Nothing else on the house sits as high in the air as the chimney stack, so it takes the weather first. When a pot goes over or a corner of the stack comes away, the first call can be to the insurer, and the insurer's first question is about cause. Did a storm do this, or had the stack been wearing out for years?
That is a fair question, and a roofer does not answer it. Your policy, your insurer and, if it comes to a dispute, the Financial Ombudsman Service decide it. What a roofer can do is look at the stack, photograph what is there and describe it plainly, which gives the decision-makers something firm to read. No payout is promised by anyone here, and nothing below is advice on a particular policy.
The post follows the order of events: how the Ombudsman defines a storm, what a stack can show about its own condition, the photographs and reports that matter, safe first steps, and then the repair rules, which part company at the Welsh border. For the repair work itself, see our chimney repairs service.
How the Ombudsman sorts storm from wear
The Financial Ombudsman Service settles complaints about insurers, and it publishes how it approaches storm damage. On its storm damage page it says: "a storm usually involves violent winds, usually with rain, hail or snow." It adds that some storms arrive without high winds, so rain, hail or snow alone can be enough to qualify. It consults the Beaufort Scale of wind force, though it records that individual insurers sometimes name a minimum wind strength of their own.
Two further points from the same page bear on a chimney claim:
- To judge the state your property was in on the day, the Ombudsman's page says that it will "usually look at expert reports and photos".
- Where a policy exclusion is used to turn a claim down, the burden of showing that it applies sits with the insurer, and an inspection report is one way of doing so.
The page also says the Ombudsman expects the insurer to read the policy as a whole, not just the storm wording. A refusal that mentions only wear and tear therefore deserves a close reading against every part of the cover.
None of this says that a particular chimney claim will succeed. It describes what the Ombudsman weighs if a complaint reaches it. That is the reason the condition of the stack on the day, shown in dated photographs, counts for so much, and the reason that a stack with a long history of bad mortar and a stack hit by a gust can look very different in the pictures.
What a stack can show about itself
A stack tells a story to anyone who knows how to read it. The signs below can point towards sudden damage or towards long wear, and a surveyor weighs them together. None settles the matter alone, and the insurer decides.
| What you see | May point to | What to record |
|---|---|---|
| Pot or cowl on the lawn, clean break at the base | A sudden event | Where it landed, and the flaunching it came from |
| Fresh pale mortar crumbs below the stack | Recent movement | The bed joints above, close up |
| Open, eroded joints and soft, flaking bricks | Long-term weathering | The joints and brick faces, with a coin for scale |
| Lead flashing that has lifted or come out of the joint | Wind lift, or old lead that had already failed | The lead edge and the joint behind it |
| Damp stain on the chimney breast indoors | Water entering for some time | The stain, dated, with a pencil line round it |
It is tempting to read a lean in the stack as storm damage, but a stack that leans can have been moving for years. Our answer on what cracked flaunching means explains the mortar collar round the pots, which is a place where wear can first show.
We describe what is there and photograph it, from the ground and, when it is safe, from a platform. Whether it counts as a storm for your policy is the insurer's call, not ours. Where the pictures could be read either way, say so to the insurer rather than guessing.
Evidence worth gathering before anything moves
The best time to take photographs is before anyone tidies, sweeps or covers anything. Because the Ombudsman leans on photos and reports, your own pictures are the first piece of evidence in the file. Shoot from the garden, a window or the loft hatch, and keep off the roof.
A useful set of evidence runs like this:
- The whole elevation first, showing the stack in place against the house.
- Close shots of each fault from the ground, using the zoom on your phone.
- Anything that has fallen, photographed where it landed, with a tape or a coin beside it for scale.
- The loft side of the chimney breast and the ceilings below, for any damp.
- A note of when the weather changed, and what it was doing.
Keep the fallen pieces somewhere dry, since a surveyor may want to look at them. If you have earlier photographs of the house that show the chimney, such as a holiday snap or an estate agent's listing, keep those as well. A picture of the stack in good order before the weather is the kind of evidence about condition that the Ombudsman says it looks for.
Do not climb up for a closer picture. Wind and wet slates make a roof a bad place to stand, and a fall is a far worse outcome than a weaker photograph. A zoom lens or a pair of binoculars from the road will do most of the job.
Reports, repair prices and the excess
According to the Ombudsman, a surveyor's report is the normal route on the insurer's side. You can hold a roofer's report as well, provided it sticks to what was found: the position of the damage, the state of the mortar, brick and lead, and a photograph of each. At Horizon, a survey means photographs of the stack and the roof as they stand, shown to you on the day, and you may pass them on to your insurer. Whether a claim is paid is for the insurer to decide, and a roofer's pictures cannot promise it.
It also helps to know what a repair may cost, because a policy may carry an excess, which is the first part of any claim that you pay yourself. Your policy schedule states the figure. MyJobQuote's leadwork-replacement page for chimneys, last updated 22 September 2026, puts a lead flashing patch repair at around £200 and a full replacement at around £570. For removing a chimney breast, MyJobQuote gives around £2,500 (3 November 2026). These are national figures, not quotes for your house.
A repair total well below the excess may not be worth claiming for, while a larger one is worth reporting to the insurer in any case. Either way, ask for one written total for the work, and speak to the insurer before you commission anything permanent.
If the stack is dangerous, say so in your first call and ask what the insurer wants done first. Your policy documents may list an emergency helpline. A make-safe visit leaves the evidence of cause in place, and we keep the fallen pieces dry so you can show them to the surveyor.
Safe first steps when a stack has been hit
Safety comes before paperwork. A loose pot or a cracked stack can drop masonry at any moment, particularly in wind, so keep people and pets away from the ground below it. Do not park under it either, and close off the garden path beneath until the stack has been looked at by someone on a scaffold or a platform.
As general good practice, the order that tends to work is:
- Clear everyone from the drop zone below the stack.
- Ring the insurer before agreeing anything permanent, and ask what evidence it wants.
- Have the stack made safe if it is loose, with a temporary measure such as taking off the loose pot or capping the opening.
- If rain is entering, protect the room below with sheeting and bowls, and switch off any circuit near the wet area at the consumer unit.
- File the photographs and the make-safe receipts together.
A make-safe is not the repair. It keeps the weather out and the masonry off the lawn while the proper job is agreed. Our answer on whether a loose chimney pot is dangerous explains why a pot that moves needs attention soon.
Treat these steps as general advice for any roof claim. Your policy may set its own conditions, including a time limit for reporting damage, so read it or ring the helpline early, and keep a note of whom you spoke to and when.
Repair rules in England and Wales
When the claim is settled, the repair has to follow whichever rules apply where the house stands. They differ in small ways that matter for a chimney.
- In England, the Planning Portal's line is that Building Regulations approval is always involved when a chimney breast comes out. In England, GPDO 2015 Class C leaves out the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney, so rebuilding a stack is a question for the council.
- In Wales, GPDO 1995 Class C.1(c) also excludes any new, altered or replacement chimney, and adds that taking a chimney off a house on article 1(5) land, or on a World Heritage Site, falls outside Class C.
- In England, consent is required for any work to a listed house that touches what makes it special (Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, section 7). In Wales, sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 apply.
- In both England and Wales, a shared chimney breast on a party wall means the building owner must give the neighbour written notice, at least two months ahead of any cutting.
Our answer on whether rebuilding a stack needs planning gives the English and Welsh position in more detail.
If your insurer refuses and you disagree, take the complaint to the insurer in the first instance. The Financial Ombudsman Service is on 0800 023 4567. You can refer a complaint to it if eight weeks pass with no final response, and you then have six months from the date on a final response. Its how to complain page sets out the steps.
