01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Valley and box gutters

Valley and box gutters on commercial roofs

A valley or box gutter carries the rain from two roofs through one channel. This guide covers the linings, the falls and the outlets we check, and when a relining is the right answer.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

On a shop, a unit, a hall or a block with a pitched roof, the water from two slopes can meet in one internal channel. Where two pitched slopes meet at an angle, that channel is a valley gutter. Where it runs behind a parapet or between a roof and a wall, it is a box gutter, a flat-bottomed trough with upright sides. The channel is lined in a waterproof material, and the lining is what keeps the building dry.

Because so much roof drains through one narrow line, a fault here lets in more water than a fault on an open slope. The channel is also hard to see from the ground, so a leak can run for a while behind a parapet before it shows inside.

This guide explains what the linings are, how the falls and outlets work, and how we decide between a repair and a new lining. These gutters are part of our commercial roofing work, and each job is priced from its survey.

Valley, box, parapet and tapered: the terms

The words overlap, so it helps to fix them. A pitched valley gutter sits in the angle between two sloping roofs, with the covering cut and lapped over its edges. A box gutter is a trough with a flat bottom and vertical sides. A parapet gutter is a box gutter set against the inside face of a parapet wall. A tapered gutter changes depth along its length so that the floor falls towards the outlet even where the building is level.

Each has a floor, called the sole, with sides rising from it. The sole is lined end to end with one material, then dressed up the sides under a flashing or a roof covering. The outlet is where the channel empties, normally through a hopper head into a downpipe, or through a drain set in the sole itself. An overflow is a second outlet set a little higher, so that a blocked main outlet does not flood the building.

The overflow matters on a commercial roof because a box gutter holds a lot of water. Blocked at the outlet, it fills to the top of its sides, then spills into the building or over the parapet. Our guide on why a box gutter leaks goes through the signs. The first thing we look at is whether the outlet and the overflow are clear and whether either has been moved or blocked since the roof was built.

Linings: lead, membrane, GRP and zinc

Four coverings go into gutters of this kind, and each has its own life and its own weak points.

  • Lead sheet, worked to the profile of the channel and joined with rolls or steps.
  • A single-ply or felt membrane, welded or bonded into the sole and sides.
  • GRP, a fibreglass lining formed in place.
  • Zinc sheet, joined with folded seams.

On lifespans, none of these is a promise. HomeBuilding and Less publish lead flat-roof ranges, which do not carry across to a valley or box gutter. MyJobQuote says correctly installed lead flashing "can last" for over 80 years. VMZinc, the maker, says "when correctly designed and installed a zinc roof can last in excess of 100 years". EPDM is 25-30 years in HomeBuilding and 30 to 50 in Less, and GRP is 25-30 in HomeBuilding and 25 to 40 in Less.

A lead gutter is worth keeping where it can be. On an old building in a conservation area, lead may also be the covering the building was designed for. The question we answer at the survey is not which material is best in the abstract. It is which lining suits this channel, this fall and this building, and what the rules on that side of the border ask for.

Where a membrane or GRP lining has split along a seam, a local repair can be reasonable. Where the whole lining has gone brittle or lifted, a new one is the sounder buy.

The joints matter as much as the sheet. A lining laid in one length with few joints has fewer places to fail than one made from many short pieces.

Lead codes for gutters

Lead sheet is sold by code, which is a thickness. Royston Lead's cast-lead table lists six codes and says what each is used for, in letters: soakers (A), flashings (B), a pitched valley gutter (C), a parapet, box or tapered valley gutter (D) and dormers (E). A gutter is not a place to guess at a thinner sheet. The table makes the choice plain.

Royston Lead codes and their printed uses
CodeThicknessPrinted uses
31.32 mmA, recommended for lead soakers only
41.80 mmA B C E
52.24 mmB C D E
62.65 mmB C D E
73.15 mmC D E
83.55 mmC D E

So Code 3 is for soakers only. Code 4 is listed for a pitched valley gutter (C) but not for a parapet, box or tapered gutter (D), which starts at Code 5. A parapet or box gutter is, by this table, a Code 5 to 8 job. We read the code from the existing lead if there is any, and we say which code we propose before a price is agreed.

Lead roofs fall outside BS 6229, which covers membranes only, and Approved Document C cites BS 6915 for lead. Neither document is a substitute for the supplier's table when the code is chosen.

The heavier codes cost more per square metre, but a thicker sheet in a long box gutter is less likely to crack as the building moves with the seasons. That is a reason to match the code to the length and the exposure of the channel and not to whichever sheet is on the merchant's shelf.

Falls, outlets and why they leak

Water must be able to run to the outlet. NFRC says BS 6229:2025 sets "a minimum 1:80 finished fall for general roof areas and internal gutters", and the standard covers flexible membranes only. IKO gives 1:40 as the fall to design for. For the ordinary rainwater gutters on the outside of a building, Brett Martin gives "1mm for every 600mm".

When a valley or box gutter leaks, the causes fall into a few families:

  • a blocked outlet or a missing overflow, so the water rises over the sides
  • a split, a lifted seam or a cracked joint in the lining
  • a short or sunken fall, so the channel holds a pool that wears the lining
  • failed upstands or flashings where the sides meet a wall or parapet
  • rot in the timber floor or boards underneath, after a long leak

A tapered gutter that has lost its fall, because the boards beneath have sagged, will hold water even when the lining is intact. That is a build fault, and a patch on the lining does not cure it.

To find where a leak enters, we use a controlled water test, low on the gutter first and then higher, while someone watches inside. Our page on finding leaks on large roofs describes that method. We photograph each finding and show you before anything is agreed.

Debris is one cause to rule out first, so a gutter that drains slowly is cleared and watched through the next heavy shower before we recommend anything larger.

Reading the building from inside

A gutter you cannot see from the ground can still be read from the inside of the building. The ceilings, the walls and the loft or roof void all carry marks that point back to the channel.

We look for these signs:

  • brown rings or bubbled paint on the ceiling below a parapet or valley line
  • damp plaster at the top of a wall that runs under a box gutter
  • tide marks on the timber under the sole, or soft boards that give when pressed
  • daylight, or a draught, where the gutter lining meets a wall
  • efflorescence, the white salt bloom, on the brickwork under a parapet

Where the building has a roof void, the underside of the gutter boards can be inspected directly. Wet timber there tells us the leak has been running for a while and that the boards need to be checked before a new lining goes on. A new lining over rotted boards is wasted money.

Outside, we map every outlet and every downpipe, and we trace where each one discharges. A downpipe that ends at a blocked drain, or that has been boxed in and forgotten, can fill a gutter quietly. We check this by running water through the system once the roof has been cleared.

We photograph each mark with its location, so the pictures can be matched to the roof plan. You see them before any price is given.

Repair, reline or rebuild, and the approvals

A repair is right when the lining is sound and the fault is local: a lifted seam, a split at a corner or a blocked outlet. A reline is right when the lining has failed across its length but the fall and the boards beneath are sound. A rebuild is right when the timber floor or the fall is the problem, because a new lining over a wrong fall will pool again.

Access is the main cost driver on a commercial building. A box gutter behind a parapet can need a scaffold or a mobile platform, and a scaffold standing on the carriageway is licensed under section 169 of the Highways Act 1980, which we arrange with our scaffolder. The scaffold is carried in the written quote, and each job is priced from its survey as a single written total, because no two channels are alike.

On approvals, the border matters. In England, the Planning Portal asks for Building Regulations approval where a new covering is heavier "by 15 per cent or more". In Wales, the Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." On both sides, roofs also count as thermal elements in the Building Regulations 2010, so a new lining can bring an insulation question with it, and we ask building control about that before the work is priced.

Before the work starts we also check three things: for asbestos, on a building built or refurbished before 2000, as HSE advises; for nesting birds, because section 1 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 protects an occupied or half-built nest from being "intentionally" damaged; and for who owns the roof, if the gutter is shared with a neighbour.

Valley and box gutter questions

How do you tell a valley gutter from a box gutter?

A valley gutter sits in the angle where two sloping roofs meet, with the covering lapped over its edges. A box gutter is a flat-bottomed trough with upright sides, sometimes behind a parapet or between a roof and a wall. Both are lined and both drain to an outlet, so the checks are similar.

Can a leaking box gutter be patched, or must it be relined?

A local split or a lifted seam can be patched when the rest of the lining is sound. If the lining has gone brittle along its length, or the fall has sunk so water pools, a patch will not last. We show you photographs of the lining so you can see which case it is.

Which lead code is used in a parapet or box gutter?

Royston Lead's table lists Codes 5, 6, 7 and 8 under D, parapet, box and tapered valley gutter. Code 4 is listed for pitched valley gutters but not for D, and Code 3 is for soakers only. We state the code in the written price, once the existing gutter has been checked.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing