On a period house the lead may not be a plain sheet. It may be a hip roll over slates, a saddle where a ridge meets a stack, a lead-lined valley between two stone-tiled slopes, or a cheek on an old dormer. Each piece has a shape that was made for that spot, and the shape is part of why the roof looks right.
That is why lead on a listed or period roof is handled in two steps. The first is consent: whether the law lets the work go ahead and who has to agree. The second is matching: if the work goes ahead, whether the new lead copies the old in its code, its shape and the way it is fixed.
This guide takes both steps in order. It lays the English and Welsh listed building rules next to each other, then turns to conservation areas, what we record before old lead comes off, the question of a change of material, and the separate consent routes for churches and monuments. The wider picture is on our lead roofing page.
What counts as a period roof
A period roof is an older roof whose covering, lead and details belong to the age of the building. Some period roofs are listed, some stand in a conservation area, and some are neither. The law treats the three differently, so we find out which applies before we plan anything.
The roofs on this side of the border have a recognisable range of materials. Stone roofs in Herefordshire are covered in local sandstone tilestones, and the St Maughans sandstones are, in the atlas of Herefordshire's building stone, the principal source of roofing stone. In the same atlas, the "Black and White Villages" to the north-west of Hereford are "notably Eardisland, Pembridge, Almeley, Dilwyn, Yarpole and Weobley", and the stacks on those timber-framed houses are "commonly of local sandstone". SPAB: Welsh slate and stone roofs "are predominantly double-lapped", and there are "some purple types in Herefordshire".
Lead appears wherever those coverings meet something else: the stack, the wall, the valley, the dormer. The older the roof, the more likely its lead has been patched, and the more it matters to read what is there before replacing it.
We begin a period roof survey with a short list:
- whether the building is listed, in a conservation area, or both
- what covering lies either side of each piece of lead
- which pieces are original, which are repairs and which are substitutes such as cement fillets
- how each old piece was shaped and fixed
Listed building consent in England and in Wales
A listed house has its own consent system, and it applies as well as, not instead of, planning and Building Regulations. The two sides of the border now use different Acts.
| Point | England | Wales |
|---|---|---|
| Law | Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, section 7 | Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023, sections 88 and 89 |
| Work caught | Works that would "affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest" | Alteration or extension that would affect that character |
| Start date | Section 7 is the current law | Section 88 in force from 4 November 2024 |
| Permitted development | Class B and Class C both remain for a listed house, which also needs consent | Wales is alike here: both classes remain, with consent still required |
In England, section 7 says works must not be carried out "in any manner which would affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest, unless the works are authorised". In Wales, section 88(1) says a person "must not carry out works to which this section applies" unless they are authorised under section 89 by listed building consent.
Whether a particular piece of leadwork touches the building's special character is a judgement for the council, and not one a roofer can make for you. Consent is applied for by the owner, with a description of the work and photographs, and our survey notes are written so that they can be handed on to that application. We put the question to the council first, with photographs of the old lead and notes of its code and shape. The list entry for your building is the document to read, held by Historic England in England and by Cadw in Wales.
Conservation areas and Article 4
A conservation area covers a whole group of buildings, and a house within it need not be listed. The controls are lighter than on a listed house, yet they still bear on a roof.
Herefordshire has 64 conservation areas, which include Hereford's historic centre. Other counties in our area keep their own lists, and so do the Welsh councils. Where a house stands in a conservation area, we point you to the council's list and map rather than guess from the postcode. In Wales, conservation areas are designated under Part 4 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023.
An Article 4 direction withdraws specified permitted development rights across a defined area. In Wales, the Welsh Government says permitted development rights "may also have been removed by an 'Article 4' direction. These are most common in conservation areas". Whether one covers your road, and what it takes away, is something only your council can confirm, and the council can say when each conservation area was designated.
Permitted development also runs differently in the two countries.
- In England, the Class C right for roof alterations is not removed by a conservation area, but dormers are.
