In brief
Lead is the safer pick wherever the roof butts into a wall or chimney or laps over slates or tiles, because it can be dressed into awkward corners. Zinc can suit a plain, straight-sided small roof such as a porch top. VMZinc, the maker, cites a BRE Environmental Product Declaration stating 100 years for a correctly designed zinc roof, and HomeBuilding gives a lead flat roof 60 to 100 years. On a listed house, changing the metal needs consent first.
How the two metals compare on paper
Published lifespans are the fairest starting point, but they have different authors and none is a promise. Read each row for the job it describes, and notice who is speaking, because a maker and a magazine do not have the same interest in the answer.
| Metal and use | Quoted life | Who says so |
|---|---|---|
| Lead, flat roof | 60 to 100 years | HomeBuilding |
| Lead, flat roof | 50 to 100 years | Less |
| Lead, flashing | "can last for over 80 years" if correctly installed | MyJobQuote |
| Zinc roof | "in excess of 100 years" | VMZinc |
VMZinc makes zinc, so its figure is a manufacturer's claim about a roof that has been correctly designed and installed. The two lead flat-roof sources are a home-building magazine and a flat-roof cost guide, and they sit ten years apart at the low end. The flashing line is about a different job again, and its wording is a hedge. None of these rows says that one metal beats the other on your roof. Whichever metal goes on, how well the joints are formed and how the deck beneath is kept dry will count for more than the number in a table.
Why shape decides more than the metal
Lead is soft. A roofer can press it into a corner, around a pipe or over a saddle from a single piece, and it holds that shape. Zinc arrives as sheet that is folded along straight lines, which suits a roof made of plain rectangles and gives less room for improvising at odd angles.
So the questions at a survey are about the roof in front of us:
- Is the roof a simple box, such as a porch, a small bay top or the cheek of a dormer, or is it full of corners?
- What touches the metal: a brick wall, a chimney, or a slate or tile slope that must be overlapped?
- Can the metal be reached again for upkeep without a scaffold?
- Does the covering on a neighbouring extension set a pattern you want to match?
A small roof with four straight sides and no chimney is where a real choice exists. A small roof that butts up against a stack and a brick wall is mostly an abutment, and abutments are lead work. The metal follows the joints, which is why we look at the joints before naming a material.
Where lead stays the sensible answer
At a chimney, a side wall or a valley with slate on both sides, the metal has to be tucked into the masonry and lapped over the covering. That is lead's home ground, and the Royston Lead brochure names lead for each of those jobs. Its use letters work out like this:
- Code 3 is marked "Recommended for lead soakers only".
- Code 4 appears under soakers, flashings, valleys and dormers.
- Codes 5 and 6 drop soakers and add parapet and box gutters.
- Codes 7 and 8 drop flashings as well.
The page on what lead code is used for flashings explains the codes in more depth. Zinc remains a sound metal for a plain flat top, and the guide to alternatives to lead sets out the other coverings too. When a quote you hold proposes zinc at a chimney, ask who will form the joint at the masonry, how it is held there and what happens to the slates or tiles that lap over it. A good answer is specific about each. Our lead roofing page covers the leadwork we take on.
Listed houses, conservation areas and the written price
A change of metal is a change of material, so a listed house goes to the council first. England and Wales each have their own statute for this:
- In England, the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 section 7 asks for consent for works that would "affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest".
- In Wales, the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 requires works to be authorised under section 88, and section 89 makes listed building consent the route.
Herefordshire Council records 64 conservation areas. Whether an Article 4 direction removes extra permitted development rights at your address is for your own council to answer, so ask it before ordering any work.
On price, the area, the number of corners, the access and what lies under the covering matter for either metal. We survey the roof, photograph the joints and give you one written total for the metal you choose, with scaffold in it where one is needed. Ask any other quote whether VAT sits inside its figure.
