In brief
A like-for-like swap is the shortest job, because the frame, the rafters and the lining are already in place. A new opening takes longer: the slope is opened, the rafters are trimmed and framed, the flashing is dressed and the inside is lined. The time is given after a visit to the roof, and we plan the work around the forecast. Approval rules also differ in England and Wales.
A swap compared with a new opening
The two jobs differ in kind, not only in length.
In a swap, the old window comes out, the flashing is lifted and the new frame goes into the same opening. Because the opening is in place already, a swap comes out around £100 cheaper on MyJobQuote's figures for Velux replacement. That is a statement about price, but it points to the shape of the work: less is opened, less is rebuilt, and less is left to dry.
A new opening begins with the structure. The covering is stripped back, the rafters are cut and a header is fixed across the gap, so the load passes round it. The framed opening is lined, the window is set, and the flashing kit is lapped into the slates or tiles. Then the room inside is finished, with the lining and any plaster following the window, and the plaster has to dry before paint goes on.
Each step follows the last, and the roof stands open while it happens. That is why a new opening is planned around the forecast, and why the slope is covered each time we leave it, even for a night.
What sets the time on your roof
Fitting time is not a single number. These points push it up or down:
- whether the opening exists already or has to be made
- the covering: slate, plain tile and stone each take their own care, and the flashing kit must suit it
- the pitch and the access, and whether a scaffold has to go up first
- the state of the rafters, battens and underlay once the roof is opened
- the number of windows, and the finish inside, such as lining and plaster
A window in a flat roof is built on a kerb and is covered in our flat-roof answer. For a straight swap, swapping an old roof window goes through the steps in order.
A plain time given after the roof has been seen is worth more than one quoted over the phone, so that is when you get it. Rain on the day matters less for a swap, which can wait for a dry spell, than for a new opening, where the slope is already cut and must be sheeted over. Weather is therefore the main thing that can stretch a job beyond what was planned, and we tell you if a day has to move.
Approval before any work starts
Time can also go on approval, so the order of things matters. For an English house, Class C normally covers a new roof window as permitted development, subject to its conditions, while the Building Regulations are a separate matter that your council's building control team can explain. If the house is listed, listed building consent is also required, and that application can take longer than the work itself.
In Wales, the Welsh Government's page on roof lights says approval under the Building Regulations will "generally" be needed to put one in. On article 1(5) land, meaning conservation areas, National Parks and National Landscapes, Class C gives no cover to a roof light, so planning permission comes first and the order for the window waits for it. The Welsh Government says new building regulations reforming building control processes came into force in Wales on 1 July 2026.
Roof windows take 1.4 or WER Band B and rooflights 2.2, in England and in Wales. Each planning condition is quoted in our planning guide for England and Wales.
How the day is run, and what you get
At the survey we photograph the slope, the covering and the room, and measure the opening. You receive a written total with scaffold included, and a plain idea of the time. If the window is one of several, we say whether they go in together or one after another.
On the day, the work is set out so the slope is covered when we finish. The covering is made good around the flashing, the waste is taken away and the room is left clean. Afterwards we photograph the finished flashing and show you, and the photographs can be kept with your house papers for a future buyer.
If opening the roof reveals a weak rafter or a wet batten, you are told with photographs before the price moves. Where the covering around the window needs attention, our roof repairs can be done in the same visit, using slates or tiles matched to the roof.
The full set of window jobs, from swaps to new openings, is listed under Velux and skylights.
