In brief
Yes, if the slate itself is whole. A slate slips because its nail has failed, so the slate may be undamaged. We slide it back into its course and hold its bottom edge with a slate hook or a strip of metal called a tingle. It needs replacing when it is cracked, flaking or broken at the head, and its replacement is chosen to suit the slates around it in size, thickness and colour. Several slipping on one slope means the nails are failing more widely.
Why a sound slate slides out of its row
Each slate hangs on two nails driven through it into a batten, the timber strip that runs across the rafters. Over the years those nails corrode, or wear thin where the slate rubs against them, a fault roofers call nail sickness. When a nail gives way, the slate drops out of its course (its row) and slides down until it catches on the slates below, or lands in the gutter. The slate itself may be perfectly sound.
Welsh slate and stone roofs, SPAB notes, "are predominantly double-lapped", which means every point on the slope is covered by at least two thicknesses of slate. So one slipped slate does not always let rain straight through, but it opens a gap where underlay or bare batten shows, and wind can get under the slates on either side of it.
When we come out, we look along the ridge and verges and the chimney first, then at the slope with the gap. On your roof we check and photograph:
- whether the slipped slate is whole or cracked across
- whether its nail holes have split out at the head
- the slates around it, for any that move under a hand
- the batten and underlay showing behind the gap
How a whole slipped slate goes back in
A slate that is whole goes back into its own place. Nailing it again is not possible without lifting a wider patch, because its nail holes sit under the course above. So the slate is held at its tail, the bottom edge you see from the ground, instead.
There are two ways we do that:
- A slate hook: a stiff hook fixed to the batten in the narrow joint between the two slates below, with the tail of the refixed slate sitting in its bend.
- A tingle: a thin strip of copper or lead, nailed into the batten through the same joint and folded up over the tail after the slate has been slid back into line.
Cupa, the slate producer, does not recommend hooks on a slope shallower than 25 degrees, so on a shallow slope we use a tingle or rework the patch instead. A hook shows as a small mark at the tail and a tingle as a short strip of metal.
Before we come down, we photograph the refixed slate with the slates around it, so you can see the course is closed and lying flat.
When the slate has to be replaced instead
A slate is replaced rather than refixed when it is cracked, has lost a corner, has broken through at the nail holes or is flaking apart in layers. Sometimes it is simply gone, smashed on the path below, and the job is much like replacing a few broken tiles. Whatever goes in must suit the slates already up there.
| Point | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Length and width | Keeps the lap and the line of the course |
| Thickness | A thicker slate tips its neighbours up |
| Colour and source | Welsh, Spanish and reclaimed slates look different |
The source also bears on how long the new slate lasts. HomeBuilding puts Welsh slate at over 100 years, Spanish slate at 75 to 100 years and reclaimed Welsh slate at 50 to 80 years, as typical ranges rather than promises.
A Herefordshire stone tile roof, laid with local sandstone tilestones, is a different job from a slate one. On unavailability and long lead times, SPAB's line is that such claims "should always be checked with the quarries", so a quarry gets our call before another stone is suggested.
Several slipped slates: repair, re-slate and the rules
Slipped slates across one slope point to nails failing over the roof, not one bad fixing. Hooks and tingles still close each gap, but the slates still in place hang on nails of the same age. That is when we set out the photographs and weigh up targeted roof repairs against stripping and re-slating, and we tell you when the repair is the better buy.
A full re-slate meets different rules depending on the nation:
- England: the Planning Portal says a Building Regulations application is normally unnecessary when under 25 per cent of the total building envelope and under 50 per cent of the roof is affected.
- England: the Planning Portal also says approval is needed once a new covering makes the roof covering 15 per cent or more heavier.
- Wales: Building Regulations approval will be needed for re-roofing in most situations, the Welsh Government says, and its example of a change likely to need it is slate replaced by tiles.
For a patch, Checkatrade's June 2026 guide gives natural slate repairs at £150 to £220 per m², excluding VAT, on patches up to 3 m². For a whole roof, MyJobQuote's figure for fitting a whole slate roof is an average of around £7,800. One written total price follows our survey of the roof.
