01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Overcladding

Overcladding an industrial roof: when it suits

Overcladding fixes new sheets over an old roof instead of stripping it. This guide covers when that suits an industrial unit, when it does not, and what building control looks at.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

Overcladding means fitting a new weatherproof roof over the existing one, rather than stripping the old sheets first. On an industrial unit it is a well-known route, because the building stays in use, nothing is lifted off a worn roof into the weather, and the old sheets stay as a deck until the new layer is on. It is not a cure-all. The roof underneath has to be able to carry the new layer, and the new layer can bring moisture and fire questions of its own.

This guide is about overcladding an industrial roof: where it suits a unit, where replacement is the better buy, and what to settle before the order goes in. It covers the special case of asbestos cement sheets, the effect of added weight on the structure, the insulation and condensation questions, and the building control position in England and in Wales.

Overcladding is one of three routes for a failing metal roof, alongside repair and full replacement, and the choice between them is set out in our guide to repair, overclad or replace a metal roof. The wider range of work is under commercial roofing.

What overcladding is made of

A typical overclad system has three parts. First come the fixing brackets or spacers, fastened through the old sheets into the purlins (the horizontal beams of steel or timber that carry the sheets). Next comes any insulation laid between or over the brackets. Last come the new profiled sheets, lapped and fixed to the brackets, with new flashings and trims at the ridge, eaves and gable edges.

The old roof is left in place, so the work is done from above with the building still occupied. That is the main reason owners choose it: production, storage or tenants carry on below. It also means the old sheets remain as a fragile layer under the new one, and a fall-through risk on the new roof is replaced by the same risk during the work itself, which is why our guide to fragile roofs and rooflights matters before any overcladding job begins.

The pieces that decide the result:

  • the brackets or spacers, which set the gap between old and new
  • the insulation, if the job is to improve the thermal performance of the roof
  • the new sheets, matched to the span between purlins
  • the sealed laps and flashings, which keep water out at the joints
  • the rooflight sheets, which must be changed to suit the new profile

None of these is hard to describe, and all of them are easy to get wrong when the existing roof has not been surveyed first.

When overcladding suits the roof underneath

Overcladding earns its place when the leaks come from the surface of the roof and the frame below is in good order. The test is a survey from inside and out, looking at the purlins, the rafters or portal frame, the fixings and the condition of the sheets between them.

Overcladding or replacement: the usual dividing line
Finding at surveyPoints towards
Sound purlins, sheets leaking at laps and fixingsOvercladding
Sound frame, sheets still holding their shapeOvercladding
Rotted or bent purlinsReplacement of the deck
Sheets sagging between supportsReplacement or new supports
Asbestos cement that must come down for other reasonsRemoval, then new roof

If the frame is not up to the job, overcladding only hides the problem. Fitting a new layer to a purlin that has rusted through is a waste of the money spent on the new sheets. When the survey finds that, you see the photographs and a price for replacement instead.

Another sign that favours overcladding is an old roof with some leaks at the same kind of joint, for example the end laps or the cut edges of sheets. A new roof removes every old joint from the water's path at once. Rust creeping in from the cut edges of old sheets is the kind of failure that points this way, and a new layer takes every one of those edges out of play.

Overcladding an asbestos cement roof

Overcladding can be considered for asbestos cement (AC) roofs, because it avoids breaking the sheets up. HSE's guidance sheet A14 asks the question directly in its AC section: "Can you overlay sheets with non-asbestos material instead of removing the AC?" If so, it says to attach the new material to the existing purlins and to avoid drilling through the AC. That advice is for work on a small scale, and the same sheet says a large job needs a full risk assessment and plan of work.

Several things follow from that for a unit roof:

  • the brackets are fixed to the purlins, so the fixing positions are found from the structure, and the sheets are not drilled to hold anything
  • the AC stays on the building, so it must still be assumed to be there for every later job, and recorded for whoever owns or lets the unit next
  • the old sheets remain fragile, because the HSE treats AC roofs as fragile at all times, and nobody should stand on them during the fitting of the new layer
  • if any sheet breaks during the work, the job changes category and the plan is revisited before anyone goes on

Overcladding also postpones removal rather than avoiding it. When the unit is eventually demolished or re-roofed, the AC still has to come off, probably under a more complicated site layout, with a new roof to protect first. For some owners that is acceptable, and for others the sensible time to remove the AC is now.

