The Welsh border runs through the country our roofers work in. A semi in Ledbury and a semi in Abergavenny can look alike from the pavement. The law that governs a re-roof on each is not the same, because building regulations, planning rules and listed-building law are devolved, and Wales sets its own.
That matters for the survey, for the paperwork and sometimes for the price. A roofer who learned the English test and applies it on a Monmouthshire street will give the wrong answer, and so will the reverse. At Horizon Roofing Hereford we work out which side your house stands on first, then apply the rules of that side.
What follows goes through the main differences point by point. Every rule carries its country inside its own sentence, which stops any line being applied on the wrong side of the border. The post explains where to look. It is not legal advice, and the council for your address has the last word on what your project needs.
Which side of the border is your house?
The side is set by the council area your address sits in, not by how near the Welsh hills it feels. Check your council tax bill or the council named on your planning papers, then use the table below to see which column of this post is yours.
| Side | Council areas in our radius | Rules to use |
|---|---|---|
| England | Herefordshire, Worcestershire, Gloucestershire (Forest of Dean, Tewkesbury) and south Shropshire | English Building Regulations, Planning Portal guidance, GPDO 2015 |
| Wales | Monmouthshire, Powys and the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park | Welsh Government guidance, Welsh approved documents, GPDO 1995 as applied in Wales |
Two edge cases catch people out. The Wye Valley National Landscape crosses the border, and Herefordshire Council's page places its team in Monmouth. A National Landscape is a label for the land and has no power to decide applications: the Malvern Hills National Landscape says it is the job of "the individual Local Planning Authorities" to decide applications, not the National Landscape team. The country your house stands in still decides which rules you follow.
The Bannau Brycheiniog National Park lies in Wales. For any work within the Park, ask the National Park Authority as well as the council. Our guide to roof work inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park treats the Park in its own right, and a roofer who works both sides should be able to tell you which council covers your road.
Re-roofing approval and insulation
Start with the first question to settle: does a re-roof need Building Regulations approval? In England, the Planning Portal's test has two limbs. Is less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope affected, and is less than 50 per cent of the roof affected? A yes to both means nothing normally to apply for. In Wales, the Welsh Government begins from the opposite end, saying that "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." Its roof page then sets a separate threshold for small repairs, which you should read on gov.wales for your own address.
Weight follows the same split. In England, the Planning Portal brings approval in once a new covering is 15 per cent heavier or more, while Approved Document A, paragraph 4.4, speaks of a loading increase "more than 15%". In Wales, the Welsh Approved Document A repeats "more than 15%", and slate replaced by tile is the Welsh Government's example of a swap that is likely to need approval.
| Case | In England | In Wales |
|---|---|---|
| New roof on an existing home | Approved Document L Table 4.2: 0.15 | Welsh Approved Document L Table 4.1: 0.13 |
| Renovated roof | Table 4.3: threshold 0.35, improved 0.16 | Table 11.1: 0.16, and not worse than 0.35 where 0.16 is not feasible |
| Next edition | From 24 March 2027 | From 4 March 2027 |
Both countries expect a roof window to reach a U-value of 1.4, or WER Band B, and set the rooflight figure at 2.2. Our guide to roof work approvals in England and Wales goes into the paragraphs.
Planning: roof windows, dormers and a change of covering
Planning law is where the border bites hardest. In England, GPDO 2015 Class C covers any other alteration to a dwellinghouse roof, so putting a new covering on a house is normally permitted development, and England's Class C asks for no match with the old materials. Dormers fall under Class B, which stops short of article 2(3) land: a conservation area, a National Landscape, a National Park or a World Heritage Site. Class C is not removed on that land.
In Wales the governing instrument is the 1995 General Permitted Development Order, still in use there. Its roof rules differ in four ways:
- Wales, Class C.2(a): the new materials must "so far as practicable match" how the existing ones look, so a covering of different appearance falls outside it.
- Wales, Class C.1(d): a roof light is not permitted development on article 1(5) land, that is, conservation areas, National Parks and National Landscapes, and World Heritage Sites.
- Wales, Class B.1(g): no permitted-development dormer on that same land.
- Wales, Class C.2(b): a side-slope window within 10.5 metres of the facing boundary must be obscure-glazed and non-opening, and the opening part may sit at least 1.7 metres above the floor.
