Short answer
Because water is reaching the wall that should be carried away. The causes are a leaking joint, a gutter that overflows because it is blocked or has lost its fall, a split downpipe or a broken stop end. Watch the run in rain, or have it hosed from a ladder, and the stain lines up with the fault.
Tracing the stain back to its source
A gutter is meant to take roof water along a gentle slope to a downpipe. When water ends up on the wall instead, one of the links in that chain has failed. A wall shows it as a dark band, green growth, flaking paint or a patch still wet days after a shower.
The pattern of the stain points to the cause:
- A stain directly under one joint: the seal has failed and the joint is weeping.
- A long band under the whole run: the gutter overflows, because it is blocked or the fall has gone.
- A stain from a downpipe down to the ground: a split pipe, a loose collar or a broken shoe at the bottom.
- A patch at one end: a missing or cracked stop end.
It is worth looking at the roof edge above as well. If tiles or slates overhang the gutter by too little, water can run behind the channel and onto the fascia and wall, whatever state the gutter is in. Flashings, valleys and chimneys leak onto walls in the same way, which is why the survey does not stop at the gutter itself. We photograph each point where water meets the wall, so the cause is on record before anything is priced.
The fall, and why a sag matters
A gutter that does not slope towards its outlet holds water, and water standing in a channel finds the joints. The fall Brett Martin recommends is "1mm for every 600mm". On a 6 metre run, that is 10 mm of drop towards the outlet, which is easy to lose when brackets work loose or a fascia board softens.
A sagging run shows up in rain. Water pools in the low spot and spills over the front lip, or it backs up against the wall behind the gutter. Look for a green line on the face of the channel, or a trail of dirty streaks on the wall below one spot.
The fix depends on the cause. Refixing a run to firm brackets on sound timber restores the fall. If the fascia behind has rotted, the boards come first, and our guide to the signs of rotten fascias lists what to press and look at. A detailed look at slope and levels is in the guide on gutter falls and alignment.
Repair or replace the run
One failed joint is a repair. The joint is opened, the faces are cleaned, and a new seal or union is fitted. A cracked section of cast iron can be replaced like for like. Repeated joint failures along one run, brittle plastic or a channel that has lost its shape point towards replacing the whole length.
Costs are better set against third-party figures than guessed. In its November 2025 survey, Which? reported £75 to £350 before VAT for emptying every gutter on a house. MyJobQuote's UK average for a full replacement is around £1,000 to £1,600. What you are quoted is one total, put in writing once the survey is finished, with the joints photographed so that the money has a visible purpose. Replacement is advised only when the run really cannot be mended, and a repair that holds is the cheaper route.
| What the survey finds | Likely step |
|---|---|
| One weeping joint | Reseal or replace the joint |
| Blocked run | Clear and test the outlet |
| Split downpipe | Replace the pipe length |
| Brittle or distorted run | Replace the run |
When the wall stays damp afterwards
A wall that took water for a long time does not dry overnight. Fix the water source first, then give the masonry time, and look again after a dry spell. If the patch is still wet, the cause may be elsewhere: a roof leak, a failed flashing, raised ground against the wall, or damp rising from the ground. A damp specialist, rather than a roofer, is the right person for rising or penetrating damp inside a house; a gutter repair only removes one source of water.
Grey rainwater goods that look old could be asbestos cement, and HSE treats any building built or refurbished before 2000 as one to suspect. A suspect gutter or downpipe should not be drilled, scrubbed or snapped, and we want to hear about it before the visit. Waste rules split by nation. England's exemption for household hazardous waste leaves asbestos out, and in Wales NRW requires consignment notes from contractors.
The overview of guttering, soffits and fascias shows how each part of the roofline works, and the guide on why gutter joints leak goes deeper on that repair.