- In Wales, Class C asks that the new materials "so far as practicable match" the existing ones, and roof lights are not permitted in a conservation area or a National Park.
A like-for-like lead repair raises fewer of these questions than a change of lead to another material.
Recording the old lead before it comes off
Matching begins before anything is taken apart. On a period roof we make a record of the old lead, because once it is stripped the shape is gone, and the council or a conservation architect may ask what was there.
For each piece, we note:
- the code, read from the thickness and, where visible, from any colour mark or stamp on an offcut
- the shape: how the roll, saddle, cheek or apron was formed and where it was lapped
- how it was held: wedges, clips, nails or a chase pointed in mortar
- what lies under it: boards, rolls, a fillet, or nothing
- the condition of the masonry or timber it meets
Photographs go with the notes, taken before, during and after.
Royston Lead's table links each code to uses: Code 3 only for soakers, Codes 4 to 6 for flashings, Codes 4 to 8 for pitched valley gutters, Codes 5 to 8 for parapet and box gutters, Codes 4 to 8 for dormers. On a period roof we start from the code that was there. A sound original code is copied. A thin piece that has failed is replaced in the code its detail suits, and cut and formed to the original shape.
The pointing and the stone get the same care. A chase cut into a sandstone stack, or lead fixed to a timber-framed wall with no mortar joint to chase, calls for a method designed for that wall. Our guide to repairing old leadwork follows an old repair from first look to finish.
Like for like, or a change of material
On an old roof the easiest job to defend is a like-for-like repair, using matching metal, matching code and matching shape, laid where the old piece lay. Even that is worth raising with the council before work begins on a listed building, because the council, not the roofer, decides what affects its character.
Swapping the material is a bigger step. Lead may have been stolen and the owner would like to avoid the same loss, or an earlier repair may have put felt, a cement fillet or a sealant in place of lead. Putting lead back is the natural answer on a period roof. Moving to another metal, such as zinc, changes how the roof looks and ages, so it is a change to check with the council first. VMZinc, which makes it, says: "When correctly designed and installed a zinc roof can last in excess of 100 years." That is a maker's claim, and it does not settle the consent question.
Lead has its own record on old roofs. HomeBuilding gives a lead flat roof 60 to 100 years, and Less gives 50 to 100 years. MyJobQuote says correctly installed lead flashing "can last for over 80 years". Those are ranges and hedged claims, not promises, and each assumes sound workmanship on the lead.
SPAB warns that stone roofs have been altered:"Unfortunately, many are changed to different stones or even to slates or fake stone slates". It also says that "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries". The same care applies to lead, so we ask for the code and the shape before we agree a substitute.
Churches, chapels and scheduled monuments
Churches and monuments follow their own routes, and the lead on them can be large in area. The route depends on the building, on whether services still take place in it, and on the country it stands in.
- In England, Church of England churches still in use fall under faculty jurisdiction, which sends the work through the diocese's faculty system. Churches in use that are Roman Catholic or Methodist are exempt too, and so are United Reformed Church ones, and Baptist Union churches if a Schedule 1 trust corporation holds them.
- In Wales the exempt list names the Church in Wales, Roman Catholic and Methodist buildings, Church of England faculty buildings, and Baptist buildings held by one of two bodies: the Welsh Baptist Union Corporation Limited or the Baptist Union Corporation Limited. The URC does not appear on it.
- Other faiths' places of worship, Unitarian and Quaker among them, are outside the exemption in both countries. So are redundant churches and Churches Conservation Trust buildings, and all of these need listed building consent.
- A scheduled monument needs scheduled monument consent. In England that is under section 2 of the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Areas Act 1979, from the Secretary of State. In Wales, applications "must be made to the Welsh Ministers".
A minister's house on a Welsh site is not a religious building for this purpose, so lead work that affects a listed one needs listed building consent.
If the building is a church or chapel, tell us its denomination and whether services are held there, because those two facts decide the route. The church's governing body is then asked before any lead is touched.
