Every roofer is tempted by the bigger job, and every owner knows it. That is why the question of repair against replacement needs a method and not a sales pitch. The method here is plain: look at the roof from the skyline down, photograph what is wrong, work out whether the fault is one spot or the whole covering, and compare the price of putting it right with the price of starting again.
Neither answer is always right. A roof with three slipped tiles and sound timbers beneath does not need a new covering, and no sensible roofer would say it did. A roof with rusted fixings on every slope, brittle underlay and a leak that has come back three winters running is a roof where a fourth repair only postpones the argument. Between those poles lies a lot of ground, and the table below helps you place your own roof on it.
After the table we look at age, at what the survey inspects, at published prices side by side, and at the rules that switch on when a repair turns into a re-roof, in England or in Wales.
The decision in one table
Use the table as a first sort. It is not a verdict: a survey with photographs is what turns it into one.
| What the survey finds | Points to a repair | Points to replacement |
|---|---|---|
| Age of the covering | Well inside the range for its material | At or beyond the far end of that range |
| Slipped or cracked tiles | A few, in one area, with a cause that can be put right | Spread across several slopes, with no single cause |
| Underlay | Sound, with only local damage | Brittle, torn or perished across the roof |
| Nails and fixings | Firm, with surface rust only | Rusted through, so tiles slip as soon as they are touched |
| Leaks | One entry point, found and fixed | A leak that returns after repairs, in new places |
| Timbers | Dry and sound | Damp, soft or showing rot along the rafters or battens |
Read across a row and then down the page. One row on the right is a reason to look harder, not a reason to replace. Several rows on the right, on several slopes, is a different conversation. Equally, a column of ticks on the left does not mean the roof will last for ever; it means the next few winters are not likely to be dramatic.
Our answer on how long a roof repair should last explains what to expect from a repair that is done well, which helps when you are weighing it against the price of a new roof.
What age tells you, and what it does not
Age matters, but it is a range, not a date of death. The published figures are wide, and they disagree with each other, which is itself a warning not to treat any one number as a promise:
- Concrete tiles: Marley's figure is around 60 years for a roof tile, whereas HomeBuilding's is 40 to 50 years for plain concrete.
- Clay tiles: Marley reports a 60-year minimum life expectancy worked out by the BRE, and that number belongs to clay alone.
- Natural slate: HomeBuilding gives 100 or more years for Welsh slate, 75 to 100 years for Spanish slate and 50 to 80 years for reclaimed Welsh slate. SPAB considers a roof laid well in slate likely to last longer than 100 years.
For a stone-tiled roof, the useful question is not the date but the condition of the individual stones and the fixings beneath them.
What the range cannot tell you is the condition of this roof. A concrete tile roof at 35 years with sound underlay is in a better position than one at 25 with a blocked valley that has been wetting the batten for years. The age tells us where to start looking, and the survey decides.
Age also affects how a repair behaves, and how much a repair can promise. On an older covering, taking off one tile to replace it can disturb its neighbours, which is why repairs on old roofs are priced and planned with care. Our answer on repairing roofs on older Hereford homes goes into this.
Nails, underlay and repeated leaks
Three things decide most borderline cases, and all three are found by looking closely, not by guessing from the pavement.
Nails come first. Fixings can corrode over decades, and when they do, tiles hold by habit and not by strength. Lifting a tile at a few places on different slopes shows whether the nails are firm or have rusted through. If they have rusted through, patching individual tiles is a poor investment, because the neighbours are about to follow.
Underlay is the second check. It is the sheet laid beneath the tiles as a second barrier. A local tear can be mended, but underlay that has perished across a slope will fail again wherever you disturb it. Some older roofs were laid with none, which is how they were built and not a fault in itself.
Repeated leaks are the third, and the most telling:
- The same stain returning after a repair suggests the cause was never found.
- New stains in new places suggest a roof that is failing broadly.
- A leak that only appears in driving rain, or only in wind, narrows the search to flashings, verges and ridge joints.
We photograph every one of these, so the decision is made with your own slopes in front of you. If a repair is the cheaper sound choice, the report says that, and a new covering enters the conversation only when the roof leaves no other answer.
The costs side by side
The published ranges below are national, they come from different surveys, and none is a Hereford price or ours. Put together, they show how far apart a repair and a re-roof sit.
| What is priced | Published range | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| A handful of broken tiles replaced | £75 to £400 | Which?, November 2025, excluding VAT |
| Average roof repair | Around £650 | MyJobQuote, 2026 |
| Average new roof | Around £5,250 | MyJobQuote, 2026 |
| Replacing an entire roof, three-bed house | £7,000 to £21,000 | Which?, November 2025, excluding VAT |
| 65 m² semi, plain concrete tiles | £10,000 to £15,000 | HomeBuilding, 30 September 2025 |
| Welsh slate, same semi | Might reach £18,000 | HomeBuilding, 30 September 2025 |
The new-roof figures disagree widely, which is a reminder that a national average is a poor guide to one house. Size, access, covering, chimneys and scaffold all move the price. A roof with two chimneys and a valley makes a different job from a plain gable end, even when the floor areas match.
The useful comparison is not one repair against one re-roof. It is several repairs over the next few years against one re-roof now. If the survey shows two or three modest repairs that will hold, repairing is the better buy. If it shows a repair every winter, the sum starts to approach a new covering and buys less.
Once the survey is done, we hand over one written total that names scaffold and VAT, and the old material leaves with us.
Where repair ends and re-roofing begins
Patching a fault stands apart from stripping and re-covering the whole roof. Re-covering can bring approval into play, and the border decides how.
- For an English house, the Planning Portal draws two lines, under 25 per cent of the building envelope and under 50 per cent of the roof. Work that stays inside both lines normally needs no application.
- The Planning Portal also names a covering 15 per cent or more above the weight of the old one as a trigger for Building Regulations approval in England.
- For a Welsh house, the Welsh Government's guidance starts from the opposite position, that re-roofing will need Building Regulations approval in most situations. Its example of a likely trigger is changing slate to tiles.
- The Welsh guidance adds that roofs rank as thermal elements, so re-covering one should also improve its insulation.
A listed house adds a further step, and the statute differs. In England the control sits in section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. In Wales it sits in sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023, in force since 4 November 2024. Check with the council before any work starts on a listed roof, since consent is needed as well as any other approval.
For any Welsh address, and for an English one near the line, we check with the council's building control team before we start. Our post on how urgent a roof repair is helps with the timing, and roof repairs start from a survey that photographs every slope.
Questions for anyone who says the roof must go
Replacement is sometimes the right answer, and sometimes a bigger job than the roof needs. A short list of questions separates the two without any argument.
- Which part of the roof has failed, and can I see a photograph of it?
- Are the fixings rusted through, and where was that checked?
- What state is the underlay in, and was it looked at in more than one place?
- Are the timbers dry, and can you show me the loft?
- Why can the fault not be repaired and left to run for a few more years?
- Does the quote say whether scaffold and VAT are included?
- Who takes the old material away, and when?
A firm that is sure of its case answers each of these with a picture or a plain sentence. A firm that is selling a bigger job than you need gets vague on the fourth or fifth.
You are also entitled to ask for the work in stages where the roof allows it. Some roofs have a bad slope and a good one, and treating the bad slope first spreads the cost without leaving a weak point behind. Not every roof splits that way, so the survey has to say whether yours does. Where it does, we plan the stages so that nothing is left half done over a winter, and you know on each visit which slope is being worked on and which is still waiting.
