A house inside the National Park is not subject to a different roof from one outside it. The slates, the stone tilestones, the ridge and the flashings are the same. What changes is the paperwork around them, because Welsh planning law treats land in a National Park as a special category, and a few jobs that need no application elsewhere need one here.
That category is called article 1(5) land. The Welsh Government's technical guidance for householders defines the term as land in Wales within a National Park, a conservation area or an area of outstanding natural beauty. Roof lights and dormers are two jobs it catches, and the guide below deals with them directly. Re-roofing, chimneys, listed houses and bats are covered as well, because each has a Welsh rule of its own.
This page uses the Welsh rules only, since a house in the Park is in Wales. Where a question is the Authority's to answer, this page says so; put it to the National Park Authority before work begins. Our other roofing services are listed from the Horizon Roofing Hereford homepage.
What article 1(5) land changes for a roof
Welsh householder permitted development comes from the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 as it applies in Wales. Part 1 of its Schedule 2 gives Class B for roof enlargements such as dormers, and Class C for any other alteration to the roof. Inside the Park, both classes carry extra limits.
Two other Class C limits apply across Wales, Park or not. The alteration must not protrude more than 15 centimetres beyond the plane of the slope of the original roof, and it must not rise above the highest part of the original roof. Those limits are why a new roof light has to sit close to the slope.
For land inside the Park, planning applications go to the Park Authority. Building control is a separate question and stays with the council, so a single re-roof can involve two different offices, each with its own forms and its own questions about the work.
| Job | Permitted development inside the Park? | Where the rule sits |
|---|---|---|
| Re-covering in matching material | Normally yes | Class C, condition C.2(a) |
| Re-covering in a different-looking material | Ask the Park Authority | Class C, condition C.2(a) |
| A new roof light in a slope | No | Class C.1(d) |
| A dormer | No | Class B.1(g) |
| Removing a chimney | No | Class C.1(c)(vii) |
"Not permitted development" means a planning application is needed, not that the work is refused. The Authority decides each application on its merits.
Re-roofing inside the Park: the planning side
The Welsh Government's planning page for roofs says: "You do not normally need to apply for planning permission to re-roof your house". That rests on a condition. The Order's condition C.2(a) requires that the appearance of the materials used "so far as practicable match" the appearance of the materials on the existing dwellinghouse, and the Welsh Government's page puts it as materials that "match the appearance of those used on your existing roof" as far as possible.
In practice, that gives two cases:
- A slate roof re-covered in slate that looks like the old covering, or a stone-tiled roof re-covered in stone tilestones, sits comfortably inside Class C.
- A change to a covering that looks different, such as clay or concrete tiles on a roof that was slate, is not covered, so ask the Park Authority first.
Welsh slate and stone roofs are "predominantly double-lapped" in SPAB's advice note, which also records that plenty of stone roofs in the region have since been recovered in other stones or even in slate. A roof that has lost its original covering has no "existing appearance" to match in the usual sense, so which look counts is a question for the Authority.
Permitted development rights can also be withdrawn by an Article 4 direction. Check whether one applies with the council or the Park Authority before work starts, and read the Welsh Government planning page for roofs for the national summary.
Re-roofing inside the Park: Building Regulations
Planning permission and Building Regulations are separate tests, and a roof can pass one and still need the other. Re-roofing is dealt with by the Welsh Government in two places. The first page reads: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." The second, which deals with works to an existing roof, draws a 25 per cent line. Repair or re-covering below that figure, on a pitch or flat roof, is not normally something you apply for; above it, improving the roof's thermal insulation is the normal consequence.
Three further points matter on a Park house:
- A change of covering (the Welsh Government gives slate to tiles as its case) probably needs approval, so that structure, fire performance and energy use can all be looked at.
- Welsh Approved Document A treats a roof loading increase of "more than 15%" as a significant change, which means a structural check.
