01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Repair lifespan

How long should a roof repair last?

No one can promise a number of years for a repair. What can be said is what makes one hold, and how long the roof around it tends to last.

Short answer

There is no sound figure to give. A repair lasts as long as its fixings, its materials and the roof around it allow, and weather and age keep changing that. What helps is the typical lifespan of the covering, which published guides give as ranges: from 10 to 20 years for felt to over a century for good natural slate. A well-made repair should see out the coming seasons, but a promised lifespan would be guesswork.

Why a repair has no fixed lifespan

A repair is a small piece of new work set into an older roof, and its life is tied to the parts beside it. A new tile sits on old battens, fixed with new nails into timber that has been through decades of weather. A new length of lead flashing tucks into a joint that may be crumbling. A patch on a felt roof bonds to felt that is already ageing.

So the fair statement is that a repair should do its job for as long as the things around it stay sound, and nobody can say when they will not. Weather adds to the uncertainty. A mild few winters treat a roof more gently than a hard one, and exposure differs between roofs and even between slopes of one roof.

Any number of years offered for a repair, with no mention of the roof it is going into, deserves a second look. A trustworthy answer sounds different: this repair deals with this fault, the surrounding materials are in this condition, and here is what we would keep an eye on. Our roof repairs page describes how we show a roof's condition in photographs, so the judgement is yours to make as well as ours.

What published guides say about the roof itself

The best indicator of how long a repair can last is how long the covering is expected to last. These are typical ranges from published guides. They are not promises, and the guides do not always agree with one another.

Typical lifespans as published, not promises
CoveringPublished range
Clay tile (clay only)A minimum life expectancy of 60 years, determined by the Building Research Establishment (Marley)
Welsh natural slate100+ years (HomeBuilding)
Spanish slate75 to 100 years (HomeBuilding)
Felt flat roof10 to 15 years (HomeBuilding); 10 to 20 years (Less)
Concrete tileAround 60 years (Marley); 40 to 50 years (HomeBuilding)

Marley is a tile maker, and its concrete tile figure is higher than the one from HomeBuilding, so both are shown. For lead, MyJobQuote's line is that correctly installed chimney flashing can last for over 80 years, which is a hedge, not a pledge.

For the sandstone tilestones on older Herefordshire roofs, each stone is judged on its condition at the survey. SPAB's line about a well-slated roof does not carry across to stone.

What makes a repair hold

You cannot buy a promised lifespan, but you can look for the habits that make a repair last. These are the points we work to, and they are worth asking any roofer about.

  • The cause was found, not just the symptom. Swapping one slipped tile achieves little if the nails across the slope are failing.
  • The material matches in size, thickness and type, and lead is of a weight suited to the detail.
  • The fixing is right. Marley points out that mortar alone is no longer enough to secure a roof covering, so ridges and verges are held mechanically too.
  • The neighbouring work was checked: battens, underlay, flashings and valleys.
  • Photographs were taken, leaving a record of the fault and the fix.

Our slipped slate repair page shows how one fault is handled, and ridge and verge repairs explains why those edges get extra attention.

Looking after the roof afterwards counts too: clear the gutters, glance at the slopes from the garden after storms, and call early if something has moved, so a small fault is not left to spread.

Repair or something bigger?

A repair can be the better choice where the fault is local and the covering around it is sound. It stops being so when the same fault keeps coming back in new places, when the covering has reached the far end of its published range, or when fixings and battens across a whole slope are going. In those cases we show you the photographs and give our view, and you decide with both options in front of you. Anything bigger comes up only where the survey supports it.

The paperwork differs by side of the border. For England, the Planning Portal sets its limits at less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof, below which an application is not normally needed. For Wales, the Welsh Government's re-roofing page opens with the warning that in most situations the work will need Building Regulations approval.

As a cost comparison, Which? gives £75 to £400 for one to six broken tiles, and MyJobQuote's average roof repair is around £650, against an average new roof of around £5,250. These are national guides, not our prices. What we put in writing is one total, prepared after the survey.

Related questions

Is a repair certain to last as long as the old roof?

No. A repair has its own fixings and materials, while the old roof around it keeps ageing. A sound repair should hold for as long as its surroundings do, but nobody can name the date. Photographs taken before and after leave the condition on record, so the next inspection has something to compare against.

How do I know if a roof repair was done well?

Ask for before and after photographs, check that the replacement matches in type and size, and ask what caused the fault and what else was looked at. A good repair comes with answers, not just an invoice. A leak that returns in the same place within a season should be reported promptly.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing