A flat roof that has started to leak puts its owner in a bind. A small repair costs little and may buy several more seasons. A new roof costs far more and settles the matter for a generation. Spending on a repair that was never going to hold is money lost, and replacing a roof that only needed a patch is money wasted. The skill lies in telling the two apart.
We make that call by reading the roof, not by guessing from the age. A felt roof of twelve years may be sound where it was laid well and drained properly, and a five-year-old roof can be finished where it stands in water. What counts is how far the failure has spread, whether the deck beneath is dry, and whether water is leaving the roof as it should.
The sections below cover the signs, the case for each choice, what the published costs say, and what Building Regulations ask once a roof is replaced. This guide belongs to our flat roofing service, and the answer on ponding water on a flat roof deals with one of the most important signs.
Reading an ageing flat roof
The surface tells most of the story, if you know what to look at. Some signs are minor and local. Others show that the whole covering is spent.
| Sign | What it may mean |
|---|---|
| One split or blister | A local fault that may be repairable |
| A lifted seam or edge | Bond failure at one line, repairable if the deck is dry |
| Cracks across the surface | The covering is ageing across its width |
| Standing water after rain | The fall is wrong or the deck has dipped |
| A soft or spongy feel | Water has reached the deck or the insulation |
Inside the building, stains on the ceiling that spread, return or sag are worth taking seriously, and so is a damp smell in the room below. A single drip after a storm is a different thing from a ceiling that has stained in several places over a season. Take photographs of any stain with a coin or ruler beside it and the date, so that a change can be seen later. A mark that has not moved for a year is reassuring, and one that has doubled in a month is not.
It also helps to know what the roof is made of. Felt, rubber and fibreglass age differently, and each has its own repair route: felt cracks and blisters as it dries out, rubber tends to fail at seams and edges rather than in the open, and fibreglass fails where the deck moves. Our answer on whether EPDM can be patched shows how a repair differs by material.
When a patch is the right buy
A repair is the right choice when the fault is local and the roof beneath it is sound. That means a single split, a lifted seam, a failed collar round a pipe, a worn flashing or a short length of open edge, on a roof whose deck is dry and whose surface is otherwise intact.
These conditions point to a repair:
- the leak traces to a single place that we can point out on the roof
- the deck is dry and firm when probed around the fault
- water is not ponding anywhere on the surface
- the covering is within a plausible working life for its material
- earlier repairs, if any, are few and are holding
Repairs differ by covering. Felt can be patched with a bonded section or a sealed strip. Rubber takes an adhesive patch, though old rubber can be harder to bond to. Fibreglass is ground back and re-laminated, then topcoated. In each case the aim is to restore the waterproofing at the fault and disturb nothing else.
When a repair is the sensible option, that is what we recommend, even though it is the smaller job. You see the photographs of the fault, you see the repair priced as one written total, and you decide. A patch with a realistic expectation of the time it should buy is worth more than a promise that it will last for ever. We tell you what the repair should achieve, what it will not cure and what to watch for afterwards, such as a stain returning in the same corner after heavy rain.
When replacement is the sound choice
Replacement becomes the better choice when the faults are no longer local. Patching a roof that is failing everywhere is a series of small bills that never ends the problem, and each visit disturbs the covering a little more.
Signs that point to replacement:
- cracks, blisters or splits across much of the surface
- wet insulation or soft boards, which a surface patch cannot cure
- ponding that persists, because the deck has dipped or the fall was never right
- repairs that keep coming back in different places
- a covering that has passed the working life published for its material
Lifespans in print are ranges that do not agree with one another, so both are shown.
| Covering | HomeBuilding | Less |
|---|---|---|
| Torch-on felt | 10-15 years | 10 to 20 |
| EPDM rubber | 25-30 years | 30 to 50 |
| GRP fibreglass | 25-30 years | 25 to 40 |
These are ranges, not promises. A roof near the far end of its range can still be repairable, and a younger one can need replacing. When a whole roof is replaced, it is the right moment to correct the fall, renew the upstands and edge trims and add insulation, since the deck is open anyway. The deck is also the moment to check how water leaves the roof, since an outlet that is too small or a gutter that is set high will undo a new covering. Our guide to flat roof replacement cost looks at the price side.
What the published costs say
Nothing published prices your roof, but the figures that exist show the gap between mending and replacing. They come from third parties, with their dates, and none is a quote from us.
- Which? (November 2025 survey, ex VAT) gives £1,400-£3,500 for a felt roof on a 6m by 3m single garage.
- MyJobQuote gives an average flat roof replacement of between £1,500 and £6,000 in 2026 (20 October 2026), felt at £80 to £120 per m², and rubber at around £1,050.
- Checkatrade gives repair rates of £120 to £170 per m² for EPDM and £130 to £180 per m² for GRP (June 2026, ex VAT, up to 3 m²).
Read these with care. The per-square-metre figures describe a small repair area. Multiplying one by the size of your roof would give a misleading sum, so we leave that to the survey. The replacement ranges are wide because roofs differ in size, in the state of the deck, in access and in what is laid.
The comparison that matters is not repair price against replacement price on the day. It is the total over the years. A repair that costs little and holds for a long time is good value. A repair that has to be done again each winter costs more than the new roof it was meant to avoid. We tell you which of the two we expect your roof to be, and why.
After the survey you receive a written total price, and it also shows whether VAT and scaffold are inside it.
The rules when you replace the roof
Mending a small area may not raise a Building Regulations question. Replacing a covering does, and the two nations set the test differently.
- In England, the Planning Portal puts the threshold at "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof"; an application is not normally needed under both.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."
A new waterproof layer for a flat roof is renovation under Approved Document L, whichever side of the border the house stands. In England, Table 4.3 gives 0.35 as the threshold and 0.16 as the improved U-value, and paragraph 4.13 allows the lowest feasible value, generally not worse than 0.7, where reaching 0.16 is not feasible or would take longer than 15 years to repay. In Wales, Table 11.1 gives 0.16 and not worse than 0.35 where 0.16 is not feasible, whole-element improvement applies where more than 50% of the element is renovated, and the test of payback is within 15 years.
Both editions are due to be replaced. AD L 2026 starts on 24 March 2027 in England, and the Welsh successor starts on 4 March 2027. Until those dates the current tables apply, and we quote against the edition in force.
We check with building control before work starts, either the council or a registered building control approver, and we pass their answer on to you.
What the survey records and what you are shown
A decision on patching or replacing should rest on evidence, so the survey records it. We go onto the roof, around the edges and, where we can, into the room below. For a pitched roof, the equivalent question is repair or re-roof, and our roof replacement page covers it.
- the extent of the damage, mapped on the roof and photographed
- the deck, probed for soft areas and checked for damp
- the fall, and any places where water stands
- the upstands, trims and outlets, where early failure starts
- any earlier repairs, and how they have held
You are shown the photographs and given a straightforward explanation of what each means, including what we could not see: a deck under an intact covering is judged by probing and by moisture checks, not by sight, and the report says where that limit applies. We then put the choice to you in writing: a repair, with what it should achieve and what it will not, or a replacement, with the build-up we propose. Each comes as one total price.
If you want a second view, the photographs and the written findings are yours to give to anyone you choose. A roof can be surveyed from the room below as well as from above, and a survey that looks only at the top can miss what the ceiling shows. It is your roof and your decision.
Whichever option you choose, we clear the site and take the waste away.