The decision belongs to the owner, and the survey should say which route the roof allows. Our guide to asbestos cement sheet roofs on industrial units covers the categories of work and the waste routes in full.

Added weight and the structure

A new layer of sheets, brackets and insulation weighs more than the old roof alone. Approved Document A, the part of the Building Regulations on structure, deals with this for re-covering. Its paragraph 4.4 counts an increase of more than 15% in the loading upon the roof as a significant change, and the Welsh Approved Document A repeats the same words for Wales. In England and in Wales the lesson is the same: the added load has to be assessed, and where it counts as significant, the structure has to be checked.

On a lightweight steel roof the added weight of a metal overlay is modest, but it is still weight, and it sits on brackets that concentrate load at the purlins. Snow, wind uplift and the weight of people working on the roof during the job all act on the same frame. The fixings also matter: a bracket that needs a long fastener into a corroded purlin is not holding what it appears to hold.

What the survey should confirm before an overcladding order is placed:

  1. the type and condition of the purlins and their cleats
  2. the span between purlins, which sets the new sheet gauge
  3. whether the added load is likely to count as a significant change
  4. whether any plant, ducting or sprinkler pipework hangs from the old roof and needs to be taken into account

If the answer to the third question is yes, a structural engineer's calculation goes with the building control application. That is raised early, because it changes the programme.

Insulation, condensation and fire between the layers

Two roofs on top of each other can hold moisture in the gap. Warm, damp air from the unit rises, meets the cool underside of the new sheets and condenses. How much moisture gets there depends on the building's use, the quality of the old roof's seal and whether the gap is ventilated or closed. The design of the overlay decides that, and BS 5250, the British Standard on managing moisture in buildings, is the reference for it. Cold, damp uses such as wash-down areas, food rooms and swimming-pool halls need particular thought.

The Building Regulations 2010 treat a roof as a thermal element, and the two nations apply that idea to re-covering in different ways:

  • In England, building control looks at whether the overlay is building work that affects the thermal element; ask the council or a registered building control approver before the order goes in.
  • In Wales, the Welsh Government says that, as a roof is defined as a thermal element, work to re-cover a roof should also include for improving the thermal insulation properties of the roof. It also lists a significant difference in the new covering's fire performance as a reason for approval.

Fire is the third question. A new sheet and insulation build-up has its own fire classification, and the combination of old and new layers needs to be looked at as a whole. We pass the product data to building control, who confirm the position on that side of the border.

Wherever a roof is insulated, the written quote says what is included, and one total price covers the brackets, the sheets and the finishing details.

What sets the price of an overcladding job

A per-square-metre figure does not carry from one building to the next, so this section names what moves the price. Access is the first factor: a roof that needs a platform or a scaffold at every elevation costs more to work on than one with a clear apron. Area and height come next, then the number of rooflights, ridge ventilators, flues and plant stands that have to be flashed round.

Condition of the existing roof is the third driver. Sound steel under the old sheets keeps the job simple. Repairs to purlins, new cleats or isolated sheet replacement before the overlay go on the same written price once they are found at survey.

For a unit that stays in use, the working method also counts. Fitting the roof in bays, protecting stock and machinery below, and agreeing the working hours with the site manager all feature in the programme. The finishing details cost real time as well: eaves gutters, verge trims, ridge cappings and the tie-in to adjoining buildings, where the new roof line meets a wall or a neighbouring roof at a different height.

For a unit in England, the owner should ask whether a building control application is needed and whether a fee applies; for a unit in Wales, the same question goes to the council's building control team or a registered building control approver. Either way, the written price follows the survey and says whether VAT and any scaffold are included.

Overcladding a unit roof: questions

Does overcladding mean the old roof is never touched?

The old sheets stay in place, but brackets go into the purlins, and HSE says to avoid drilling through AC, and rooflights, flashings and edge trims can need work. The old roof also has to be surveyed before anything is ordered, since a weak frame or damaged sheets can rule overcladding out.

Can an asbestos cement roof be overclad?

HSE guidance sheet A14 asks whether sheets can be overlaid with non-asbestos material instead of being removed, with the new material fixed to the existing purlins and drilling through the AC avoided. The asbestos stays on the building, so it is recorded and assumed present for later work.

Is building control involved when a roof is overclad?

It can be. Added weight, insulation and fire performance are all building control concerns. In England, ask the council's building control team or a registered building control approver. In Wales, the Welsh Government says re-covering a roof should include improving its insulation, so the council or an approver is asked first.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing