In brief
Repair when the sheets are sound and the faults are local, such as failed fixings, open laps or a few holes. Overclad, which means fitting a new covering over the old one, when the structure can carry the added weight and the old sheets are not asbestos cement that would be drilled through. Replace when the sheets or their supports have failed. A survey decides which, and the written price comes after it, as one total.
When repair is the right answer
A profiled metal roof is made of long sheets with ridges and troughs that give them strength, fixed to rails (purlins) that span the building. Faults on these roofs can be local: a line of fixings with failed seals, a lap that has opened, a rooflight edge, a hole where something fell, a gutter joint. Where the sheets themselves are sound, repairing those faults is the cheaper route, and that is the advice you get.
The survey for a repair checks and photographs:
- the laps and side seals, along their whole length
- fixings, for loose, missing or corroded heads
- the cut edges and any coating that has gone
- rooflight junctions and flashings
- the purlins and structure, from inside
If the faults are many and spread right across a slope, repair stops being the cheaper route, because each new patch sits beside old metal of the same age. That is the point to price the other two options alongside. Our answer on what a commercial roof report includes shows how the findings are laid out so that the three routes can be compared fairly.
When overcladding fits
Overcladding means fitting a new weathering layer over the existing roof sheets instead of stripping them. It keeps the building in use during the work and avoids opening the whole roof above stock or machinery. It suits a roof whose supporting steel or timber is sound and can take extra weight, and whose old sheets are failing as a covering rather than as a structure.
Two checks come first. The first is weight. The Planning Portal's test in England is whether a new covering makes the roof 15 per cent or more heavier, and Welsh Approved Document A sets the line at "more than 15%". A structural check and a word with building control therefore sit ahead of the specification. In England that means the council's service or a registered building control approver, and in Wales the council's service or a registered approver.
The second check is what the old sheets are. For a unit built or refurbished before 2000, HSE says to assume asbestos is present, and fixing a new layer through asbestos cement sheets is work on those sheets. The full picture is in overcladding an industrial roof.
When replacement is needed
Replacement means stripping the old sheets and fixing new ones. It is the answer when the covering and the structure beneath have both reached the end of their useful life, when the purlins cannot carry another layer, or when the old sheets are damaged and there is nothing sound to build on.
On a roof of asbestos cement the stripping becomes its own piece of work. HSE treats careful lifting without breakage as non-licensed and treats broken or badly damaged sheets as notifiable. The sheets are always fragile, so access is planned first. Asbestos waste from a business goes out in a lockable skip under a registered carrier, with consignment paperwork, on both sides of the border.
Replacement is also the time to correct falls and details that were wrong from the start, which a patch or an overclad cannot do. Our guide to profiled metal roof sheets covers types, laps and fixings.
The job is costed after the survey and you receive one written total, which includes the old sheets being taken away and the site left clear.
How the survey chooses between them
| Option | Fits when | The survey checks |
|---|---|---|
| Repair | Sheets sound, faults local | Laps, fixings, edges, rooflights |
| Overclad | Structure sound and able to take weight | Purlins, the weight added, what the old sheets are |
| Replace | Sheets and supports have failed | Structure, access, waste route, falls |
A commercial roof of this kind is priced once it has been looked at, because its size, height and condition drive the figure. Zinc is the one metal here with a published lifespan: its maker, VMZinc, says a correctly designed and installed roof can last in excess of 100 years. That is a different material from profiled steel, and it is a maker's statement, not a term for yours.
A commercial roof's age, exposure and use all enter the judgement. If a repair is enough, the repair is what is recommended. If it is not, the photographs show why, and the same photographs support the choice between the other two routes. Repair, overclad and replace each get a short written account, with what the roof needs now and what it is likely to need next, so the decision rests on the building and not on a sales pitch. The whole service sits under our commercial roofing pages.
