A bad roofer may not look bad on the doorstep. The ladder is clean, the van is tidy and the patter is friendly. What gives a poor job away is what is missing from the paperwork: no list of what will be done, no photograph of your own roof, a price given out loud and a start date that depends on you paying today.
So this post is not about spotting a type of person. It is a short method for checking any firm, ours included, in the order you would meet the problems. First the paper, then the pictures, then the price, then the rights you hold in law. Your rights are the part people forget, and for most of what follows they read the same either side of the Welsh border.
At Horizon Roofing Hereford you get one written total after a survey, along with photographs from your own slopes. Hold any other roofer's quote up against that. Whenever the law is different in Wales, the sentence names the country it has in mind. If anything below does not match what you have been offered, ask the firm to put the answer in writing before you pay a penny.
What the warning signs look like at the door
Some signs point to a problem straight away, and none of them needs any roofing knowledge to notice. A caller who arrives unasked and says they were doing a job nearby, or that they spotted a loose tile from the road, has started the conversation on their terms, not yours. A sound roof can look worn from the street, and a short walk along the pavement will not show a fault that needs fixing today.
Watch for the following, and treat two or more together as a reason to stop:
- Pressure to decide today, or a price that is only good while they are on the doorstep.
- A refusal to put the scope or the price on paper, or wording so vague that it fits any roof.
- Photographs taken on a phone that cannot be tied to your house, or a stock image offered as proof.
- A request for payment in cash, or for most of the money before any work has started.
- No address, no landline and no company name that you can look up for yourself.
None of these proves bad intent, but each one removes a protection. A roofer who will not write down what they plan to do cannot be held to it, and a firm that has vanished by the time of a callback cannot be asked to return.
Sound roofers also call on spec from time to time, so judge the paperwork, not the manner. Ask for a written quote after a proper survey, and take your time over it. A real fault will still be there next week, and a temporary cover for a leak costs far less than a rushed re-roof.
A written scope that names what will be done
The scope is the written description of the work, and it is where most disputes start. A good one reads like a survey note: it names the parts of the roof, the covering and the fixings, so that you and the roofer would picture the same job. The table shows what it should settle.
| Question | What the paper should say |
|---|---|
| Where | Which slopes, ridge, verges, valleys, flashings and gutters are included |
| With what | The covering, underlay, battens and fixings, by type |
| What is left alone | Anything that is not part of this job, such as the chimney or an extension roof |
| Who clears up | Whether waste is taken away and the site left tidy |
| When | A start window, and what happens if the weather delays it |
The total should state whether VAT and scaffold sit inside it. Putting scaffold on the road calls for a licence under the Highways Act 1980 section 169, and each council sets its own fee, so ask the roofer to confirm that this is covered in the total. We arrange the licence with our scaffolder, and the quote records that.
If the scope says little more than "re-roof" or "repair roof", ask for it to be rewritten. A roofer who cannot say which slopes they will strip, or what will go back on, has not yet looked properly at the job.
Photographs of your own roof, before and after
Photographs are the lowest-cost protection you can ask for, and they cost a good roofer nothing. They should show your roof, not a similar one: the street behind it, your chimney and your colour of tile. Ask for pictures taken before the job begins, one set during the work if the covering is stripped, and one set at the end.
Here is what each set can show:
- Before: the slipped tiles, the cracked ridge bedding, the perished flashing or the lifted felt, close enough to read.
- During: the underlay and battens once the covering is off, which is the one chance to see the structure.
- After: the ridge, verge and valleys finished, and the site cleared.
A photograph shot from a ladder at the gutter line, or from a drone, spares anyone from walking on the roof. HSE is blunt about the risk on fragile roofs: "AC roofs are always fragile", and "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." A quote for a garage roof of corrugated sheet that says nothing at all about asbestos is a quote that has skipped a step.
Photographs also protect the roofer. When the pictures show a roof that was already tired before the work began, nobody argues later about what was there. Keep the files, and ask for them on a link or a memory stick if they do not arrive.
One total price, and how to read it
The price that matters is the total you will pay for the work as scoped. A day rate or an hourly rate is not a price, because it says nothing about how many days the job will take or what the materials come to. Ask for one written total, and ask what would change it. A fixed total with a sensible list of exclusions is easier to hold than a low figure with open-ended extras.
It also helps to know the published ranges. Which? surveyed 11 of its Trusted Traders in November 2025, and their prices, which include labour and materials but exclude VAT, put the job of replacing a few broken or missing tiles at £75 to £400 and a new ridge tile at £80 to £300. Replacing the whole roof of a three-bedroom house came out at £7,000 to £21,000. These are national ranges, not Hereford quotes, but a figure far outside them is a reason to ask what the job includes. Our answer on what a written roof quote should cover goes through the points to check.
Then look at how you are asked to pay. Any deposit is a matter for the written contract, so ask what an advance buys and get that in writing. Pay by a method that leaves a trail, such as a bank transfer or a card, and keep the receipt. Ask for the balance to be due after the work is finished and you have seen the final photographs.
Your rights if you sign at home
The law gives you more cover than the doorstep suggests, and for these points it reads the same in both England and Wales:
- Under the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, regulation 5, an agreement reached in your own home once the survey is done is off-premises, in both England and Wales.
- You then have 14 days to cancel. Regulation 30 says the period "ends at the end of 14 days after the day on which the contract is entered into."
- Should you want the work to begin within that window, regulation 36 requires you to ask, and for an off-premises contract the request goes on a durable medium, which in plain terms means in writing.
- No cancellation right exists where you specifically asked the trader to call for urgent repairs or maintenance (regulation 28(1)(e)). Citizens Advice says there is no cooling-off if "you invite the business into your home for urgent repairs or maintenance".
The Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49, asks that a service be performed with reasonable care and skill, again in both England and Wales. Since 6 April 2026 the old ADR Regulations have gone, and the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 308, requires the trader to tell you about any complaint arrangement that is available if you are dissatisfied.
Citizens Advice runs the consumer helpline on 0808 223 1133, with a Welsh-speaking adviser on 0808 223 1144. Its page on cancelling building work sets out the steps, and our answer on the 14-day right to cancel roof work gives the detail.
Rules that change with the side of the border
Some of the questions to put to a roofer have different answers in Hereford and in Monmouth, and a firm that works on both sides should know which applies. Ask the question and listen for a specific answer.
| Question | In England | In Wales |
|---|---|---|
| Does the re-roof need Building Regulations approval? | Planning Portal test: nothing normally to apply for while under 25 per cent of the building envelope and under 50 per cent of the roof is affected | The Welsh Government says that in most situations this work will need approval |
| Does a heavier covering matter? | The Planning Portal says 15 per cent or more brings approval in | The Welsh approved document says more than 15% |
| Who can be asked about bats? | Natural England licenses | Natural Resources Wales licenses |
A roofer who answers "it is all the same" for every one of these has not looked into it. Building control is done by the council or by a registered building control approver, and the roofer should be able to tell you which route applies to your address.
Finally, a membership logo on a van or a letterhead is a claim, not a proof. If a firm names a body, ask for the name and check the membership with that body yourself. The same goes for any promise a firm makes about how long the work will last: ask to see it on paper, with what it covers, before you rely on it. Our guide to choosing and checking a roofer in Herefordshire covers the rest of the checks.
