In brief
No. Marley says installing to BS 5534 isn't required by law. The standard is not a statute. The law that does bear on a roofer includes the Building Regulations, which apply to re-roofing, and section 49 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, which asks for reasonable care and skill in a service. That section does not mention the standard. We follow it because it records good fixing practice.
What the standard is
A British Standard is a document published by BSI. It sets out agreed practice, and it carries no legal force unless a law or a contract points to it. BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 is the version in force for slating and tiling pitched roofs, and its recommendations cover how a covering is fixed to the battens and how its edges are secured.
The fixing rules matter most at the edges. Marley reads the 2015 amendments as ruling out a mortar bed as the lone fixing for the covering. Mortar was not banned by that change. It became one part of a fixing and not the whole of it. For ridges, hips and verges, the mechanical fixings the standard describes are what keep tiles on in a gale.
Dry-fix systems have a separate specification, BS 8612, which covers dry-fixed ridge, hip and verge parts. Neither document is a licence or a qualification. Each is a reference that a roofer, a maker and a customer can all read. For a plain-English guide to what the standard asks of your tiles, see what BS 5534 means for your tiles.
What the law does require of a roofer
Where a standard is not law, other rules still apply. The table sets the main ones beside the standard so you can see which carries legal force.
| Item | Legal force |
|---|---|
| BS 5534 | None by itself, per Marley |
| Building Regulations | Law, in England and in Wales |
| Consumer Rights Act 2015, s49 | Law: reasonable care and skill |
| Highways Act 1980, s169 | Law: licence for scaffold over the highway |
On the Building Regulations, the two countries word the re-roofing test differently. In England, the Planning Portal's two re-roofing tests are under 25 per cent of the building envelope and under 50 per cent of the roof. In Wales, gov.wales says approval is needed in most re-roofing situations. Scaffold over a public road needs a licence under the Highways Act 1980, and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder.
Planning permission is a separate matter again. In England, Class C normally lets a roof be re-covered without a planning application. In Wales, Class C.2(a) adds a condition on appearance: new materials should look like the old where practicable.
None of this makes BS 5534 optional in practice. The standard is followed because it is good practice, and the law asks a different question.
Why we still fix to the standard
Fixing to BS 5534 is not a legal duty for us. It is what a careful job looks like. A ridge bedded on mortar alone may drop in a storm, and a verge tile that is only bedded can lift with the edge of a gust. Mechanical fixings cost little against the risk they remove.
For you, the useful question to put to any roofer is what the fixings will be. A good answer names them, such as clips, nails or dry-fix parts, for ridge, hip and verge alike. Photographs taken as the work goes on show them, and we send those to you. Putting the fixings into the written specification is also how a customer can ask for them: a document that names the fixings tells you what was agreed.
A few points worth asking about before work starts:
- how each ridge, hip and verge tile will be fixed
- whether the old mortar will be removed or kept as a bed
- whether the batten size and the underlay suit the tile
- how the work will be photographed as it goes on
Our page on whether a dry ridge uses mortar shows one of those answers in practice.
If a roofing job goes wrong
If the work falls short, the legal question is whether the service met the duty in section 49 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015. A standard can show what careful work looks like, but it is not the test in the Act. Keep the written price, the photographs and any messages, since together they show what was agreed and what was done.
Free advice is available. The Citizens Advice consumer helpline is 0808 223 1133, with a Welsh-speaking line on 0808 223 1144. Section 308 of the 2024 Act on digital markets, competition and consumers requires a trader to tell a dissatisfied customer about any dispute arrangement that exists.
It also helps to hold a copy of the survey photographs. They fix the state of the roof on the day we looked, which stops an argument about how it was before. A dispute is also easier to settle when the paperwork on both sides is complete and dated. The pitched roofing hub links every page on tiled roofs, and our other pages show the fixings and the standards in more detail.
