The soffit is the board fixed beneath the eaves that shuts off the space between the roof edge and the wall. On an older house it can be a flat white panel that has only ever needed a wash. HSE lists "AIB white soffit panels to underside of roof eaves" among the places where asbestos insulating board, shortened to AIB, turns up in buildings, and it lists "Damaged AIB soffit" as a separate entry.
AIB is a different product from asbestos cement. Cement was cast into hard sheets for roofs and rainwater goods. AIB is a board made for lining and fire protection. HSE treats the two differently when it asks who may remove them, and a soffit can turn out to be either one. That single fact decides whether a roofer can take the board down carefully, or whether the job has to go to a licensed firm first.
This guide sets out how the two materials differ, what HSE says about each, what changes between England and Wales once waste is involved, and what happens at our survey. The wider roofline work is covered on our guttering, soffits and fascias page.
Telling AIB from asbestos cement on a soffit
Nobody can tell the two apart by looking at a painted panel from a ladder. Both can be flat, pale and fixed with small nails or pins along a timber batten. What gets people to the right answer is the age of the building and a sample analysed by a laboratory. HSE puts the starting position plainly: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." That sentence is about a building, so it tells you to treat the roofline with care, not that every board is asbestos.
The table sets out where each material sits on a roofline and which route HSE gives for taking it away.
| Material | Where it shows on a roofline | HSE route |
|---|---|---|
| Asbestos cement | Roof sheeting, tiles, gutters and downpipes | Non-licensed if carefully removed without breaking up |
| Asbestos insulating board | White panels fixed beneath the eaves as soffits | Removal is mostly licensed work |
A white soffit that was replaced with a modern board in recent years is a different case again, which is why we ask what you know of the house's history before we climb anything. When a laboratory report exists, keep it. It names the material, it saves repeating the test, and every later contractor on that roofline will want to read it. A survey of the whole house, rather than of one soffit, covers boards that were added in different decades.
What HSE allows for asbestos cement
For asbestos cement, HSE's non-licensed work page covers "asbestos cement products, (eg roof sheeting and rainwater goods) provided the material is carefully handled/removed without breaking up". It adds that the group takes in cement described as "weathered but not otherwise substantially damaged". Weathering alone does not move a gutter or a sheet out of that category, and sound cement can be taken off whole by hand, bagged and sealed on the spot. The same page lists, under maintenance work, "asbestos cement products (eg on roof sheeting, tiles and rainwater goods)", so a grey downpipe or a gutter on an old garage can fall in this group as well.
The category changes when the material breaks. HSE's notifiable non-licensed work page names asbestos cement "where the material has been substantially damaged or broken up", and removal that will leave it "substantially broken up, creating significant quantities of dust and debris", with the example of "dropping" an asbestos cement roof. Notifiable non-licensed work carries extra duties, so it matters whether a sheet comes off whole or in pieces. A cracked gutter lying on the ground is already a different job from the same gutter lifted off its brackets.
One more line from HSE's A14 guidance matters at the eaves of a garage or outbuilding: "AC roofs are always fragile". Sheets beside a soffit are never a place to stand, kneel or rest a ladder.
- Weathered but sound cement: non-licensed, handled whole
- Cracked or broken cement: notifiable non-licensed work
- Anything that would be dropped or smashed: not an option
Why AIB soffits are usually licensed work
For AIB the position is stricter. HSE's location list names the soffit panels, and its notifiable page makes one narrow exception: "short duration work to remove asbestos insulating board as part of a refurbishment project". Licensable work is work "on AIB, where the risk assessment indicates that it will not be of short duration". In practice, most AIB removal is licensed work, and the soffits along a whole house may not be a quick job.
So any licensed removal is handed on to a specialist company. Our part sits either side of theirs: we survey, photograph the board, the fixings and the eaves detail, and write down what we saw so the firm can plan. After their clearance, we fit the new soffit, fascia and gutters and finish the rest of the roof. Our written price covers our share as one total, and the specialist company quotes its own work separately, because it is a separate contract. Ask each of them to say what the price includes.
