A roof on an older Hereford house tells you how the house was built. Its covering came from the ground nearby or from a quarry further off, its lines were set by a carpenter working with timber of varying size, and its details were shaped by repairs made over generations. A repair that ignores all that can leave the house looking patched for good, even when it keeps the rain out.
Repair on this kind of roof is a matter of judgement as much as skill. The question at the survey is what can stay: which stones, slates or clay tiles are sound, which timbers still carry their load, and which details give the roof its look from the road. Only what has failed is renewed, and each new part is picked to sit alongside the old.
You will find here a way of reading the materials, the points a survey checks on an older roof, how to match what has to be replaced, the details that carry the look, and the rules in England for older houses. The guide is written for houses in England. For the full range of repairs see our roof repairs page.
Reading the roof you are repairing
Before any repair is planned, the covering has to be identified, because each material is repaired in its own way. A street name is no guide to the covering, since neighbouring roofs can differ. What helps is knowing what each covering looks like and what repair asks of it.
| Covering | How it looks | What repair asks |
|---|---|---|
| Stone tilestones | Thick, heavy, with an uneven face | Sound pieces re-laid, new ones matched |
| Welsh or other slate | Thin, flat, with a clean edge | Slipped slates re-fixed, cracked ones swapped |
| Clay plain tiles | Small, slightly curved, in even courses | Broken tiles replaced to match colour |
On the stone, the building stone atlas traces Herefordshire's traditional stone roofing chiefly to the St Maughans sandstones. It places flagstone roofs on older cottages at Longtown and Kington, and it ties the clays of the Raglan mudstones to the county's tile and pipeworks industries.
A single house can carry stone, slate and clay in different places, added in different centuries. In the timber-framed villages north-west of Hereford the roof sits on a frame that moves in its own way, which is one more thing a repair has to allow for.
Parts of one roof also age at different rates. A slope shaded by trees can hold moss and damp for longer than one in the open, and a valley collects more than a plain slope does, so the faults on an older roof may not be spread evenly.
What a survey looks for on an older roof
The survey starts in the loft, because the timbers show how the roof has moved. We look for:
- a ridge line that sags or dips between the gables
- rafters that have bowed, or battens that have gone soft under a wet patch
- daylight through the covering, and tide marks where water has run
- old repairs in a different stone, slate or tile from the rest
- stones or slates that have slipped, split or lost their fixing
- stacks that lean, and lead that has lifted at a chimney or against a wall
Outside, the survey climbs to the ridge line first and works downwards, so verges, stacks and valleys are seen before the open slopes. Each fault is photographed from the position where it was found, and you see it on your own roof.
SPAB cautions that older roofs are often found altered, with other stones, slates or imitation stone slates put in where the originals were. Those earlier changes matter, because a repair has to decide which roof it is matching: the original, or the version that has stood for fifty years. We note what each part is made of before suggesting how to carry on.
Old coverings give away their condition in small ways. A stone that is flaking at its edge, a slate that has lost its fixing and hangs a little below its course, and a ridge repaired in cement that stands out in colour from the mortar around it each change what the repair should be. They are photographed and marked on a plan, so the work is agreed against what is actually on the roof.
A first look needs no ladder. From the lawn, a pair of binoculars shows slipped pieces and lifted lead, and our guide to a slipped slate repair explains what follows when one turns up.
Keeping what is sound
On an older roof, repair comes before replacement, and the reason is practical as well as visual. Stones and slates that have stood for generations have already shown they can do the job. A roof re-covered in new material starts that test again, and it changes the look of the house in one go.
A repair works in this order:
- Lift only the pieces that have failed or that stand in the way.
- Sort what comes off into sound pieces that can be re-laid and pieces that have split or worn through.
- Re-lay the sound pieces in their original pattern, with new fixings.
- Fill the gaps with matching material.
The work goes in sections, so the roof is open only where it is being worked on, and a written note of what was lifted and what was re-laid is kept with the photographs, so the next owner can read the history of the roof. Where a timber has gone soft, the soft part is cut back and the roof is carried on new timber of matching size.
If the repair is small and the roof is otherwise sound, it is left at that, and the report says so. When replacement really is the better buy, you see the evidence: photographs of the failing areas and a written explanation of why patching would not last. As a guide to life spans, HomeBuilding lists Welsh slate at "100+ years", Spanish slate at "75-100 years" and reclaimed Welsh slate at "50-80 years". Treat these as ranges, not as commitments.
Scale matters too. MyJobQuote gives around £650 for an average roof repair in 2026, a very different order of spend from a new covering.
Matching what has to be new
A mismatched patch shows from the road for decades. Matching is about colour, thickness, texture and the way the courses run, and it starts with finding out what the roof really is.
SPAB lists grey and brown among the shades of the region's stone slates, and mentions some purple types found in Herefordshire. A purple repair on a grey roof, or the reverse, would stand out for years. Reclaimed material from a stripped building can be the closest match, though the supply is small and varies.
On supply, SPAB's advice is direct: "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries." Following it means asking the quarries instead of accepting a substitute that is offered because it is easier to get.
A few matching questions come up on an older roof:
- Is the colour right in dry weather and in wet?
- Does the thickness suit the courses on either side?
- Will the new piece weather to the same tone, or stay bright for years?
- Is the fixing method the same as the old one, or has an earlier repair changed it?
Clay is a separate case. BRE's minimum life expectancy of 60 years, as Marley reports it, applies to clay roof tiles only and is not to be read across to other coverings.
Where no good match exists, the options are laid out in writing: a difference chosen on purpose, or a longer wait for the right material.
Details that carry the look of the house
On an old house, small parts of the roof do much of the work of giving it character. They are also where weather tends to get in, so they are checked before the open slopes.
- Where a stack is built of local sandstone, repointing uses a mortar matched to the stone in colour and hardness.
- A ridge that was bedded in mortar can be rebedded and fixed mechanically as well. Our guide to ridge and verge repairs covers the options.
- The verge at a gable is kept in the style of the house, with no plastic trim added to a stone or slate roof, and chimney pots and the mortar collar round them are repaired like for like.
- Flashings and soakers are renewed in lead, and our guide to leaks where a roof meets a wall describes the junctions.
- Rainwater goods are chosen to suit the building and laid to a fall, which Brett Martin gives as "1mm for every 600mm".
Marley says installing to BS 5534 "isn't required by law", and that mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering". That is why a rebedded ridge on an old house is also fixed. The roof looks the same from the road, but the ridge is held more firmly against the wind.
The aim throughout is that nobody passing the house can tell where a repair was made, while the roof is sounder than before.
The rules in England for an older house
In England, most repair work to an older house needs no application, but a handful of cases do, and they are worth settling at the survey:
- Listing brings its own consent: under section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, work that alters the special character of a listed house needs consent first. Classes B and C of permitted development stay open to such a house, with that consent needed on top.
- Herefordshire Council says the county has 64 conservation areas, among them the Central Area Hereford conservation area. A conservation area takes away permitted development for dormers (Class B), but not for a change of covering (Class C). Planning permission is what is sought, and the council is the place to ask.
- An Article 4 direction can withdraw permitted development across a defined area. Check whether one applies with Herefordshire Council.
- For re-roofing, the Planning Portal says no Building Regulations application is normally needed where "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof" are affected.
- Under the Portal, a replacement covering that makes the roof heavier by "15 per cent or more" needs approval too. A flat-roofed extension to an older house faces the same tests.
Herefordshire Council's building control team is on 01432 261938. If you are in any doubt about a listed or period house, ask before a stone is lifted, and keep the reply in writing.