The English rule is simpler. In England, Class C.2 makes every side-slope window obscure-glazed, whatever its distance from the boundary.
Flats have no householder permitted development rights in England. Listed status leaves Classes B and C available on either side of the border, but listed building consent is required as well. Our guide to planning permission for roof work in Herefordshire covers the English side in more detail.
Listed buildings, churches and monuments
Listed-building law changed in Wales on 4 November 2024. In England, work that would affect a listed building's special interest needs consent under the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, section 7. In Wales, sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 require works to be authorised by listed building consent. A roofer quoting for a Welsh listed house who cites the 1990 Act has the wrong law in front of them.
Churches in use follow different routes on each side, and some denominations are treated differently, as the table shows.
| Case | In England | In Wales |
|---|---|---|
| An Anglican parish church | Faculty jurisdiction | Faculty jurisdiction |
| United Reformed Church in use | Exempt, with its own system | Not exempt: listed building consent |
| Baptist chapel in use | Exempt only if a Schedule 1 trust corporation holds it | Exempt only if held by a named Baptist Union corporation |
| Scheduled monument | Secretary of State consent | Application to the Welsh Ministers |
In Wales a minister's house does not count as a religious building, so it needs listed building consent. A Unitarian or Quaker meeting house is handled under listed building consent in each country. And where a scheduled monument stands in the grounds of an exempt church in Wales, the notes to the 2023 Act say works to the monument still need scheduled monument consent, so a churchyard cross is worth a call before anyone sets up a scaffold.
Loft conversions and building control
A loft conversion brings fire safety rules into play. In England, Approved Document B (the 2019 edition incorporating 2020, 2022, 2025 and 2026 amendments) says in paragraph 2.5 that where a storey sits above 4.5 m the house needs one of two things: a stair enclosed in fire-resisting construction, or a top storey separated off and given a route of its own out to a final exit. Paragraph 2.23 offers sprinklers as an alternative for open-plan layouts, and escape windows under paragraph 2.10 apply only to storeys within 4.5 m of the ground.
In Wales, the Welsh Approved Document B (2006 edition incorporating 2010, 2016 and 2020 amendments) gives the same pair of choices in paragraph 3.6. Paragraph 3.20 lets automatic fire suppression stand in for protection to an open-plan area, alongside a partition and door that resist fire, and escape windows sit in paragraph 3.8.
Who checks the work also differs:
- In England, building control is done by the council or by a registered building control approver, and approvers register with the Building Safety Regulator (from 6 April 2024).
- In Wales, the Building Safety Regulator oversees approvers and inspectors for the Welsh Ministers, while the Welsh Ministers themselves regulate local authority building control.
- In Wales, a new building control regime started on 1 July 2026.
For a Powys address, ask the council's building control service or a registered building control approver which route suits the job. Private building control existed in England long before 2024. Only the registration scheme is new, so a firm that says otherwise has the date wrong. Whichever route applies, the roofer should be able to say who signs the work off before the first tile comes off.
Bats, waste, scaffold fees and who to ask
Four more points change at the border, each worth a minute before work starts:
- Bats: in England, licences come from Natural England. In Wales, they come from Natural Resources Wales.
- Asbestos waste: in England, the household consignment-note exemption is "other than asbestos waste". In Wales, NRW says "contractors moving asbestos from a domestic property will need to use consignment notes".
- Scaffold licences: in England, Herefordshire Council charges £167 for a maximum of 1 month per licence. In Wales, Monmouthshire County Council charges £108 as an administration fee and £27 per week to extend, and Powys runs its own scheme.
- Help with a dispute: in England and in Wales, Citizens Advice runs the consumer helpline on 0808 223 1133, and a Welsh-speaking adviser takes calls on 0808 223 1144.
None of these should hold up a job, but each is a place where a roofer new to the area can slip. Our scaffolder and we arrange the licence together, and the written quote states whether it sits inside the total.
Where you are unsure, ask the council for your address. In England, Herefordshire Council Building Control is on 01432 261938 for a Herefordshire address. In Wales, Monmouthshire County Council's duty planning officer answers queries about whether planning permission is needed, on 01633 644831. The right answer for your roof is the one that names your side of the border, and a roofer who can say which it is has done the groundwork.
