes the non-opening part of that condition and nothing else.
Class B covers "the enlargement of a dwellinghouse consisting of an addition or alteration to its roof", which is where a dormer belongs. In England the allowance is 40 cubic metres on a terrace house and 50 on every other house, measured as added volume. It cannot extend past a slope facing the road on the main elevation.
Class B does not apply on article 2(3) land: conservation areas, National Parks, areas of outstanding natural beauty (now called National Landscapes) and World Heritage Sites. England's Class C carries no article 2(3) exclusion. The full conditions sit in the roof window planning guide for England and Wales.
What the 1995 Order changes in Wales
Wales has kept its 1995 Order, and Class C there carries heavier conditions. A Welsh roof light stops being permitted development on article 1(5) land, which means a conservation area, a National Park or an area of outstanding natural beauty, and in a World Heritage Site (C.1(d)). Class B.1(g) bars dormers from the same land. Inside Bannau Brycheiniog, or in a Welsh conservation area, both options need planning permission.
Off protected land in Wales, the volume limits match England at 40 and 50 cubic metres, and Class C allows 15 centimetres of projection. Welsh Class B adds two tests that England does not have. The dormer must stay at least 20 centimetres up from the eaves, and it cannot extend beyond a side slope that lies within 10.5 metres of a highway opposite the side elevation.
Welsh Class C.2(a) asks that the new work match the appearance of the existing roof so far as practicable, and C.2(b) applies obscure glazing to a side-slope window only inside the 10.5 metre boundary test, with non-opening required below 1.7 metres.
Reading the two options against each other
The table puts the same house in four settings. The Welsh Government's planning page says you "do not normally need to apply for planning permission" for roof lights or skylights, and then lists the protected land where that stops.
| Setting | Roof window | Dormer |
|---|---|---|
| English conservation area | Class C stands | Planning permission |
| Welsh conservation area | Planning permission | Planning permission |
| English projection limit | 0.15 metres | 40 or 50 cubic metres |
| Welsh projection limit | 15 centimetres | 40 or 50 cubic metres |
The two classes are separate rights, so a house can take a roof window on one slope of its roof and a dormer on another, each judged against its own limits. Listing does not remove either class in England or in Wales, but the house needs listed building consent for work that touches its character. A flat has no householder rights in England under the 2015 Order, so a flat owner applies for planning permission for either option. In Wales the Building Regulations also come into it: a new rooflight there will generally need approval, according to the Welsh Government.
Choosing on a real roof
Pick a roof window when the room already has the headroom to stand in and only lacks daylight or a view. Pick a dormer when it lacks floor area or height, because a dormer adds both, and neither option is a cheap shortcut. A dormer is a small build in its own right: a new roof, the small side walls called cheeks, and fresh flashings and drainage where it meets the main slope.
The energy figures follow the size of the work. In England and Wales alike, a roof window takes the window value of 1.4 or WER Band B. A dormer's new roof is new fabric, so Approved Document L asks 0.15 in England and 0.13 in Wales. Ask the council's building control service or a registered building control approver before the work is drawn.
At the survey we measure rafters and ridge height, photograph your loft, and say so when a roof window will do. One written total price follows. For the figures on the window alone, see the roof window U-value answer, or browse Velux and skylights.