Until a sample has been analysed, treat any suspect board as if it contained asbestos:
- do not drill, sand, scrape or brush it
- do not jet wash it or scrub it with a stiff brush
- leave a damaged or loose panel where it is, and keep children and pets out of the area below
- photograph it from the ground and send the pictures to us
England and Wales: what happens to the waste
Once material is off the house, the rules for moving it work differently in each country. In England, the GOV.UK consignment-note guidance exempts "the movement of domestic hazardous waste (other than asbestos waste) from a domestic household to an initial collection point". The words in brackets matter: asbestos waste is outside the household exemption. In Wales, Natural Resources Wales says "contractors moving asbestos from a domestic property will need to use consignment notes", and a business based in Wales "must register" with NRW as a waste carrier.
A householder taking a small amount to a council site meets different local rules:
- Herefordshire, in England: the Hereford and Leominster recycling centres take asbestos that is double bagged or sealed in plastic sheeting. Booking is open to Herefordshire residents only, and trade loads are turned away.
- Monmouthshire, in Wales: a householder with a small amount is sent to Five Lanes or Llanfoist, where a slot must be booked in advance and the sites are for Monmouthshire residents only. Mitchel Troy cannot take it.
- Powys, in Wales: check with Powys County Council before moving anything.
A roofer's asbestos is trade waste, never household waste. HSE's waste guidance says "Use a lockable skip for asbestos", and "It is not good enough to throw sheeting over a standard skip". An open skip on the drive is not an option on either side of the border. If a skip is needed for the new roofline waste as well, the two loads are kept apart.
Roof work around a soffit that may be AIB
If your soffits are suspect, the order of work changes. Fascia and gutter replacement normally means taking the soffit down at the same time, so nothing on that run of roofline goes ahead until the board is identified. Roof repairs elsewhere on the house can carry on, because they do not disturb the eaves boards, though the scaffold is best left standing until the soffit is settled, so a second erection is avoided. Any scaffold standing on the public highway requires a scaffold licence (Highways Act 1980 s169), and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder.
- We survey from the ladder or scaffold and photograph the board, the fixings and the eaves.
- A sample goes to a laboratory for analysis, arranged by you or by a surveyor you choose.
- If the result is AIB, a firm licensed for the work removes it, and we wait for their clearance before we start.
- We fit the new soffit, fascia and gutters, and leave the site tidy.
The replacement is a chance to put ventilation right. Where high resistance underlay sits over a cold roof, Marley's eaves figure is "25mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of 15° or less" and "10mm" for steeper pitches. Our guide to soffit vents and roof ventilation explains the openings.
What shifts the price is the number of elevations, the access needed, the type of replacement board and the licensed firm's own scope. A quote should state plainly whether VAT and scaffold sit inside the total.
What to do before anyone visits
There is little you need to do, and some things to avoid. Your own notes help the survey.
- Write down when the house was built, and any refurbishment you know of, including who fitted the soffits and roughly when the roof edge was last altered.
- Keep any asbestos survey report from a purchase or a previous contractor.
- Photograph the soffits from the ground, close enough to show panel edges and fixings.
- Leave the boards unpainted, undrilled and unwashed in the meantime.
- Tell anyone else who works at the eaves, such as a window cleaner or an aerial fitter, what you have been told.
If a piece has already fallen, leave it where it landed and keep people away. Ring us with the photographs, or contact your council's environmental health team for advice on a household fragment. Our guide on whether your soffits could contain asbestos goes through the clues, and our note on signs of rotten fascias covers the timber that sits beside the soffit.
HSE's page on where asbestos is found lists the roofline materials, and its non-licensed work page sets out the cement rules in full. A buyer or seller with a pre-2000 house on the market may want the survey on file before roofline work starts, because the buyer's own surveyor is likely to raise the question of the eaves boards. Each of these steps takes a few minutes and keeps the later decisions straightforward. If the house changed hands recently, the seller's paperwork may already hold an answer.