- Welsh Approved Document L sets 0.13 W/m²K for roofs added to existing homes (Table 4.1), and 0.16 for a renovated roof, not worse than 0.35 where 0.16 is not feasible (Table 11.1). A newer edition of that document takes effect on 4 March 2027.
For an address inside the Park, the question goes to the council's building control service or a registered building control approver. Building control is oversight of the work as it is built, and the Park Authority does not do it.
Read the Welsh Government roof page for the wording in full.
Roof lights and dormers: why the answer is an application
Outside protected land in Wales, a roof light can be permitted development. Inside the Park it cannot. Class C.1(d) of the Order excludes an alteration that consists of or includes "the insertion of a roof light into a roof slope" where the dwellinghouse is on article 1(5) land. The Welsh Government's technical guidance puts it plainly at paragraph 9.7: "Where houses are located on article 1(5) land or within World Heritage Sites, roof lights are not permitted."
Dormers are barred as well. Class B.1(g) excludes an enlargement where the dwellinghouse is on article 1(5) land. For that reason, a new dormer or roof window on a house in the Park has to go to the Park Authority as a planning application, however small.
Building Regulations are a second, separate hurdle. The Welsh Government says approval "will generally be needed for the installation of a new rooflight". Welsh Approved Document L, Table 4.1, fixes a roof window at 1.4 W/m²K (or Band B under the window energy rating scheme) and a rooflight at 2.2 W/m²K. Elsewhere in Wales a dormer is limited by volume, at 40 cubic metres for a terrace house and 50 cubic metres in any other case, but inside the Park those limits never come into play.
The terms differ in a useful way. A roof window is a hinged or pivoting window set in the slope that you can open and clean from inside. A rooflight is a fixed unit that does not open. Our roof window planning guide sets out the side-slope conditions for the places where roof lights are allowed.
Chimneys, listed houses and conservation areas
Chimneys are treated strictly. Class C.1(c) excludes "the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney", and, for a house on article 1(5) land, "the removal of a chimney". A stack that needs rebuilding or taking down in the Park therefore sits outside Class C. Where a repair ends and an alteration begins is for the Park Authority to say. Our guide to removing a chimney in Wales goes into the detail.
Neither class excludes a listed house, so it keeps both, but it needs listed building consent as well. Wales moved to the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 on 4 November 2024. Section 88(1) says that works to which the section applies must not be carried out unless they are authorised, and section 89 makes that authorisation listed building consent. Section 88(2)(a) is about alterations capable of affecting the special architectural or historic interest of the building. A chimney, a ridge or a new covering could each be caught by those words. Before any application we photograph the existing roof, and the pictures are sent in with it.
Conservation areas inside the Park add a layer. They are designated under Part 4 of the 2023 Act, and they are article 1(5) land in their own right. A listed house, or one inside a conservation area, is a matter for the council and for the Authority together. For how a repair is matched to that kind of house, see listed and heritage roofing.
Bats and birds in Park roofs
An older roof can suit bats and nesting birds, and the law protects both. For bats, Natural Resources Wales says: "All bat species are protected by law, including their breeding sites and resting places." It adds that work affecting a protected species in Wales needs a licence, applied for from Natural Resources Wales itself.
The offences are strict. Under section 9(4) of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, intentionally or recklessly disturbing a bat where it shelters, or blocking the way into it, is an offence. Under regulation 43 of the 2017 Habitats Regulations, a bat's breeding site or resting place is protected whether or not harm was intended.
Natural Resources Wales also explains that if you cannot avoid disturbing bats or damaging their roosts, you can apply for a species licence. Roof work such as lifting a ridge, stripping a verge or closing a gap under the eaves is the kind that can reach a roost.
Birds fall under section 1 of the same Act, which protects wild birds' nests that are occupied or under construction: removing, damaging or destroying one intentionally is an offence. Work beside a nest in use is held back until the birds have left it, and we plan the other slopes first. If you see bats or signs of them, tell us before work begins. Our short answers on who issues a bat licence and nesting birds and roof work give the detail.
